Well written, well edited and well rounded, The Oxford Handbook of the History of Mathematics offers a thematic overview of mathematical episodes and case studies from antiquity forward. Editors Eleanor Robson and Jacqueline Stedall aim, they tell us, to ‘raise new questions about what mathematics has been and what it has meant to practise it’ (p. 1). They have succeeded admirably. What is more, they have done so without a bias in favour of the last three centuries of mathematical production. In particular, they have avoided undue focus on mathematical practices stemming from the Victorian era into the early twentieth century.
The chapters are organized into three sections; alas I have space here to discuss only a few examples from each. In the first section, on ‘Geographies and cultures’, G.E.R. Lloyd highlights the difference between ancient Greek and ancient Chinese practitioners. While the former sought to provide certainty through mathematical acts, the latter sought to provide unity and harmony. Gary Urton presents mathematical practices, notably accounting, as forms of imperial control in periphery polities, where the conqueror possessed the ultimate ability to define mathematical truth by establishing ‘the rules of the game’ (p. 51). Catherine Jami concludes with a chapter that demonstrates how Jesuit mathematics was integrated into pre-existing Chinese mathematical traditions in the fourteenth and fifteenth centuries rather than imported in an unmediated or direct fashion. The second section, ‘Peoples and practices’, finds Mary Croarken reconstructing the largely undocumented mathematical activity performed by human ‘computers’ – people who performed the menial task of repeated computation in eighteenth- and nineteenth-century observatories. Leo Corry launches the reader into the twentieth century with an account of the Bourbaki project and its heterogeneity. Though ‘structuralism’ played an overarching role in shaping the outputs of the Eléments de mathématique, he explains, it was by no means uniformly accepted as a defining approach to the foundations of mathematics by the multiple generations of Bourbaki contributors. Rounding off is the third section, ‘Interactions and interpretations’. Jeremy Gray's contribution draws an analogy to ‘modernism’ in art in arguing that the period from 1880 to 1940 constituted a new ‘modernist’ era in mathematics – one marked by an increasing (though not absolute) emphasis on abstractness and formalism (the new methods of axiomatization and the nascent field of topology being exemplary cases). June Barrow-Green offers an interesting analysis of Rolle's theorem, in which she demonstrates how Rolle developed his ‘theorem’ as a form of algebra, not, as is often assumed, of calculus (in fact, Rolle was an ardent critic of the calculus). Discussing more contemporary times, Reinhard Siegmund-Schultze offers an account of the institutionalizing role that racial theories played in shaping mathematical practices during the Third Reich, demonstrating that mathematical claims made in L. Bieberbach's Deutsche Mathematik (1934) manifested Nazi political views.
The historiographic sophistication of many of the contributions is impressive. Usefully, a number of contributors critically discuss the conceptual categories of ‘centre’ and ‘periphery’ in terms of the mediated transference of knowledge from a centre of learning to peripheral locations within empires, regimes and polities more generally. Alexei Volkov upturns the commonly held view that mathematical knowledge transferred along a one-way vector from the centre of medieval China to the periphery of Korea, Japan and Vietnam. Snezana Lawrence explains how the Ottoman Empire's efforts to ‘westernize’ through the importation of European mathematics in the seventeenth century exemplified the empire's waning political influence on a global scale. And Massimo Mazzotti shows how mathematics was used as a tool to institutionalize state control over the wider Kingdom of Naples, helping to entrench centralized, bureaucratic engineers whose legitimacy derived from their appeal to the rationality of mathematical thinking.
There is also an emphasis throughout on the contingency of the historical craft itself. Multiple authors claim that historians do not always recognize the problematical nature of the sources they are using. Factors including the hermeneutic and interpretative steps involved in reading and translating texts, the selection of classical artefacts from an incomplete set, and the unshakeable desire to identify seeds of current mathematics in historical settings have all shaped the stories that historians have told. In many instances, those factors have led to the generation of problematical ‘myths’. Robson notes that generalizing from a small set of seemingly disparate artefacts in the Babylonian case has led historians to trivialize that culture's practice of using numeracy and measurement to distribute resources equally and establish a system of social justice. Sabine Rommevaux documents how poor translations of Euclid's Elements changed the theoretical claims made by that text over the centuries. Ken Saito highlights the difficulties faced by past generations of historians who have tried to carry out historical work at a time when analysing diagrams scattered throughout the world's libraries required manual copies, thereby impeding the accuracy of the accounts rendered. Lastly, Annette Imhausen elaborates upon a series of myths about Egyptian mathematics that stem from persistently Whiggish approaches to Egyptian artefacts.
Juxtaposing this Handbook against others of its kind is difficult to do as there are no others of its kind. The most obvious competitor might be Ivor Grattan-Guinness's edited collection Landmark Writings in Western Mathematics, 1640–1940 (2005), but even that comparison is inappropriate as the latter book identifies primary publications that signified ‘landmarks’ (according to the editor's highly malleable criteria) in mathematics. Robson and Stedall have a different project in mind. Indeed, as noted, their volume is as much about the methodology of doing the history of mathematics as it is a history of mathematics.
Overall, if the editors' ambition was to demonstrate that important mathematical acts and practices occur in domains extending beyond the narrow scope of the contemporary discipline of mathematics, they have achieved their goal. Worth a loan from the library (if not the full cover price), The Oxford Handbook of the History of Mathematics is a healthy contribution to a burgeoning field of newly self-aware research.
