When is garbage not garbage? A conference on cleaning, clearing, and reclaiming a dump site may seem an unlikely place for political scientists and scholars of international relations to pursue professional development, but the pursuit of knowledge knows no bounds—even if the smell can be hard on the nose itself! Observing such supposedly non-political sessions can quickly reveal that they are anything but, and discussions of how garbage is handled elsewhere can offer useful comparative insights as the local becomes global. Furthermore, few occasions provide such a useful context for developing one's critical thinking skills and recognizing the value of interdisciplinarity—an approach often touted as desirable in our profession.
My introduction to the politics of garbage came with my attendance at an international conference on landfill site remediation held recently at my university in Sharjah, one of the seven United Arab Emirates (AUS 2005; Saffarini 2005). An impressive display of cooperation between physical scientists, local authorities, and environmental technology firms was evident throughout the gathering—well, sort of. As perhaps the sole social scientist in attendance, I was pleased to find the discussion quickly move into the realm of politics. Most of the others in attendance seemed displeased, but not surprised. Needless to say, it would have been useful to have more political scientists, historians, sociologists, ethicists, literary specialists, and the like on hand. Fortunately or unfortunately, I was left to soldier on alone, although the absence of someone with more knowledge of the local and national policies was a shortcoming for which I was unable to compensate. Hopefully, such interdisciplinary gaps will be addressed in advance by the organizers of future meetings of this sort wherever they may be convened, as the connection between the environment, technology, and public policy warrants more study in both democratic and less-than-democratic settings (Lyons 1970, 5–9; Rosow 2003; Beier and Arnold 2005; Woods 2005). Here, the importance of policy was exposed when the first question to the first presenter in the first session was pointedly posed by someone from the federal government who clearly seemed more interested, if not aggrieved, that the project underway a stone's throw from our campus had not been approved by the national authorities. Such are the challenges in this still young federation (Ghareeb and Al Abed 1997; Duke 2002; “UAE” 2005).
The challenge of interdisciplinarity also looms when it comes to the landfill issue, as does the attraction of this approach to research and understanding (Squires 1992; Lattuca 2002). Beyond the political dimensions I promptly discovered, it was clear that public administration experts would have a field day, business professors would have been presented with a wonderful new case study, and all variety of engineers—civil, mechanical, chemical, environment—could have been called upon as consultants with respect to enormous, if messy, technological, logistical, soil, and water issues. Each of these areas of expertise impinges on the others; in this context, none of them can proceed alone in trying to understand or resolve the landfill site remediation problem. Each has a contribution to make. This is to say nothing of the plethora of disciplines in the social sciences, humanities, and natural sciences commonly engaged in the inherently interdisciplinary fields of environmental, urban, women's, and international studies now found in most university catalogs.
Regardless of what might be in the landfill, the opening sessions demonstrated that we had a hot topic on our hands and that more heated discussion was to follow, discussion which would perhaps go where the conference organizers had neither intended, nor wanted. A provocative and useful typographical error on a slide within the first presentation also illustrated a broader political point when the word “plant,” in this case a reference to the remediation plant, was rendered as “planet,” as in “the capacity of the planet” and the “operation, controlling and observation of the planet.” To this political scientist, either word would work. Shortly afterwards, another installment of “Your Daily Smile” appeared via a botched reference to wells being set at “right angels,” instead of “right angles.” The use of “angels” here seemed appropriate given the scope and importance (visual and olfactory) of the apparently positive clean-up efforts being discussed.
For the purposes of this conference, remediation was defined as “recovery, reclamation, to make usable again.” Various projects in Switzerland, Germany, and the Netherlands were discussed early in the meeting in an effort to offer a comparative perspective and alert the uninitiated to the intense international competition for new ideas and contracts in this line of business. The creativity of the human spirit in seeking to solve environmental problems seemed a prime driving force (Newell 2000; Gunter 2004), but it soon became apparent that economic incentive was not far behind, notwithstanding the fine and frank admission by the leading local bureaucrat with respect to the project at hand that this public-private enterprise was giving his government “the chance to correct a mistake” made from 1975 to 2000 when the landfill site was in use (Korten 2001; Mofid 2002). Let this local remediation project serve as a trial that will in turn serve as a model for such projects throughout the country, the region, and the world, he exhorted. The central question up for debate was thus set: Would this project be a one-off experiment never to be repeated, or would it serve as a model and help forge international standards for landfill site remediation (Al Jandaly 2005)? Put another way, were we really discussing an exemplary case of “thinking globally, acting locally” (Held and McGrew 2002; Mott 2004)? Indeed, it is useful to ask if anyone elsewhere—especially governmental elites and corporate executives—has ever tried to set this aspect of waste management in a comparative or international context (Woods 2006) and to thereby “glocalize” the topic (Ritzer 2003)? The answer is resoundingly affirmative when one considers the range of studies and initiatives recently undertaken in this subject area (see, for example, Hogland 1997; Gee et al. 1998; ESAB 1999; Smith et al. 2001; New York City 2004; Chu and Bala 2005).
Of the seven clean-up options reported by a team from a neighboring university in 2001, it had been agreed by local authorities that the best was full rehabilitation. A private firm with foreign connections was commissioned to undertake the job (EET, n.d.) and work began in earnest three years later on what the company, together with Sharjah Municipality officials, have since described as “the largest project of its kind in the world” (“EET to Highlight Details” 2006). In a manner of speaking, this whole conference afforded this firm an opportunity to live up to the emerging, though often questioned, ideal of corporate social responsibility (Mofid 2003; Bakan 2004). Health, safety, and environmental standards were to be met and these would hopefully help establish guidelines for landfill site remediation throughout the region, an independence streak which arose in response to the thorny question of whether the project here should adhere to American, European, or international standards or whether these foreign practices should be adapted to local conditions (Said 1979). How deep was the professed learning of lessons from cases elsewhere?
As noted earlier, the Sharjah case also raises the question of whether our findings will hold for both democratic and non-democratic settings. Could projects such as this be undertaken in more democratic contexts? Here, the ruler makes decisions based largely on input from court advisors. Developers and financial interests compete for the ear of these advisors and the ruler. Members of Emirati civil society have access to the court and ruler via a majlis system in which citizens are able to make direct representations, although this form of direct democracy is not the sort of pluralism conceived of in the West (“Traditional Government” n.d.). The process may not be as transparent and the corresponding regulatory regime may not be as strong or well-defined as elsewhere, but this does not prevent the ruler from acting in an enlightened and benevolent manner, just as allegedly more democratic systems are not immune from less-than-transparent practices. However, it does mean that each circumstance may be unique and incomparable to cases elsewhere.
This said, the corporate involvement seen in this case may be a factor enabling more meaningful comparisons with other locales. The bottom line is the bottom line. Profit is profit—more or less. The roles of the state and civil society may differ, but the profit motive and the obligations to shareholders will be similar across case studies of corporate involvement in the resolution of local waste problems, thereby suggesting that international models for corporate contributions, the positive pursuit of corporate social responsibility, and possibly even effective state-business partnerships may begin to emerge (Korten 2001; Mofid 2002; 2003; Bakan 2004).
When asked how the initial mistake to establish the problem landfill site was made, the lead local bureaucrat in attendance quickly responded, “Ignorance.” Environmental awareness among the local population is increasing, he said, and his office would be seeking to ensure that the remediation project had a lasting educational impact (EEG n.d.; Jongbloed 1998). Had a survey of flora and fauna on the site been done prior to the commencement of its use as a dump? No. Was one done before the current remediation process began? Not systematically. When I asked in the first afternoon session on basic principles for landfill rehabilitation if anyone was concerned about the flora and fauna that had colonized the site (Woods 2002)—“Is it ethical to simply displace or destroy them?”—I was told by a German presenter that in Europe they must be taken into account and, if possible, moved intact. This said, another European participant observed that there is a related question that must be considered: “Is it ethical to let these species develop on these dump sites if the plants and animals living there are becoming contaminated and deformed?”
Day Two began with researchers from a nearby school reviewing their preliminary assessment of the site and discussing the replacement site established 30 km from the city center in 2000. The most interesting aspect of this presentation was not what they had to say about the site being remediated, but what they had to say about the new landfill, which they noted had not initially been planned to operate in a sustainable manner and was already undergoing a refit. This planning failure and subsequent retrofitting are not surprising, just disappointing. Even more disappointing, if not startling, was the news that our mid-sized city generates more waste per capita than anywhere in Europe! (A later speaker from the local municipality would contend that one week of our household waste would be cover to one football field 10 meters deep!) Smiles returned to the drawn faces of the participants when the next presenter detailed the use of “smelling squads” (which walk perpendicular to the wind direction) and the measurement of “smelling units” (which are different from “sniffing units,” we were reminded) on a remediation project in Holland.
By the second afternoon, we were ready to get “down and dirty” and to hear about the local landfill remediation effort proper. A much-anticipated site visit would follow! A company spokesperson took us through the contents and scale of the landfill and project area, stressing that the company had been given a tight 18-month timeline—the viability of which was frequently questioned during the conference—to clean an area equivalent to one-third of the entire unusually flat and unusually large landfill. Construction for a new highway cutting across the landfill and running alongside the sector they were remediating would begin in three months, hopefully using clean backfill generated by the project. Sorting machines had begun work on-site four months prior to our conference and 157 employees were now actively engaged as excavation, sorting plant, and engineering support staff. Their biggest challenge is not the sorting and removal, but how to handle the water running from our university and environs through the site and toward downtown, a problem that had even prompted them to build their own dam to try to seal off their work site from the lagoons beside the nearby sewage treatment plant.
As predicted, the highlight of the conference was the fieldtrip to the “under remediation” landfill site. As we arrived in our fleet of three buses, 10 flamingos greeted us and a large raptor swooped low. My chariot stopped first at one of the two sorting plants. To see the process of sorting through all of this garbage in action was astounding, inspiring, and reassuring, as piles of wood, metal, plastic, concrete, and other cast-offs took shape. This system accounts for 40% of the project costs, alongside the cost of excavation/transportation (18%), air-quality technology (14%), and overhead (9%). (A separate tire-shredding operation was going on nearby and slowly reducing the size of the huge tire dump on the site, with the output—unsuitable for retreading—being shipped to India.) We were then introduced to the technology of “smell wells” and shown the firm's dam, where we were treated to an excellent view of—and show by—a raptor (I believe it was a Tawney or Steppe Eagle, or possibly a Marsh Harrier) displaying its intriguing ability to hover just above lagoon-side bushes before lowering itself into the center of a bush and then rising up again! As we drove away, three more of these raptors joined the parade. Arriving at the site offices and laboratories, a dozen flamingos took flight from beyond the perimeter fence in our honor.
Despite working in the desert, the real problem for the company heading the project is the water in which the flamingos once thrived. In this sense, this case study of the politics of garbage is just as much about the politics of water (Shiva 2002). A high artificial water table runs at one to three meters below the waste. Still, company officials say they are now confident that with the help of nature (evaporation and the slope of the land), run-off water coming in from outside to flush the site clean, and some trucking of water to other sites and users, there will be no water on the site in two years. Our hosts also stressed repeatedly that they are solving problems well beyond the purview of their project and having to overcome less-than-helpful government departments.
Disembarking back at our campus, a company official indicated that their client was a private customer related to the leading political family here. The longer-term goal for the strategically important, highly valued piece of land being remediated? It is to be sold and a shopping mall is expected to be built upon it. All having been revealed, the central question of my observations returned: Was this to be a one-off experiment or a project worthy of becoming a model for the world?
Our final day began with a discussion of an extensive chemical survey undertaken via trial pits dug on the site and some drilled wells. Mercury, lead, cadmium, chromium, sulphate ammonia, and other heavy metals were all found in varying amounts. Though perhaps predictable given the construction, industrial, medical, and household waste in the dump, this report left a bad taste in my mouth prior to lunch. The taste worsened when we sat down to eat and—as if to redirect our attention—a local conference organizer announced that a neighboring city's many mega-development projects were “the crime of the century” because they were not designed with environmental considerations and sustainability in mind. “Where will they put the waste created by 10 million people?” he asked, later downgrading the ranking of this crime to second place behind the American invasion of Iraq. Returning specifically to the water issue, he added that the vulnerability of the desalination plants needed to sustain such a population is the real risk, interspersing his remarks with calls for more scientific logic and societal input to shape decision-making in this country in the face of the now overwhelming strength of developers' dollars (Sampler and Eigner 2003; Wheeler 2005; Sengupta 2006).
To be sure, the expected local population growth rates in the near-term in the UAE raise a number of environmental issues which have had to be confronted by small states and city-states in the past as they have sought to pursue a rapid development trajectory. Allowing for the necessity of adapting to local conditions, there is no need to reinvent the wheel, as students of comparative politics and political sociology will let us know. Dubai might have recently become (in)famous in the U.S. as a result of the ports management contracts purchased from the British firm P&O by Dubai Ports World (“U.S. Committee Votes” 2006; Weisman and Graham 2006), but on the ground in the UAE the waste management issue is soon to become far more pressing and will provide lessons of its own for the broader international audience (“Hitting the Bottle” 2006).
We returned to the “experiment or model” question in our closing session, noted the success in Europe of a tax on landfilling as a way of funding environmentally important remediation projects that might lack an economic incentive, received a call for monitoring air quality and other aspects of the environmental process during the remediation process, revisited the issue of a lack of national involvement and permits, and heard that the weakest link in the whole project might be the client's consultant who did not attend the conference beyond the opening coffee!
Thanks and congratulations are due those who organized, contributed to, and participated in this unusual yet timely conference, so much so that when one of the closing speakers sought to summarize the remediation project we had managed to discuss for two and a half days with the familiar, if not often trite, saying that “a long journey begins with a single step,” the analogy made eminent sense. So the next time you have an opportunity to attend a conference on garbage, go. In terms of professional development, chances are you won't be “wasting” your time. Take your critical thinking skills with you (Hoefler 1994), put your own production of waste in perspective (Royte 2005), and discover new directions for your own life and work (Dombrowski 2002; Wilson 2002). Watch where you step, though: that garbage may be more political than you think!
Author Bio
Lawrence T. Woods is professor of political science and international studies at the American University of Sharjah in the United Arab Emirates. The emirate of Sharjah shares a border with the emirate of Dubai. An aspiring countertenor and avid bird-watcher, Woods' recent work on interdisciplinarity and international education has appeared in International Journal, Interreligious Insight, New Political Science, and Pacific Affairs.
