It is pedantic to state that most of us have at least seen or used a statistical graph. Some of us regularly produce graphs or charts as part of our work. Graphs are a means of conveying statistical information and are almost universally used throughout different professions and academic disciplines. They are ubiquitous across a range of communication media: in print, film, or digital. They are used by investors, store owners, homeowners, politicians, news readers, and many other non-specialists to quickly understand statistical relationships. They can tell a story as much as they show the results of sophisticated analysis. And yet most people don’t usually think about when was it that modern societies started using statistical graphics. They almost never think about the person who may have invented or popularized their use. They most probably would never have heard of William Playfair.
Playfair was of Scottish descent and spent most of his adult life in England and Revolutionary France in the late eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries. He was an innovative printer, a prolific writer, a failed financier, banker, and entrepreneur, and at times an astute political commentator. According to David Bellhouse, he was a genius, although he was deeply flawed. He concocted elaborate schemes to make money, hobnobbed with political nobility in both England and France, tried to blackmail people, was in and out of prison several times, and was constantly in need of money to provide for his family. He had business dealings with James Watts and Matthew Boulton, the giants of the British Industrial Revolution. Equally he was entangled with some questionable people in France and the United States to cheat French émigrés of their money. His name was associated with the forging of assignats, which were monetary instruments used as currency during the French Revolution. He was a critic of Adam Smith and other writers of economic literature in the period. But his most important legacy is that he developed the process for creating and mass-printing statistical graphics that are key to how economic and statistical ideas are communicated in the modern world.
Bellhouse’s book is a compelling biography of the colorful life of William Playfair. It is rich in historical detail, which is painstakingly recreated using a constellation of contemporary sources. It is extraordinarily detailed, almost as if Bellhouse had Playfair’s daily journal or diary at hand. The fact that Playfair left no such memoirs and that Bellhouse has trawled through a rich archive of publications, correspondence, court records, and other source material makes this biography a remarkable record of Playfair’s life. A few other biographies of Playfair exist but none so detailed and comprehensive. Bellhouse does not pull any punches when describing the dubious schemes and shady alliances that Playfair was involved in. Nonetheless, he carefully considers Playfair’s culpability in relation to that of other people involved in the schemes: Playfair almost never acted on his own. On the whole, Bellhouse manages to present Playfair as a commercially inept, personally flawed, but a highly perceptive individual who has left an indelible mark on the disciplines of both economics and statistics.
The Flawed Genius of William Playfair is mostly a chronological account of Playfair’s life in twenty short, focused chapters. Each chapter is broadly associated with an important phase in Playfair’s career, or a decision he made (such as moving to France), or a calamity or dilemma he faced (such as being imprisoned). The first few chapters (2 to 6) chronicle Playfair’s early career in the English Midlands, which is when he developed the printing processes for reproducing detailed color graphics of statistical relationships. Subsequent chapters describe his shenanigans in France as an anti-Jacobin, as a failed banker back in England, as a bankrupt banker hoping to compete with the Bank of England, as a schemer trying to get back to Paris, and so on. Throughout the book, Bellhouse manages to weave Playfair’s literary and intellectual contributions, to statistical graphics as well as to contemporary economic thought, alongside the many questionable schemes he hatched.
There are over forty color illustrations in The Flawed Genius, several of them reproductions of Playfair’s original graphics from his many publications. They are interspersed with many more quotations from contemporary sources, often correspondence and other material produced by people whom Playfair encountered. The historical reconstruction is quite detailed. Where Bellhouse’s conclusions are at odds with other biographies or writings about Playfair, this is mentioned explicitly. Bellhouse’s book does not appear to be an attempt to resurrect Playfair’s image: he was a complicated person with many flaws, both personal and professional. And Bellhouse states this clearly. Indeed, the book is a thorough biography that considers Playfair’s legacy, warts-and-all.
Although The Flawed Genius is compelling as a biography, the book is partially useful as a history of thought or ideas. Bellhouse has contextualized Playfair’s many publications, writings, and his pioneering use of graphical statistics within their immediate historical contexts. However, it does not appear to be Bellhouse’s intention to place these contributions within the rich histories of ideas, histories of economic thought, or histories of statistics and quantification. He has implicitly left that to the readers. For example, how should we consider Playfair’s legacy of statistical graphics in the context of William Petty’s legacy of “political arithmetic” from around the same time? Or to what extent did Playfair influence (or not) the early Victorian “statistical movement” after the 1830s, shortly after his death? Bellhouse mentions that late nineteenth-century economists such as William Stanley Jevons and Francis Edgeworth acknowledged Playfair’s contributions. But as readers, we are mostly left to consider the significance of his life’s work on our own terms. Playfair’s historical legacy as a statistician and economist, as a failed entrepreneur, a political meddler, and an anti-Jacobin remains incompletely examined, and this book is a step in the direction to remedy that.
