Along with a small set of colonies, Germany lost its leading position in the field of African studies after the First World War. Nonetheless, an account of the German researchers who continued working in this area through to the end of the next global conflict remains welcome: first, to consider how their scholarship and institutional efforts still shaped academic understanding of Africa; and second, to consider their links to the internal and international politics of the Weimar and Nazi German regimes. Holger Stoecker has not only undertaken a careful investigation of the primary and (surprisingly large) secondary sources on German Africanists between 1919 and 1945 but also presents his results in a clear, engaging, and appropriately dispassionate manner.
The study is limited to Berlin and thus leaves out two of the best-known German Africanists of the era, the linguist Carl Meinhof and the anthropologist Leo Frobenius; but the restriction both allows greater focus and covers the major issues of how scholars of Africa throughout Germany related to one another, to the larger domestic world of academic life and politics, and to their colleagues abroad. The most important individual in the book is Diedrich Westermann, essentially a linguist who also branched out into anthropology and history. Stoecker might have made a bit more out of the centrality of language in German African studies (thus bringing it closer to other branches of philology as opposed to the social sciences), since this approach has roots in the era before Germany acquired colonies and also derives from the missionary background of many leading figures (including both Meinhof and Westermann). The contrast to the more anthropologically based British tradition (Stoecker's main comparison) is noted but mainly by reference to the specific functionalist school that became dominant in the inter-war era. Stoecker does demonstrate not only how productive Westermann was in his own areas of research but also the major role he played in the formation and development of the London-based International African Institute (the IAI, tellingly founded in large part by missionaries and originally called ‘International Institute for African Languages and Cultures’).
Because this book is less about scholarship itself than what Stoecker calls (in English) a ‘scientific community’, politics does play an important role. The takeover of German colonies by the victorious allies in 1918 reduced public support for some aspects of the previous African studies apparatus but nationalistic concern about the return of these territories, or at least about the moral charges against their previous rulers, encouraged such research and even its fuller institutional development under both the Weimar and Nazi regimes. Westermann, the first Berlin professor of ‘Afrikanistik’, was a political conservative, as were most of his significant colleagues. The exceptions come mainly from the rare ranks of Africanist economists, including Moritz Bonn (who coined the term ‘decolonization’ as early as 1926) and Charlotte Leubuscher (one of the only Jewish members of this cohort, who left Germany in the 1930s to gain her greatest distinction in Britain).
Although Westermann and others took advantage of German colonial ambitions to gain funding for their work, Stoecker does not find evidence of extreme nationalism or racism in their academic writings. In fact, the one chapter of the book that I found rather dull describes the elaborate research apparatus established by the Nazis around their phantom colonial empire during the early and (for them) victorious years of the Second World War. To spice this section up, Stoecker adds a somewhat tangential but quite entertaining account of Otto Schulz-Kampfhenkel, a tropical adventurer, film-maker, and popular travel writer who actually organized a 1943 field research team that supported Rommel's Afrika Korps in Libya. The racism that Stoecker does identity among German Africanists is not extreme but distinct in some ways from the broader attitudes of the era. For example, as linguists they employed many native-speaker assistants whose status remained very restricted, and they also took advantage of military prisons during both world wars to record the speech of captured African allied soldiers. Although Westermann showed some liberalism in producing (without benefit of prisons) a volume of African autobiographies and also in paying attention to pre-colonial African history, he made no effort to encourage Africans as fellow scholars. A minor sensation that emerges from Stoecker's archival findings is Westermann's veto of IAI research support for an apparently promising Nigerian student, one Benjamin Nnamdi Azikiwe.
In summary, this is not a book for most (even Germanophone) readers of this journal but those who are interested will find it very rewarding.
