Co-authors Daniel Fischlin, Ajay Heble, and George Lipsitz ably demonstrate the ways in which improvisatory practices are informed by, and, more importantly, embody and instantiate, the claims and possibilities contained within human rights discourse. Acknowledging that the two are conventionally viewed as incommensurable fields of activity, the authors present a richly detailed and convincingly argued study of the myriad ways in which creative musicians have long tethered their musicking to social-justice imperatives, programs, and organizations. As these authors argue, these artists’ “harmonious balance between individual solos and collective improvisation provides a metaphorical solution to one of the recurrent dilemmas of social life in the United States: how to encourage individuality without selfishness and how to encourage collective consciousness without totalitarianism” (Lipsitz, Footsteps in the Dark (2007), quoted at xxiii). Moreover, the authors’ agenda is to
draw wider connections than are usually made between the symbolic force of music in a rights and social justice context, and to point to an emergent shared language associated with improvising musicians of the free jazz movement that brought together in the 1960s crucial concepts of freedom, community, agency, and self-identity as a function of cocreative improvisatory utterances. (30)
The authors begin by showing how improvisation is a social practice, particularly in “recasting the identities and histories of aggrieved populations and in promoting self-representational counternarratives that enable an enlargement of the base of valued knowledges” (34–35). These valued knowledges, moreover, encourage “real-time creative decision-making, risk-taking, and collaboration” realized in improvisatory musicking and, more significantly for their argument, serving as models for the development of new ways of theorizing, organizing, and manifesting alternatives for aggrieved communities (36). Detailing the ways in which various musical collectives such as the Art Ensemble of Chicago (AEC) and the Association for the Advancement of Creative Musicians (AACM) believed not only that their improvisatory musicking “can teach us to enact the possibilities we envision” but also that these collectives enacted and embodied those possibilities in the way they organized themselves, the links between improvisatory musical practices and human rights discourse and activities are made abundantly evident (37).
The authors do not ignore the listener and provide important insights into the ways that the agency of the musician and the listener are bound together in the improvisational moment, affectively linking artist and audient in the enactment of contingent and exploratory musicking. This insight raises the question of the “ethics of encounter,” as the authors describe it, and their argument that the simultaneous rise of free jazz and the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR) underlines the connection between improvisatory musicking and human rights as an encounter between discrepant yet empathetic agents. As they state in the Coda, “listening is a crucial form of agency that generates ethical and artistic imperatives, like those generated in an improvisation founded on the capacity to hear the other in ways that change one's own contribution to the collective narrative,” clearly elucidating the responsibilities on either side of the stage (232).
The authors also trouble the conception of “human rights,” particularly as they have been conceived in terms that have historically excluded members of aggrieved communities. Free jazz artists have challenged that exclusion by providing “a significant testing ground for models of encounter that span individual voice and agency, cultural differences and similitudes … and how to sustain discourse (or not) in the face of the multiple agencies and contingencies that come together as embodied public, performative practice” (89).
I have only scratched the surface of the rich set of arguments, insights, and analyses that run throughout this text. As they write near the end of their Coda,
Both hope and improvisation tend toward, invite, invoke, and imagine the event-horizon of the possible. As such they address the ethics of creation and cocreation that are an underlying aspect of both musical aesthetics as an outcome of improvisatory agencies and of imagining and exercising rights imperatives as an expression of core aspects of human being. (243)
As we enter the second half of the second decade of the twenty-first century, with its set of environmental, economic, and political crises threatening to bring an end to all human creativity, the fierce urgency of now is no longer simply rhetorical (if, indeed, it ever was), but implores us to “give agency to [our] hopes” while listening to others in a cocreative exploration of life-affirming possibilities.
