World War I was fought on the home front through food. United States's entry into the war meant an immediate mobilization of the food supply, as vital foodstuffs were diverted to troops and starving European civilians. Rae Katherine Eighmey tells this story as it unfolded in Minnesota, as farmers and city dwellers conserved wheat and meat, planted victory gardens and raised more chickens, shared wartime recipes, and sent wheatless cookies to their boys in service. As a farming state, Minnesota had a unique capacity to increase production of scarce commodities like wheat, potatoes, and hogs. Rural and urban women alike substituted eggs, corn meal, and sorghum for meat, wheat, and sugar.
Eighmey makes good use of primary source material in the Minnesota Historical Society, the state archives, the University of Minnesota Agricultural Extension, and the state branches of the Food Administration and Commission of Public Safety. In addition, Eighmey pulls food-related reports and announcements from small-town newspapers like the Cloquet Pine Knot and the Bemidji Daily Pioneer. Eighmey also includes many recipes, so that readers may try a Corn and Nut Loaf (110) or a Cottage Cheese Pie (135) for themselves. The sources are prominent in her account and sometimes feel insufficiently edited. Eighmey could not resist including all the many fascinating stories she found, with the result that the book wanders a bit.
Eighmey begins chapter 1 by briefly recounting the war, via letters between Minnesota soldier Tracy Gray Cassidy and his family in Minneapolis. This chapter is full of details about the food Tracy ate in camps and overseas (plenty of meat and white bread), while his family struggled with meatless and wheatless days. Throughout the book, Eighmey appends anecdotes from soldiers' letters on the subject of food. Different soldiers told families how they bought eggs from a French matron who fried them up; picked berries while off duty; or found gum and candy in a home-knitted sock on a field hospital bed.
In chapter 2, Eighmey tells how Minnesota mobilized for food conservation. As head of the U.S. Food Administration, Herbert Hoover urged Americans to consume local, perishable foods, especially dairy; to conserve wheat, meats, fats, and sugars, and other staples that could be shipped overseas; and to eliminate waste. In conjunction with the Food Administration, the University of Minnesota's University Farm and Agricultural Extension Service established a food commission to organize Minnesota farmers' contributions. The commission also advised Minnesotans on victory gardening, offered help with preserving food, and distributed “conservation recipes” using wheat and meat substitutes. Households were asked to sign a “Food Pledge” promising conservation; food businesses were subject to social pressure to adopt conservation menus. Eighmey argues that Minnesota's participation was “virtually viral,” and she draws connections with modern social networking, as local and state government, small-town newspapers, libraries, and county fairs all became means for sharing information.
The next several chapters deal with specific key foods. Because wheat flour was limited during the war, women had to learn to make “war breads” using corn, oatmeal, rye, and whole-wheat flour, and Minnesota's grain farmers had to shift their crops. Vegetables were “victory foods,” as Americans could save transportable staples by eating more locally produced, perishable vegetables. Town and city Minnesotans enthusiastically took to gardening (despite high seed prices and shortages), guided by advice from newspapers, the agriculture service, and seed manufacturers.
With meat scarce in wartime, Minnesota's newspapers exhorted home cooks to replace beef and pork with chicken, fish, eggs, or beans. From February to June, 1918, Americans were asked to serve nine meatless meals a week. As Minnesota farmers sought to increase hog production, buying city garbage for feed, even urban dwellers attempted to raise and sell hogs within the city limits. Minnesota's many farmers also contributed dairy during the war, as Americans sought to replace meat with milk, cheese, and eggs. Butter, however, soon became scarce, and Minnesota's dairy farmers felt threatened by the spread of butter substitutes like oleomargarine or “Holiday Nutmargarine,” made mostly from coconut oil.
Potatoes were another Minnesota crop that could replace wheat and meat; Eighmey offers a recipe for “Wheatless Sugar-Saving Potato Chocolate Cake” (173). Sugar was a difficult food to conserve, despite government claims that it was “nutritionally unnecessary.” Sugary treats traditionally greased the wheels of society and voluntarism. Red Cross and other women's groups had to give up coffee and pastries at their meetings. The sugar shortage also complicated efforts to preserve fruits at home; fruits had to be canned via a “no-sugar hot-pack method” (201). Across the state, Minnesotans experimented with honey, sorghum, sugar beet, or maple syrup to replace white sugar.
The chapters on individual food commodities reveal a nagging flaw in the book: it is often too narrow a case study. Eighmey shares myriad detail about how Minnesotans dealt with shortages, but she often fails to provide any larger context. Was Minnesota similar to other states or different? How do these events illuminate the inherently national story of wartime mobilization? Eighmey has set out to tell Minnesota's story and has done so admirably, but the lack of a larger perspective limits the book's usefulness for a wider scholarly audience.
Throughout, Eighmey focuses on cooperation and success, rather than conflict. The exception, chapter 7, “Are You Doing Your Part?” deals with the particular challenges and arguments that arose around conservation. Working class women resented being given advice from society women on how to save food. Dairies complained about homemakers who balked at higher wartime prices. Town dwellers raising vegetables protested when their neighbor's chickens decimated their gardens; chicken keepers reported an increased number of chicken thieves. In general, however, Eighmey prefers to tell a story of patriotism, sacrifice, and a “can-do” spirit of optimism and enthusiasm. Readers will find a wealth of local detail, if not much in the way of critical argument.
