What changes audience behavior, and how do historians track those changes? How do we identify the point at which one behavior replaces another as acceptable? Jennifer Hall-Witt's book Fashionable Acts: Opera and Elite Culture in London, 1780–1880 deals with such topics. Audiences are untidy: in a broad perspective, they do not usually exhibit a single behavior and then change it all at once, en masse. Because opera is a more conservative institution than theatre, the behavior its audiences exhibit is a more complex palimpsest of previous customs, some nearly totally erased, others more fully legible. Even today, who decides whether to applaud each number, as eighteenth-century castrati and prima donnas expected, or wait until the end of an act? Although families no longer rent the same box for generations, the urge to communicate with friends across the house remains familiar, and cell phones make it easy. When the Prince of Wales who grew up to be George IV buzzed around the King's Theatre, Haymarket, opera house like a royal bumblebee (Morning Post, 30 January 1786), he was doing that partly because he was young and drunk, but also because visiting during the performance was what noblemen of his generation expected to do. Queen Victoria, well versed in music and actively promoting a different set of manners, would never have behaved that way; nor would she have kept ballet girls (or boys). (The Prince of Wales preferred actresses.) Behavior patterns clearly changed between the eras under consideration in this book, but how does one go about saying when, much less why?
Jennifer Hall-Witt divides her study into two “acts,” the first concerned with Georgian patterns, the second with Victorian adaptations. Each act is preceded by an “overture,” and the book ends with a “finale.” The period labels are slightly arbitrary, because as Hall-Witt demonstrates, many of the changes discussed were well under way before 1837; the young queen endorsed rather than initiated them. At the beginning of the period, audiences viewed opera as a collaborative “event” in which they were principal participants with direct influence on many aspects of the enterprise. Well before the end of the period, they viewed opera more narrowly as a predefined “work” to which they chose to come listen—knowledgeably, respectfully, even reverently. This large shift is worth consideration, though just how it relates to politics is difficult to say.
The first act begins with “Opera as an ‘Event’: The Aesthetics of Audience Behavior,” showing how the opera functioned as a club to which the tiny hereditary upper class belonged. Opera as an “event” served them, because seeing one another was central to their evenings. The “subscription culture” explicated in Chapter 2 was controlled by the wives of leaders of society, who worked collectively to take up the desirable boxes. (Actual machinations are hard to document, but Hall-Witt later shows that a large percentage of elite families continued to hold boxes, and sometimes the same boxes, decade after decade.) The point of operagoing before the turn of the century was, according to Chapter 3, “To See and to Be Seen,” and Hall-Witt labels opera the “Theater of the Great.”
However, the economic pressures of the Napoleonic Wars led to “The Commercialization of the Opera: Entrepreneurs and the Expansion of the Public” (Chapter 4). Opera in England was not subsidized, so managers were under constant pressure to encourage the nouveaux riches emboldened by the growth of the British Empire and the productivity of the Industrial Revolution to enter the formerly exclusive club, against the wishes of the members. (Contrary to Hall-Witt's thesis, this pressure is documentable well before either revolution. See, for example, the mock-epic poem called The Opera Rumpus [1783], on the contretemps between the Countess of Jersey and Mr. and Mrs. Broadhead, whose money came from trade, over possession of a prime opera box.) Means of reducing clubbiness included changes in the layout of the house, so that the number of boxes increased while most of them shrank in size, thus breaking up large parties. The pit also shrank, helping to control the circulation of unattached males, who were eventually also prohibited from going backstage. The number of subscribers, never high enough to support the business, shrank, and blocks of tickets were increasingly handled by booksellers, from whom anyone could buy. Audiences thus paid more attention to the “work” when the factors that made up the “event” were diluted.
One of Hall-Witt's chief concerns is “The Refashioning of Fashionable Society: Gender and the Transformation of Operatic Culture” (Chapter 5). Male elite culture was shifting from indulgence to service (military, diplomatic, philanthropic), to answer by peaceful means the revolutionary question of why the elite should continue to exist. Although women lost many of their individual powers of exclusion, they began a reform that emphasized good manners and displayed more attention to the “work,” thus discouraging the non-stage-oriented behaviors that had previously made up the “event.” The opera continued to do cultural work, divided more completely along gender lines according to Hall-Witt, but did it differently. The upper classes in the 1840s and onward aspired to be models of decorum. The most particular evidence for the shift comes in Chapter 6, “Listening in New Ways: Audience Behavior and the Cultural Politics of Opera Reviewing.” Here Hall-Witt analyzes the social, political, and musical biases of a number of prolific critics who campaigned for a work-focused repertory and concomitant audience response. The finale reprises the story already told.
I wish the author had used more space to discuss methodological approaches and evidentiary problems, rather than summarizing in each chapter and each section the conclusions of the last. Finding a balance among the musicological, managerial, and sociopolitical strands of this tale is difficult, and Hall-Witt does not always succeed in keeping all elements in mind at once. The mere fact that, for a few years at midcentury, two opera houses were possible demonstrates an increased appetite for the form, but in the long run London could support only one company. Is that fact not as worthy of explanation as the shift from event to work?
This kind of study always faces the problem of infinite regress, since earlier examples that crop up need explaining. Contrary evidence should be confronted, not hidden away. To take a small example, Queen Victoria was a model of decorum at the opera as elsewhere and a great lover of music, but she was also known to come late and leave early (253), like an eighteenth-century gentleman. She was, one gathers, less of a model in respect of this inevitably disruptive behavior than in her attention to music, but why? I must also point out that the subtitle of the book is misleading: statistics go to 1880, but discussion of evidence does not extend much past 1856. At a more mechanical level, some of the information in tables is wrong, with consequences for arguments based on them. For instance, J. J. Heidegger leased the King's Theatre to the Royal Academy of Music but was not in any executive sense “manager” of that company (290); R. B. O'Reilly was a law clerk, not a lawyer (295). Lack of a bibliography is a great defect when so many sources are in play, though that may be the fault of the publisher. Fashionable Acts attempts to connect social issues to political ones and succeeds on some particular points, though I remain unconvinced that audience members' allegiance or resistance to the Reform Bill of 1832 had much in the way of direct effects on the opera in London.
