No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 01 May 2004
The Rebirth of Uzbekistan may indeed be the first lengthy monograph on post–Soviet Uzbekistan to present “systematically” a wide range of conventional social-science topics—society, politics, economics, foreign policy, and external relations. The fairly detailed and comprehensive coverage of these areas in one volume may be the work's greatest strength in that it constitutes a shift beyond lone chapters on Uzbekistan in the numerous edited volumes on the republics of Central Asia and the former Soviet Union. But the book has several major shortcomings.
First, according to the author, the book's aim is “to trace the main direction and developments in the country after the break-up of the Soviet Union” (p. 5). While the author traces Uzbekistan's developments in several important areas in helpful detail, the framing of these developments and the issues most at stake leaves a lot to be desired. This is especially true if the book, as indicated by the author, is intended to be both “easily accessible” and “used as a textbook.” It neither asks nor answers many of the most provocative questions that interest Central Asian specialists or that might draw those who seek an introduction to the region, or just to Uzbekistan. Such questions might include: What has been the impact of Soviet policies on national identity and other forms of identity in post–Soviet Uzbekistan? What challenges does this impact pose to the current government's efforts to establish and maintain its legitimacy, given that the top leadership came to power under Soviet rule with the help of socialist ideology? Given the largely effective Soviet modernization policies, how best might we understand the renewed interest in Islam, including the rise of Islamic movements that advocate violence? How do political elites define democracy, toward which they claim Uzbekistan is making a transition? The author's failure to raise and address many important issues detracts from the book's accessibility and systematicity, resulting often in dry encyclopedic reading with little guidance for the novice reader.
Second, there is no use of Russian-language sources. In such a broad and ambitious study of Uzbekistan, one would expect to find a more extensive bibliography that includes Russian sources. While knowledge of the Uzbek language is an invaluable asset for conducting fieldwork in Uzbekistan, it is probably least useful for interviewing members of the government and non-governmental organizations, almost all of whom speak Russian. Yet this is precisely the constituency the author has chosen to interview. Furthermore, official documents, newspapers, and scholarly writing in Russian form a significant part of the state archives and academic literature.
Third, several key English-language sources, which were published in the late 1990s, are also missing from the bibliography. Adeeb Khalid's historical study of Jadidism (1998) is not cited; nor are numerous works in anthropology and political science, including articles and unpublished dissertations by Foltz, Jones-Luong, Kamp, Kandiyoti, Northrop, Roi, Schoeberlein-Engel, Shahrani, and the reviewer himself, to mention a few. These would have enhanced several, if not all, of the chapters, especially the two on history and societal transformations.
The important contributions of scholarship to the analysis of post–Soviet Uzbekistan combined with only recently improved access for American, Western European, and Japanese scholars to local archives and field sites make the omission of these works all the more disappointing. This weakness arguably has affected the author's own analysis of social and political transformations, which suffers from unmarked and inconsistent shifts between face-value policy claims by Uzbek officials and analyses of various trends, resulting in clichés and other over-simplifications. For example, in the Introduction, the author writes, “All the empires formed [in Central Asia] had an impact on the people's lives, but none attempted to build a serious civil society” (p. 1), as if civil society were a universal concept that is neither historically nor culturally contingent. The sentence “[E]arly measures taken by the government to silence its opponents were not meant to prevent the emergence of a pluralist democracy in Uzbekistan” (p. 299) makes the author sound like an apologist for the early 1990s government. Another sentence, “The present period is witnessing the demolition of the old political system, the rejection of the former ideology, the establishment of new relations in the economic, political and spiritual spheres of society, and the formation of democracy and democratic institutions in Uzbekistan” (p. 303), has a similar effect. The situation, which is more complicated than implied here, would be better characterized as one of selective rejection and re-appropriation of elements of past, including Soviet, ideology. Moreover, such statements, and there are many, echo official rhetoric like extensions of titles of books and pamphlets written by or on behalf of Uzbekistan's President Karimov. In all fairness, the author is not alone among Central Asianists in committing these errors, which is why characterizations of how people invoke concepts such as democracy, civil society, and transition in local contexts and theoretically informed discussions of the rhetoric of political leaders would be useful.
The book's strengths are in the details, especially the discussions of Uzbekistan's demographic composition, with helpful sections on each of the main ethnic groups and its relations with other countries, including an interesting characterization of three phases of Turkey's relationship with Uzbekistan from 1991 to the present: raised expectations, disillusionment, and readjustment. These topics also happen to be among the author's areas of specialization. ‘Rebirth’ is clearly an ambitious (perhaps overly ambitious) project that falls short of advancing significantly most specialists’ understanding of the field. At the same time, its extensive detail and organization do not make it a particularly accessible introductory text. However, it is a useful one-volume resource for those who already have some familiarity with the recent history of Uzbekistan and are interested in brushing up on their facts.