Well, thank you very much, and good morning, ladies and gentlemen. Actually, I have to have a disclaimer. I am not a lawyer, and actually, probably the reason why I am here is to provide a dose of political realism and so really show a little bit still the limits of international law and to what extent actually international law governs international relations and why.
To begin with, one thing we have to understand, that law does not have any existence outside of society and communities, and in other words, law is not something that is out there and it's not related to the social and political conditions and processes that are going on. And, generally, also, laws are the outcome of two basic processes. Either laws develop over time, long time, over long time, or they are the outcome of political struggles and political compromises, and it's when there is a sufficient consensus within a society and that everybody is willing to give up some of their privileges for independent action for the greater good, for greater security and so on and so forth. Then we have a society that develops laws and also creates a mechanism to guarantee the enforcement of those laws.
So the one other thing that is very important to keep in mind is the enforcement mechanism—who is going to enforce laws. Let's say that in national societies it is the police or the military or whatever. So I think these are two things that we have to understand. Laws are the outcome of certain social and political processes unless, of course, we believe in divine law or national law and certain other things, but those are a different category of law.
But when we come to international law, of course, the development of international law has a very long history. It has always been certain that laws that have governed relations among states; for instance, certain things that are governing the rules of war or cease-fires and so on, even in ancient times, or even that states are responsible for the safety of envoys and so on. So let's say that in the old days, an envoy was not treated well and/or was killed. That would have been a casus belli it could have left, so there has always been international law.
But if you really want to look at the beginnings of international law, it's very interesting that the beginning of international law—and if you take Hugo Grotius, who talked about the law of peace and war, that was, more or less, also the same time that we see the state system is coming into being in Europe—on the basis of the so-called Treaty of Westphalia. That laid down a number of principles, including, for example, noninterference in international affairs of other states and so on.
So since then, because of expansion of international relations, we have also seen that a number of various types of laws have been developed, and actually, the overwhelming part of these laws that relate to the regulation and management of the various exchanges among nations and societies and so on are observed by everybody. For example, nobody—we think that mail comes and goes. Of course, nowadays with emails, this is another difficulty. I don't know how that's going to be, but when the mail comes and goes even at time of war and nobody interferes with that and all these things are regulations under the International Postal Union, for example, or when you have the maritime law process, which basically functions pretty well—and all of what I call the functional things are essentially not very contested—or aviation laws and so on and so forth. So in that part of international law, actually I think because there is common interest, the best, important guarantor that international laws are going to be implemented and observed is the commonality of interest, and in this regard, there's much broader commonality and interest. And everybody is convinced that it's in their own interest to observe this law.
Where we get into the trouble, it's when matters are related to many more areas, important areas where there is no commonality of interest, and of course, we come into the question of security, the matters of the peace and war. And that is where the problem arises—in those regards, we really don't have a commonality of interest.
And that is something that when I was growing up, and I went to university—in those days, we used to think about world peace through world law and members of United Nations associations and so on, and it is very sad that, now that I am at a much more advanced age, to see that we actually have regrets. But that is the problem that in international relations, actually more than law, it is really power that is—and I think that in international law, unfortunately, is mostly—is breached, is not observed. If somebody has the power to disregard the law, they will, and I don't think that international—I can give you examples. I mean, obviously, now we have a lot of problems going on in the Middle East and other parts of the world, but I think that's—and so the focus very naturally is on the Trump administration. But if you look at the previous administrations as well, there were a number of unilateral actions that have been taken with, frankly, very flimsy legal justification for it.
And since I also served for a long time as a delegate in the United Nations, I saw how things are done in the United Nations. In fact, what really it reflects also, is that international relations, unfortunately, are still—no matter what people say, are still based on power. Basically, if you have the power and you can do it and get away with it, you do it. And so the only thing that could deter is the countervailing power. Some people might say that—yes, I know; I will wrap up—that I am a cynical realist. I'm not cynical at all, but that is a fact of life.
For example, we have had the use of chemical weapons, for example, in the Iran–Iraq War. There was not a peep from anybody, and Saddam Hussein was not attacked. Saudi Arabia is using cluster bombs, which are equally bad, but nobody is bombing Saudi Arabia. So it's also even in defining what is a breach of international law. There is a lot of, I would say, gray—well, not to me. There is no gray area, but the fact is that the international community does not have an enforcement mechanism. And nobody else is going to enforce it, particularly the great powers.
If you look at the United Nations, why do you think that they have the veto power? The veto power was imposed because they realized after the defeat of the League of Nations that you cannot force big powers to do something they don't want. So in the UN Charter, they decided to put that.
So, finally, what I am trying to say is that this is a very sad fact that international law is often used against countries basically that don't have any way of responding, and that, basically, big powers don't observe international law at all. The application of international law is very, sort of, eschewed, and it's really based on what—I mean, Russians go and take over Crimea, and basically nobody can do anything because you don't want to start a nuclear war with Russia. Or somebody, you know, Sarkozy goes and bombs Libya, you are not going to start a war with France.
So I will just stop there but basically to give you the idea that there is the ideal of law that we want as an international community to reach a point where laws will actually be observed and will be implemented, but the reality currently is that, unfortunately, international relations are still—the international security area is still chaotic, and actually, they are determined by power and by various balances of power. Thank you. Sorry if I was a bit long.
Benjamin Wittes
No, no. Don't be silly. John?
