No visit to Orvieto is complete without time taken wandering around the Etruscan necropolis at Crocifisso del Tufo. The rows of tombs each with a name carved into the volcanic stone of the lintels are a memorable sight, and it is hard for anyone with even a passing interest in epigraphy to resist trying to read the names or taking photographs for later study. Most of the inscriptions contain the same Etruscan formula, mi followed by a bipartite name in the genitive, and sometimes a word for ‘tomb’, meaning ‘I [am] (the tomb) of NN’. The names are not without significance, since two of the tombs belong to members of a gens Latinie, giving sixth-century attestations for the ethnic. Going through notes or holiday snaps later in an attempt to track down the readings of these inscriptions can be a frustrating business. The relevant fascicle of Corpus Inscriptionum Etruscarum was published in 1907 by Pauli and Danielsson, and many of the inscriptions were not known then or have been re-edited since. Much more useful is the two-volume Etruskische Texte (Tübingen, 1991) edited by a team headed by Helmut Rix. Here most of the Orvieto necropolis inscriptions (and nearly all other Etruscan inscriptions) are presented in a splendidly compact and informative style — maddening to the first-time reader, but absolutely worth the trouble if one persists. Etruskische Texte includes details of earlier publications, availability of published photographs, an ingenious system for describing the material on which the inscription occurs and the nature of the text, and an estimate of the date. However, it is also not complete; it contains many errors and it has the significant drawback of presenting many of Rix's conjectures and corrections in place of the actual reading. For example, where one sees the praenomen cuθerus on an Orvieto tomb, Rix prints θucerus at Vs 1.12 (note also that Etruskische Texte gives the wrong reference for this inscription; the correct reference is given as a note to the previous inscription, Vs 1.11), and another clearly legible text aranθia lapanas is not recorded.
The new edition of the Thesaurus Linguae Etruscae (the TLE) does better at passing the Orvieto necropolis test than previous works. It aims for complete coverage of individual words in Etruscan inscriptions (listed in the order of the Etruscan alphabet), providing references to publications up until 2006 for every single inscription, and it keeps track of re-readings and re-editions. For each lemma all the attested epigraphic instances are recorded, including the provenance of the inscriptions and usually enough words of the immediate context are given for the reader to get some sense of comparable usages; the TLE also includes a reverse index. The form cuθerus is recorded with the correct reference to its first publication, and the full text [mi] aranθia lapanas, ‘I am the tomb of Aranth Lapana’, is given under the lemma lapanas, together with the information that this text was published in the Annali della Fondazione per il Museo Claudio Faina in 1990. It is unfortunate, however, that Rix's conjecture θucerus for cuθerus is not mentioned, since there are good grounds for its acceptance. The praenomen θucer (genitive θucerus) occurs on a couple of other Etruscan inscriptions, and is also the basis for a gentilicium θucerna, whereas cuθer is nowhere else attested.
In other respects too, the TLE might have benefited from adopting more of Rix's innovations. The transcription of sibilants in Etruscan is notoriously difficult. All Etruscan variants of the Greek alphabet use two different signs for s-sounds, which must correspond to a phonemic difference between two sibilants (probably similar to that denoted by the English orthographies of s and sh). However, in the northern area scribes generally employ sigma where southern scribes use san, and san where the southerners have sigma. The approach of the Corpus Inscriptionum Etruscarum, and that followed in the TLE, has been to transliterate san as ś, wherever it occurs, and sigma as s, wherever it occurs. This makes life easy for the epigrapher, but more difficult for the analysis of the language or parallel cases. For example, where the Orvieto inscriptions include the word for ‘tomb’, it is normally written with san, śuθi, in the TLE transcription. TLE has a separate lemma suθi, the same word, but written in inscriptions from Volterra, Perugia, Siena etc. (and once from Orvieto). In order to trace the comparanda for this word, one has to look it up in two different entries. Accordingly, in Rix's Etruskische Texte, a different system of transliteration is used, which renders a sigma from the south and a san from the north both as s, but a san from the south and a sigma from the north as σ, thereby allowing all the words meaning ‘tomb’ to be listed under σuθi. ‘Northern’ writings, i.e. a san where the south has sigma, and a sigma where the south has san, are further distinguished by having an acute written above them, thereby meaning that ś is used in some, but by no means all, of the same cases where the CIE would transcribe ś. This system is not without its drawbacks: the very common name Laris, is almost always written with a sigma, whether from north or south; and in some central areas, particularly Chiusi, sigma and san are often confused, and the decision of whether to write s or σ is editorial. The editors of TLE are no doubt right when they say (xxvii) that Rix's system ‘non si tratta di una traslitterazione, ma comporta una interpretazione del valore fonetico delle diverse sibilanti che non è sempre obiettiva o certa, e che ha creato errori e incomprensioni nella letteratura più recente.’ Even so, an index such as this cannot shrug off the problem entirely; the reader should somewhere be told to cross-refer śuθi and suθi.
In summary, the new edition of the TLE enriches the research resources for the study of Etruscan, but, as is inevitable in works such as this, it is not the last word. Although it includes all published Etruscan inscriptions up until 2006, the visitor to Crocifisso del Tufo will see inscriptions that have been on display at least since 2003 but are still unpublished, and which do not feature in the TLE. A second edition of Etruskische Texte is in hand, but more useful is the Etruscan Texts Project, a searchable online database of Etruscan inscriptions, covering inscriptions published since 1989, set up by Rex Wallace at the University of Massachusetts in Amherst (etp.classics.umass.edu). With the Etruscan Texts Project website, Etruscan studies have truly entered the third millennium.
