No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 01 November 2004
Using concise language and a clear organization, Herbert Berg's book provides a careful and nuanced examination of the modern scholarly debate over what he terms the “authenticity” of hadiths and isnāds in early Islamic texts. Berg outlines the major issues in the textual and historical study of hadith and proposes an alternative method for “testing” certain types of hadiths according to their isnāds.
Berg's study is primarily a critical review and analysis of the different Western scholarly evaluations of and approaches to hadith criticism. He groups Western scholars into three main categories: sceptics (Goldziher, Schacht, Stetter, Wansbrough, Rippin, Cook, Calder); reactionaries (Abbott, Sezgin, Azami, Horst, Birkeland, Stauth); and moderates (Juynboll, Rahman, Schoeler, Motzki, Horovitz, Fück, Robson, Versteegh, Nuranyi, Gilliot, Leemhuis, Coulson, Rubin). The number of scholars examined and the ease with which Berg moves from one specialized academic debate to another is remarkable. Despite what might appear to be an overly specialized subject, Berg's presentation is very readable and carefully explains concepts in terms accessible to the non-specialist. This does not mean that Berg over-generalizes, however, nor is his analysis overly restricted by its roughly chronological approach.
The focus of Berg's interest is what he calls “exegetical” hadiths, supplying a representative subset of the larger question of hadith in relation to early Muslim literature. Berg follows his overview of the general evaluation of hadith criticism by a more limited and detailed investigation of hadiths employed in exegesis of the Qur

an. He makes a number of bold and insightful points such as the structual parallel between the place of the Prophet Muhammad in legal hadith and Ibn

Abbas in exegetical hadith.
The centerpiece of Berg's book is his own testing of some 5,835 hadiths in al-Tabari

s Qur

an commentary whose isnāds include the name of Ibn

Abbas, though the number of hadiths for which statistical information is provided is much lower (a sample of 997 hadiths). Berg gives a meticulous description of his presuppositions and the methods he used in selecting and analyzing the isnāds using a computer database. Among the variables he examines are the number of isnāds with common informants of al-Tabari and Ibn

Abbas; the number of different types of isnāds; and a classification of hadith according to exegetical devices (drawn primarily from Wansbrough). Chapter 5 (pp. 173–218) surveys selected results of this statistical analysis.
At no point does Berg seem to tip his hand toward one camp or another, beyond his shrewd observation that those who take a “middle ground” do not appear to differ much (at least in their presuppositions and conclusions) from those who defend the authenticity of hadiths through the isnāds. Nor does Berg appear to draw conclusions about the significance of these different positions or his own analyses for the larger issues of reconstructing the early history of Qur

an exegesis or Islamic literature more generally. Readers interested in more substantive questions will need to look elsewhere.
Certainly, Berg defines well the methodological and epistemological implications of the different approaches he examines, but there is little to ground this theoretical analysis in the historical questions that seem to concern the scholars under study. For example, although Berg concedes that scholars such as Wansbrough are not interested in what “really happened,” others, such as Abbott and Sezgin, do seem to have that concern. The types of theses being argued by these different scholars, and the social contexts in which they were emeshed, may be more relevant to an analysis of their methods than Berg's study allows. It is particularly unfortunate that Berg does not elaborate on the implications of his own testing of hadiths for reconstructing the literary history of early Qur

an exegesis.
Overall, Berg's work should be considered extremely useful as an incisive introduction to Western scholarship on hadith criticism and as providing a fresh approach to the analysis of isnāds as a source for judging the authenticity of hadith literature.