Roy Armes is a leading English film-studies critic and historian of Arab cinema. His newest book focuses on the history, political economy, and narrative themes and styles of the films and filmmakers of the former French colonies of Tunisia, Algeria, and Morocco. Covering the end of the colonial period to the present, the work builds on and synthesizes arguments in such earlier books as Third World Film Making and The West (1978), Arab and African Film Making (with Lizbeth Malkums, 1991), Dictionary of North African Film Makers (1996), and Omar Gatlatu (1998). It offers an introductory survey and postcolonial analysis of selected themes, narratives, and representations of North African cinema since 1965.
The author's major theoretical objectives are to provide a concise introduction to North African cinema; analyze the historical context of the film industry and why it flourished in the 1960s and 1970s and then declined and collapsed, especially in Algeria; and apply critical theories to exploring how North African cinema reflects the tensions of colonialism, empire, gender, sexuality, nationalism, individualism, and filmmakers' culture either in North Africa or in exile—particularly in France, where many of the directors now reside. Armes's thesis is based on theoretical arguments by Edward Said, Fatima Mernissi, and Hamid Naficy. Like Said, Armes argues there is a link between the modern European novel and colonial empires and that film has similar functions and linkages.
Colonial cinema, whether French or American, is silent on the issue of colonialism and imperialism. Similarly, Armes observes, North African nationalist cinema often reproduces colonial ideology, especially because many filmmakers were Westernized intellectuals trained in European, mostly French, cinema and, above all, financed by French grants and coproduction. Armes also seems to accept the Orientalist concepts of veil and harem and the views of the feminist sociologist Mernissi concerning the gender gap between veiled and segregated women. He does, however, engage the arguments of film critic Naficy about “accented cinema.” Armes contends that North African immigrant cinema in France is not “accented” because it has been co-opted; the largest market for these films is in French and international festivals, so the films mostly deal with integration and assimilation rather than critiques of colonial conditions.
Postcolonial Images is divided into three sections: histories, themes and styles of ten brilliant examples of filmmaking, and a dictionary of 139 filmmakers and their films produced since 1965. The section on histories is basically a chronological survey of the film industry. Dominant themes range from national identity on the eve of independence from France (Tunisia and Morocco in 1956, Algeria in 1962), socialism and social concerns in the 1970s, alienation and the decade of the individual in the 1980s, and, finally, exiled or immigrant cinema in 1990s, especially after the crisis of Algerian socialism and later the bloody civil war. By the 1990s, thirteen filmmakers in Europe (Merzak Allouche, Mohamed Rachid Benhadj, Mohamed Zemmouri, and others) had directed twenty films.
Since then, however, film production in the region has been in a state of continual decline. In 2002 only five films were made in Algeria. Tunisian and Moroccan film production increased slightly due to modest state subsidies and European co-production, but even the Egyptian cinema, the hegemonic film industry in the region, declined after the early 1990s to only fifteen films per year. Contributing factors certainly include the spread of cable and satellite television in the 1990s. The number of cinema houses in North Africa is half the number that existed in 1955. In addressing this phenomenon, Armes's book, although well rooted in English and French sources, lacks analytical cohesion. As a unit of analysis, his choice of a decade is arbitrary, especially when the reader turns to the second section of the book, when a new unit of analysis is introduced without justification.
The second section is the most analytical because it deals not only with content but also the artistic, stylistic, and narrative structure of the films. Armes presents an excellent thematic and narrative review of ten outstanding films: El Chargui (Moumen Smihi, 1975), Chronicle of the Years of Embers (Mohamed Lakhdar Hamina, 1975), Omar Gatlatu (Merzak Allouche, 1976), La Nouba (Assia Djebar, 1978), Miss Mona (Mehdi Charef, 1987), Golden Horseshoes (Nouri Bouzid, 1989), Halfouine (Ferid Boughedir, 1990), Looking for My Wife's Husband (Mohamed Abderrhman Tazi, 1993), Silence of the Palaces (Moufida Tlatli, 1994), and Ali Zoaua (Nabil Ayouch, 1999). The author analyzes these films in terms of myth and history (Hamina), gendered nationalism (Taltli), sexuality and autobiography (Boughedir), or machismo and the use of first-voice-over narration (Allouche).
This reviewer found his interpretation of Silence of the Palaces and Golden Horseshoes refreshing and illuminating. Yet even in this rewarding section, Armes limits his reading by uncritically accepting Mernissi's sweeping essentialist model when he interprets the gender relations in Omar Gatlatu as merely a case of male/female segregation at the expense of working-class alienation in a failed nationalist state. He credits Halfouine as the first film to break the taboo of nudity in Arabic cinema, overlooking the history of Egyptian cinema. Although Armes cites Marnia Lazreg's scholarship, he ignores her excellent and complex analysis of gender, culture, and class in The Eloquence of Silence (Routledge, 1994). Even in his insightful and original reading of Golden Horseshoes, Armes limits himself by resorting to the sweeping concept of “Islamic fundamentalism.” Here he ignores the specific historical bases of the Tunisian Islamic opposition to the dictatorship of a francophone, secular, one-party state dominated by the elite from the Sahel region and the city of Tunis, factors that make it different from Algerian, Moroccan, and Libyan opposition movements.
The third section of the book provides an impressive reference source for North African films and short biographies of thirty-nine filmmakers. Armes covers all the English and French sources but misses important Arabic sources, especially the scholarship of Ibrahim al-Ariss, Samir Farid, and film historian Jan al-Kssan. I wish the author had covered Libyan and Mauritanian cinemas despite their marginality. Armes's work reflects the common focus in scholarship on francophone Tunisia, Algeria, and Morocco—the modern Maghrib—a colonial construction accepted uncritically by North African elites and followed in colonial French scholarship. It is ironic, too, that a postcolonial film critic like Armes glances over the uses and history of the name “Maghrib.” Another minor omission is the lack of in-depth analysis of the impact of Egyptian cinema on the Maghrib, which deserves more attention.
Despite these reservations, Armes's well-researched book provides the reader with a major text on a neglected, important, and vibrant cinema. The book is definitely useful for both undergraduate and graduate courses.
