Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-wxvwp Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T10:39:10.766Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Evolution of the rotating Rayleigh–Taylor instability under the influence of magnetic fields

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  23 April 2025

Narinder Singh
Affiliation:
Department of Mechanical Engineering, Indian Institute of Technology Kanpur, Kanpur 208016, U.P., IndiaDepartment of Mechanical Engineering and Program in Integrated Applied Mathematics, University of New Hampshire, Durham, NH 03824, USA
Anikesh Pal*
Affiliation:
Department of Mechanical Engineering, Indian Institute of Technology Kanpur, Kanpur 208016, U.P., India
*
Corresponding author: Anikesh Pal, pala@iitk.ac.in

Abstract

The combined effects of the imposed vertical mean magnetic field ($B_0$, scaled as the Alfvèn velocity) and rotation on the heat transfer phenomenon driven by the Rayleigh–Taylor (RT) instability are investigated using direct numerical simulations. In the hydrodynamic (HD) case, as the strength of the Coriolis frequency ($f$) increases, the Coriolis force enhances the mixing of fluids that dampens the growth of the mixing layer height ($h$) and reversible exchanges between the fluids, leading to a reduction in the heat transport, characterised by the Nusselt number ($Nu$). In non-rotating magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) cases, we find a significant delay in the onset of RT instability with increasing $B_0$, consistent with the linear theory in the literature. The imposed $B_0$ forms vertically elongated thermal plumes that exhibit a larger reversible buoyancy flux due to limited mixing, enabling them to transport heat efficiently between the bottom hot fluid and the upper cold fluid. This leads to enhanced heat transfer in the initial regime of unbroken elongated plumes in non-rotating MHD cases compared to the corresponding HD case. In the turbulent regime of broken small-scale structures, the imposed $B_0$ collimates the flow along the vertical magnetic field lines, reducing vertical velocity fluctuations ($u_3^{\prime }$) and increasing the growth of $h$. The increased $h$ primarily drives the heat transfer enhancement in the turbulent regime of non-rotating MHD over the corresponding HD case. When rotation is added along with the imposed $B_0$, the growth and breakdown of vertically elongated plumes are inhibited by the instability-damping effect of the Coriolis force. Consequently, heat transfer is also reduced in the rotating MHD cases compared to the corresponding non-rotating MHD cases. Interestingly, heat transport in rotating MHD cases is enhanced compared to the corresponding rotating HD cases because $B_0$ reduces mixing and mitigates the instability-damping effect of the Coriolis force. The presence of the ultimate state regime $Nu\simeq Ra^{1/2}Pr^{1/2}$, where $Ra$ is the Rayleigh number and $Pr$ is the Prandtl number, is observed in the non-rotating HD and MHD cases. However, the rotating HD and MHD cases depart from this ultimate state scaling. Furthermore, the dynamic balance between different forces is analysed to understand the behaviour of the thermal plumes. The turbulent kinetic energy budget reveals the conversion of the turbulent kinetic energy, generated by the buoyancy flux, into turbulent magnetic energy.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2025. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.Sketch of the computational domain of RT configuration for electrically conducting miscible fluids, where the colder fluid of temperature $T=-1$ is placed above the hotter fluid of temperature $T=+1$ under gravity $g$. This configuration is rotated about the vertical axis $x_3$ with uniform Coriolis’s frequency $f$, and the uniform mean magnetic field $B_0$ is imposed normal to the interface between the colder and hotter fluid (or anti-parallel to $g$).

Figure 1

Figure 2.Comparison between present simulations and results obtained by Boffetta et al. (2010b) for (a) a temporal evolution of the mixing layer of height $h$ and (b) a spatially averaged Nusselt number ($Nu$) and Reynolds number ($Re$) as a function of the Rayleigh number ($Ra$). These non-dimensional numbers are defined in (2.8). Dashed grey lines represent the ultimate state predictions, i.e. $Nu \simeq Ra^{1/2}Pr^{1/2}$ and $Re \simeq Ra^{1/2}Pr^{-1/2}$ scaling for $Pr=1$ (Boffetta et al.2010b).

Figure 2

Figure 3.(a) Grid clustering at the vertical centre region for resolving all the length scales in the mixing layer shown in the vertical $x_2-x_3$ centre plane ($x_1=0$). (b) Temporal evolution of the maximum vertical grid spacing ${\rm d}x_3$ normalised with the Kolmogorov length scale $\eta =(\nu ^3/\epsilon _v)^{1/4}$ for non-rotation and rotation cases with $B_0=0,0.1,0.15\,\mathrm {ms^{-1}}$. Here $\nu$ is the kinematic viscosity and $\epsilon _v$ is the horizontally averaged viscous dissipation rate (defined later in (3.8)).

Figure 3

Table 1.Simulation parameters: for all cases, we use $\mathcal {A}g=\beta \theta _0 g/2=1.0\:\mathrm {m\:s^{-2}}$, $g=9.81\:\mathrm {m\:s^{-2}}$, $\theta _0=2$, kinematic viscosity $\nu$, thermal diffusivity $\kappa$ and magnetic diffusivity $\mathcal {D}$ respectively are $\nu =\kappa =\mathcal {D}=3\times 10^{-4}\:\mathrm {m^2\:s^{-1}}$, such that the Prandtl number $Pr=\nu / \kappa =1$ and the magnetic Prandtl number $Pr_m=\nu /\mathcal {D}=1$.

Figure 4

Figure 4.Instantaneous temperature contours in the vertical $x_2{-}x_3$ centre plane ($x_1=0$) for (a) the non-rotating HD case B$_0$0f0 (first leftmost column), (b) the rotating HD case B$_0$0f8 (second column), (c) the non-rotating MHD case B$_0$0.15f0 (third column), and (d) the rotating MHD case B$_0$0.15f8 (fourth column) at different time instants. The blue colour represents cold fluid ($T=-1$), and the red colour represents hot fluid ($T=1$).

Figure 5

Figure 5.Temporal evolution of the mixing layer height $h$ for non-rotating and rotating (a) HD cases, (b) HD and MHD at $B_0=0.1\,\mathrm {ms^{-1}}$ cases, (c) HD and MHD at $B_0=0.15\,\mathrm {ms^{-1}}$ cases, and (d) HD and MHD at $B_0=0.3\,\mathrm {ms^{-1}}$ cases. Insets in (a) and (b) correspond to the onset of RT instability.

Figure 6

Figure 6.Vertical variation of the squared r.m.s. vertical velocity $u_{3,r.m.s.}$ normalised by the squared mean vertical magnetic field $B_0$, scaled as the Alfvèn velocity, for the non-rotating MHD cases (a) B$_0$0.15f0 and (b) B$_0$0.3f0 at different time instants.

Figure 7

Figure 7.Temporal evolution of (a) the mixing parameter $\Theta$ (defined in (3.1)) and (b) the growth rate $\alpha$ (defined in (3.2)) for non-rotating and rotating HD and MHD (with $B_0=0.1, 0.15\,\mathrm {ms^{-1}}$) cases.

Figure 8

Figure 8.Temporal evolution of the Nusselt number ($Nu$, defined in (2.8)) for non-rotating and rotating (a) HD cases, (b) HD and MHD for $B_0=0.1\,\mathrm {ms^{-1}}$ cases, (c) HD and MHD for $B_0=0.15\,\mathrm {ms^{-1}}$ cases, and (d) HD and MHD for $B_0=0.3\,\mathrm {ms^{-1}}$ cases.

Figure 9

Figure 9.Variation of the Nusselt number, $Nu$ (defined in (2.8)), as a function of the Rayleigh number, $Ra$ ($\propto h^3$), for the HD and MHD (a) non-rotating ($f=0$), (b) rotating at $f=4\,\mathrm {s^{-1}}$, and (c) rotating at $f=8\,\mathrm {s^{-1}}$ cases. Dashed orange lines represent the ultimate state predictions, i.e. $Nu \propto Ra^{1/2}$ scaling for $Pr=1$ (Boffetta et al.2010b,2016).

Figure 10

Figure 10.Vertical profiles of the horizontal ($x_1$) and vertical ($x_3$) components of horizontally averaged turbulent kinetic energy (denoted by $\mathcal {K}_{x_1}$ and $\mathcal {K}_{x_3}$, respectively), normalised by the released potential energy $|E^\prime _p|$ (defined in (3.4)), for the HD cases B$_0$0f0 and B$_0$0f8, and MHD cases B$_0$0.15f0 and B$_0$0.15f8 at time (a) $t\simeq 6.5$ s and (b) $t\simeq 8.5$ s. Solid lines denote $\mathcal {K}_{x_3}/|E^\prime _p|$, while dashed lines denote $\mathcal {K}_{x_1}/|E^\prime _p|$.

Figure 11

Figure 11.Instantaneous vertical profiles of the horizontally averaged r.m.s. of each term (force) present in the vertical and horizontal component of the momentum equation (2.1b). Horizontal forces, $F_{x_1x_2,\textit{r.m.s.}}=\sqrt {F_{x_1,\textit{r.m.s.}}^2+F_{x_2,\textit{r.m.s.}}^2}$, are shown with dashed lines, whereas the vertical forces, $F_{x_3,\textit{r.m.s.}}$, are indicated with solid lines for (a) the non-rotating MHD case B$_0$0.15f0 at $t\simeq 6.46$ s, $7.51$ s, (b) the rotating MHD case B$_0$0.15f4 at $t\simeq 6.6$ s, $7.55$ s, and (a) the rotating MHD case B$_0$0.15f8 at $t\simeq 6.58$ s, $7.51$ s.

Figure 12

Figure 12.Instantaneous vertical profiles of the resultant $\textit{r.m.s.}$ values of each force $(F_{\textit{r.m.s.}}=\sqrt {F_{x_1,\textit{r.m.s.}}^2+F_{x_2,\textit{r.m.s.}}^2+F_{x_3,\textit{r.m.s.}}^2})$ in momentum equation (2.1b) for the rotating (a) HD case B$_0$0f4 at $t\simeq 6.62$ s, $7.52$ s, (b) HD case B$_0$0f8 at $t\simeq 6.73$ s, $7.63$ s, and (c) MHD case B$_0$0.15f8 at $t\simeq 6.58$ s, $7.51$ s. Solid lines of different colours represent the resultant r.m.s. values of the corresponding force. The dashed blue line denotes the horizontal Coriolis force.

Figure 13

Figure 13.Temporal evolution of vertically ($x_3$) integrated turbulent kinetic energy ($\mathcal {K}$) budget terms of (3.6) for the (a) non-rotating HD case B$_0$0f0, (b) non-rotating MHD case B$_0$0.1f0, (c) rotating MHD case B$_0$0.1f8, and (d) non-rotating MHD case B$_0$0.15f0.

Figure 14

Figure 14.Time evolution of the turbulent magnetic to kinetic energy ratio $R=\mathcal {M}/\mathcal {K}$ for the non-rotating and rotating MHD cases with $B_0=0.1$ and $0.15\,\mathrm {ms^{-1}}$.

Figure 15

Table 2.Results from the present simulations and those of Stellmach & Hansen (2004) for RC simulations with $Ra = {g \beta \Delta T d^3}/{\kappa \nu }=1.4\times 10^7$, $E= {\nu }/{\Omega d^2}=5 \times 10^{-5}$ and $Pr ={\nu }/{\kappa }=1$, as well as for the DC simulations with $Pr_m={\nu }/{\mathcal {D}}=2.5$. Here $d$ is the distance between parallel plates, $\Delta T$ is the temperature difference between the lower (hot) and the upper (cold) plate and $\Omega$ is the angular velocity of rotation. Results are described by the following non-dimensional numbers: magnetic Reynolds number $Re_m=u_{r.m.s.} d/\mathcal {D}$, Reynolds number $Re=Re_m/Pr_m$, Nusselt number $Nu=1+\sqrt {Ra Pr} \langle u_3 \theta \rangle _{\mathcal {V}}$, Elsasser number $\Lambda =\sigma {B_{r.m.s.}}^2/\rho \Omega$ and magnetic to kinetic energy ratio $ER$, where $u_{r.m.s.}$ is the characteristic ($\textit{r.m.s.}$) velocity, $\theta$ is the non-dimensional temperature, $\sigma$ is the electrical conductivity, $B_{r.m.s.}$ is the characteristics magnetic field strength and $\langle \cdot \rangle _{\mathcal {V}}$ denotes average over the entire volume ($\mathcal {V}$). Here $Re_0$ and $Nu_0$ represent the results of non-magnetic RC simulation, whereas $Re_m$, $Re$, $\Lambda$ and $ER$ represent the results of DC simulation.

Supplementary material: File

Singh and Pal supplementary material movie 1

The evolution of the temperature field in the vertical x2 - x3 center plane (x1 = 0) for the non-rotating HD case B00f0.
Download Singh and Pal supplementary material movie 1(File)
File 5.6 MB
Supplementary material: File

Singh and Pal supplementary material movie 2

The evolution of the temperature field in the vertical x2 - x3 center plane (x1 = 0) for the rotating HD case B00f8.
Download Singh and Pal supplementary material movie 2(File)
File 2.3 MB
Supplementary material: File

Singh and Pal supplementary material movie 3

The evolution of the temperature field in the vertical x2 - x3 center plane (x1 = 0) for the non-rotating MHD case B00.15f0.
Download Singh and Pal supplementary material movie 3(File)
File 3.8 MB
Supplementary material: File

Singh and Pal supplementary material movie 4

The evolution of the temperature field in the vertical x2 - x3 center plane (x1 = 0) for the rotating MHD case B00.15f8.
Download Singh and Pal supplementary material movie 4(File)
File 2.9 MB
Supplementary material: File

Singh and Pal supplementary material movie 5

The evolution of the temperature field in the vertical x2 - x3 center plane (x1 = 0) for the non-rotating MHD case B00.3f0.
Download Singh and Pal supplementary material movie 5(File)
File 2 MB