I. INTRODUCTION: WOMEN, PRIZES, AND THE EARLY YEARS OF THE AEA
The emergence of economics and other academic disciplines in the late nineteenth century, with professional associations and scholarly journals that conferred professional legitimacy, is widely remembered as having been what the historian J.H. Hexter claimed all history was: a stag affair. But that was not entirely the case. In the first years after it was founded in 1885 (see Dorfman Reference Dorfman1936, Coats Reference Coats1960, Bernstein Reference Bernstein2008), the American Economic Association held essay competitions on topics—child labor and women wage-earners—that were likely to attract entries from women and that were, in fact, won by women, providing those women with credentials as participants in the economics profession. Not until 1985, the centenary of the founding of the association, did Alice Rivlin become the first female AEA president, and not until the early twenty-first century did a woman win the AEA’s John Bates Clark Medal for an outstanding economist below the age of forty, recognition that was hailed as the acceptance of the modern world by the economics profession. Such acclaim might have recalled the forerunners of the late nineteenth century. Notable among these was Mary Clare de Graffenreid (born 1849, died 1921), an outspoken social reformer who won two American Economic Association essay competitions, in 1889 and 1891, before becoming notorious for her articles on “The Georgia Cracker in the Cotton Mills” (de Graffenreid Reference de Graffenreid1891b, Reference de Graffenreid1891c), a critique of factory conditions in her home state (particularly child labor, a recurrent theme in de Graffenreid’s writing) that was denounced in Georgia for putting reform of labor conditions above maintenance of white supremacy. De Graffenreid and other American women publishing or participating in the AEA’s conferences, essay competitions, and publications, and publishing in other scholarly journals before World War I, were ignored in Joseph Dorfman’s massive The Economic Mind in American Civilization (Dorfman Reference Dorfman1946–59, 5 volumes), apart from a passing quotation (Vol. III, p. 243) from Emily Greene Balch that marginal utility was being taught in economics courses (but no mention of Balch’s losing a full professorship for the same reasons she later shared the Nobel Peace Prize).Footnote 1 Similarly, when William Baumol (Reference Baumol1985, p. 11), in his “Digression: On Earlier Writings by Women” in the AEA centenary volume, proudly announced his discovery “that before World War I, as today, a (distressingly) few women were contributing to the literature,” the four pre-World War I articles he was able to find did not include de Graffenreid (Reference de Graffenreid1890b), Balch (Reference Balch1893), Coman (Reference Coman1891, Reference Coman1893, Reference Coman1903a), Hannah Robie Sewall (Reference Sewall1901), Crystal Eastman (Reference Eastman1909)—or even Katharine Coman (Reference Coman1911a), the lead article in the inaugural issue of the American Economic Review.
Richard T. Ely, the founding secretary of the American Economic Association, reported in the handbook of the association in 1893 on the “excellent results” of five prizes “offered through the Association by generous friends interested in economic research.” Rader (Reference Rader1966, p. 39) reports that Ely persuaded the AEA to sponsor prize essay competitions, personally raised the prize money, and frequently selected the topics related to his reform interests. In the first competition, Richard D. Lang of Baltimore won $150 offered by the magazine America (which then published his essay) for the best paper on “The Evils of Unrestricted Immigration” (an assigned title that left competitors no leeway in choosing sides). Other contests awarded $250 for the best essay on “State and Local Taxation,” and, in 1892, $500 for two essays on “The Housing of the Poor in American Cities” ($300 for the best essay, which the AEA published, and $200 for the runner-up). According to Ely (Reference Ely1893, p. 9),
The usefulness of such prizes can hardly be over-estimated. They not merely furnish to the public the results of careful investigation on important subjects, but stimulate work on economic lines in all of our colleges and universities and enable promising young students to make their abilities known. The prizes are, of course, for such younger investigators in the main, rather than for economists of established reputation. Though it has not been deemed advisable in every case to publish the successful essay, those which have been so published by the Association have proved to be among its most useful and popular monographs.
The prize essay competitions were open to all, not just those who already belonged to the AEA.
In 1889 a prize of $100 offered by Mrs. John Armstrong Chanler (Amélie Rives) for the best essay on child labor “was, after full consideration, divided between Miss Clare De Graffenreid of the Department of Labor, Washington, and Mr. W.F. Willoughby, also of Washington, and since connected with the Department of Labor.” Both monographs were published in the Publications of the American Economic Association in March 1890 (de Graffenreid Reference de Graffenreid1890b, Willoughby Reference Willoughby1890). Then, in 1891, Clare de Graffenreid also won the $300 first prize in an AEA competition for the best essay on “Women Wage Earners,” with the $200 second prize going to Helen Stuart Campbell. The donor of those prizes was not named in the AEA Handbook, like the donor of the prizes for essays on the housing of the poor the next year. Both the prize-winning essays on “Women Wage Earners” were published two years later, in 1893, but not by the AEA (de Graffenreid Reference de Graffenreid1893b, Campbell Reference Campbell and Ely1893)—even though Ely wrote an introduction to Campbell’s essay, which was published as a book (de Graffenreid’s shorter essay appeared in the magazine Forum).
By 1893 Ely had lost control of the AEA. In 1892 more conservative economists such as Henry W. Farnam of Yale forced Ely to step aside as AEA secretary (Coats Reference Coats1960; Rader Reference Rader1966, pp. 118–120). Ely’s critics were angered by his unilateral decision to hold the 1892 AEA meeting at Chautauqua at the time of the Chautauqua Summer School, a gathering associated with social reform and the social gospel (with active participation by female social workers and reformers), a setting out of keeping with their emerging vision of economics as a science separate from social reform, social work, or home economics. According to Rader (Reference Rader1966, p. 120), Ely “completely withdrew from the association in the midnineties. From 1893 to 1899 he did not attend a single convention, his name was dropped from the vice-presidency, and he even allowed his membership to lapse.” In 1894 Ely was tried by a special committee of the Board of Regents of the University of Wisconsin for teaching and practicing subversive economic principles (Rader Reference Rader1966, pp. 131–150), although in the end he was exonerated. The eclipse within the AEA of reformers such as Ely, associated with Wisconsin Progressivism and the German Historical School’s “socialism of the chair,” coincided with reduced visibility of women in the AEA’s publications and meetings, and with a long hiatus in the AEA’s essay competitions. After de Graffenreid (Reference de Graffenreid1890b), Coman (Reference Coman1891), and Balch (Reference Balch1893), no women were published in the Publications of the American Economic Association until the reform and conservative factions reached a compromise, and Ely became AEA president for 1900–1901. The AEA subsequently published Sewall (Reference Sewall1901), Coman (Reference Coman1903a), Gilman (Reference Gilman1907), and Eastman (Reference Eastman1909), but women largely disappeared from the programs of AEA meetings. There were two women among nineteen presenters and discussants at the AEA’s first meeting in 1885, one woman among nineteen in 1886, and two out of twenty-four at the fourth meeting in 1890—a proportion that, until 1970, was matched only in 1922, 1955, and 1957 (Dimand, Black, and Forget Reference Dimand, Black and Forget2011). No women were on the program as presenters or discussants in five of six AEA meetings from 1887 to 1894, or in twenty-six of thirty-six AEA meetings from 1899 to 1934 (full programs were not published for 1895 to 1898). Yet, five of the eighty-nine doctorates in political economy in the United States up to 1900 have been earned by women (Folbre Reference Folbre and Silverberg1998, p. 41), and women accounted for at least 9% and as much as 15% of doctorates in economics at US universities every year from 1912 to 1937 inclusive (Forget Reference Forget, Dimand, Dimand and Forget1995).
II. AN OUTSPOKEN INVESTIGATOR
Clare de Graffenreid was no stranger to controversy. She was born in Macon, Georgia, in 1849, to William Kirkland de Graffenreid, a lawyer who had been expelled from Yale College for fighting a duel, and Mary Holt Marsh. Her father opposed secession, but, once the Civil War began, supported the South and served as a colonel on the staff of Governor Joseph E. Brown’s administration. When the sixteen-year-old Clare de Graffenreid graduated at the head of her class from Wesleyan Female College in Macon in July 1865, she
cast aside the prepared valedictory address that had been approved by the faculty and bitterly attacked the Union troops who had recently occupied the city and were encamped near the college. As a consequence of her defiant gesture, the commanding officer, General James H. Wilson, ordered that Wesleyan be placed under guard and even threatened to close the institution (Steelman Reference Steelman and Steelman1966, p. 54).
After remaining in Georgia through Reconstruction, de Graffenreid moved to Washington, DC, in 1876, to teach Latin, literature, and mathematics at Georgetown Female Seminary (later Waverly Seminary). After a decade of teaching, during which she published an article (de Graffenreid Reference de Graffenreid1877) on the novelist George Elliot, she resigned in May 1886 when the Secretary of the Interior, Lucius Quintus Cincinnatus Lamar, a friend of Colonel de Graffenreid, appointed her as a copyist in the Patent Office. Two months later, Lamar named her an investigator in the newly formed Bureau of Labor of the Department of the Interior, directed by Colonel Carroll D. Wright, the first Commissioner of Labor and previously head of the Massachusetts Bureau of the Statistics of Labor, the first such state bureau (see Wright Reference Wright1886, Leiby Reference Leiby1960). In 1888, when the bureau became a separate Department of Labor (not yet with Cabinet rank), de Graffenreid was one of twenty special investigators working under Wright (Steelman Reference Steelman and James1971). She held the job until she retired at the end of July 1906, and in 1892 was sent to study the factory system and industrial education in Belgium (de Graffenreid Reference de Graffenreid1895a, Reference de Graffenreid1897a). Wright was an important sponsor for Graffenreid’s career: he served as president of the American Social Science Association, the American Statistical Association, the American Association for the Advancement of Science, and the Carnegie Institution, and was active in the early years of both the American Economic Association, contributing to its first series of publications (Wright Reference Wright1888, Clark et al. Reference Clark, Wright, Dewey, Hadley and Brooks1894), and the American Political Science Association. Although Wright had been a Union colonel in the Civil War, this created no problems for the daughter of a Confederate colonel—especially if the Confederate colonel was a personal friend of the Secretary of the Interior. Carroll Wright encouraged his subordinates, both male and female, to publish the results of their investigations and to present their findings at conferences. De Graffenreid lived with her brother, a lawyer, until his death in 1906. After his death and her retirement, she continued to live in Washington (where she was a close friend of the first wife of President Woodrow Wilson) and traveled in Europe, Africa, and Asia, but published no more.
Clare de Graffenreid’s prizewinning essays and her other publications presented the results of her work for the Bureau of Labor and its successors, on whose behalf she investigated the hours, wages, and conditions of employment of women and children (de Graffenreid Reference de Graffenreid1890a, Reference de Graffenreid1893b on women’s employment; 1890b on child labor; 1892 on the effect of working mothers on children’s well-being), housing conditions for the working class (de Graffenreid Reference de Graffenreid1895b, Reference de Graffenreid1897b), and related topics such as trade unions for women (de Graffenreid Reference de Graffenreid1893a). Many of her articles were given as public addresses, starting with “The Needs of Self-Supporting Women” (1890a), which was presented to the International Conference of the Women’s Christian Association in Baltimore and then accepted by Herbert Baxter Adams for publication in the Johns Hopkins University Studies in Historical and Political Science. In that paper, Clare de Graffenreid criticized the patronizing, “de haut en bas” attitude of philanthropists to the underprivileged, and urged upper-class Christian philanthropists to associate with the poor on terms of social equality. Her article “The New Woman and Her Debts” (1896c) was presented to the National Conference of Charities and Correction in New Haven, Connecticut, in May 1895, and to the graduating class of the Pratt Institute in Brooklyn (a school of industrial education for women), and she also addressed civic clubs, graduating classes, and Association of Working Girls’ Societies (de Graffenreid Reference de Graffenreid1890d; Steelman Reference Steelman and Steelman1966, p. 56). But, although she was a frequent public speaker and although she won two essay competitions sponsored by the American Economic Association, she was never on the program of the annual meeting of the AEA or of any of the other professional associations, such as the American Statistical Association, American Political Science Association, or American Sociological Association, that, starting with the American Historical Association in 1884, emerged out of the earlier American Social Science Association (ASSA). The ASSA, founded in 1865 in imitation of Britain’s National Association for the Promotion of Social Science, brought together two distinct groups: social workers and social activists, such as took part in the National Conference of Charities and Correction; and the more academically inclined members of the various social sciences into which political economy was dividing (see Furner Reference Furner1975, Haskell Reference Haskell1977, Ross Reference Ross1991). Although de Graffenreid won prizes from the AEA and published a prizewinning monograph in the Publications of the American Economic Association, her public addresses were to gatherings of the social reformers, not the associations of those who saw themselves as academic social scientists. Carroll Wright and the Bureau of Labor occupied an intermediate position, dealing with the social issues that concerned the reformers, but from an objective, quantitative standpoint, compiling statistics rather than advocating remedies (Wright Reference Wright1886, Leiby Reference Leiby1960). Thus, de Graffenreid (Reference de Graffenreid1890a, p. 81), addressing the Women’s Christian Association’s International Conference, held that “The Women’s Christian Associations represent the most powerful and progressive sentiment bent on good works and the broadest usefulness. Sentiment, however, is not always backed by knowledge of actual conditions.”
III. CHILD LABOR AND COTTON TEXTILE MILLS
The essays on child labor by Willoughby and de Graffenreid were reviewed in the Political Science Quarterly by Edward W. Bemis (Reference Bemis1891), who, despite the name of the journal, was an active economist (from 1891 to 1910, Bemis contributed five articles to the Quarterly Journal of Economics and three to the Journal of Political Economy). After noting Willoughby’s overview of the official statistics, Bemis (Reference Bemis1891, p. 189) continued:
The second paper is written by Miss de Graffenreid, who claims that ‘from personal observation in twenty states of over 100,000 working women and individual talks with 12,000,’ she ‘has become acquainted with the forerunning signs of every form of early death ascribable to overwork in youth.’ Her essay is an interesting and really impressive account of the extent and evils, particularly physical and mental, of child labor as it exists to-day in the United States. The essay is thus an excellent supplement to that of Mr. Willoughby. It brings out two important points with much force: (1) the extent to which children are kept out of school and from needed sunlight and play to help parents at home; and (2) the growth of child labor in the Southern factories, which threatens to furnish a plausible excuse for competing Northern manufacturers in their resistance to a decrease of child labor at home. The extent to which parents, through ignorance, selfishness and poverty, and the children themselves, through the unattractiveness and poverty of the public schools in some states, favour and even insist on child labor, is well demonstrated. Taken together, these two monographs combine a valuable array of facts and deductions which, though not new in most cases to economists, will be both new and startling to the majority of the reading public, and will be likely to aid materially the rising demand for more effective restriction of child labor.
De Graffenreid (Reference de Graffenreid1890b, pp. 241–243) reported interviewing 304 white operatives in Georgia cotton textile mills, so her controversial “Georgia Cracker in the Cotton Mills,” in which she combined anecdotes and statistics to deplore both child labor and the neglect of children by working mothers in textile mills in her native Georgia, followed directly from her AEA monograph (de Graffenreid Reference de Graffenreid1891a, Reference de Graffenreid1891b; Whites Reference Whites1988). At one blow, de Graffenreid affronted Southern mill-owners (as represented by the Manufacturers’ Record), Georgia Populists (as represented by the weekly Wool Hat), and Southern advocates of (white) women’s right to employment, notably Rebecca Latimer Felton of the Georgia Women’s Christian Temperance Union and the United Daughters of the Confederacy, a powerful figure among Georgia Democrats since the 1870s, when she managed her husband’s successful campaign for the US Senate. According to Whites (Reference Whites1988, p. 478),
Rebecca Felton recognized, as De Graffenreid did not, that in the southern context the logic of a progressive solution to the problem of labor threatened the hierarchical divisions of race. In a choice between labor reform or maintenance of the racial status quo, Felton assumed that the mill workers would choose to maintain their superior position over the blacks. Similarly, she believed that if the choice was between their reputation for feminine virtue and the possibility of labor reform, mill workers would agree that the ‘sorest spot of all’ was not poor working conditions but attacks such as those made by De Graffenreid on their domestic self-respect. The state’s mill workers who collected $60.00 to have a plaque placed on Rebecca Felton’s grave in gratitude for her defense of their honor in the controversy certainly seem to have taken this position.
For a contrast to the white supremacist assumptions of both de Graffenreid and Felton, see “Colored Women as Wage-earners” (Cooper Reference Cooper1899) by Anna Julia Cooper, a Southern black contemporary of theirs who eventually received a doctorate from the Sorbonne (Cooper Reference Cooper1892, Reference Cooper1925, Reference Cooper, Lemert and Bhan1998).
IV. DE GRAFFENREID, CAMPBELL, AND WOMEN WAGE-EARNERS
In 1891 Clare de Graffenreid again won an American Economic Association essay competition, this time on “Women Wage-earners.” In the 1889 essay competition on child labor, de Graffenreid had shared the prize with Willoughby, but two years later she received the first prize of $300 for her essay, subsequently published in the social reform magazine Forum (de Graffenreid Reference de Graffenreid1893b). The second prize of $200 went to Helen Stuart Campbell for a much longer manuscript, which was published as a series of six articles in the monthly magazine Arena and also as a book with an introduction by Richard T. Ely of the University of Wisconsin, the secretary of the AEA from 1886 to 1892 (Campbell Reference Campbell and Ely1893). The works by both de Graffenreid (Reference de Graffenreid1893b) and Campbell (Reference Campbell and Ely1893) were descriptive studies, marshaling statistics and anecdotal observations about the extent of women’s paid employment in the US, what kinds of jobs women held, what wages they received (and how those wages compared to men’s wages), and the effect of factory employment on women’s health and on the care their children received. For de Graffenreid’s essay to be judged superior to Campbell’s (and, of course, to the other entries) by the AEA’s panel of judges was a considerable achievement: Helen Campbell was a well-established writer known for her books and newspaper articles on impoverished women wage-earners (Campbell Reference Campbell1887, Reference Campbell1889). Richard Ely was so impressed by Campbell’s work that, beyond writing the introduction to her 1893 book, he arranged for her to give two series of lectures on “Household Economics” and “Social Science” at the University of Wisconsin (the first series of lectures was published as Campbell [Reference Campbell1896]), with her payment privately fundraised by Ely, and he successfully recommended her to a newly elected Populist governor for appointment as professor of household economics at Kansas State Agricultural College (see also Dimand Reference Dimand2000). Such topics helped create a limited space for women in the emerging discipline of economics, as in the case of Louise Creighton’s LSE lectures published in 1907 as The Economics of the Household (Creighton Reference Creighton1907). However, in 1916 AER editor Davis R. Dewey summarily rejected a suggestion from Theodora Cunningham that the journal add “a Women’s Department of household economics” (Bernstein Reference Bernstein2008, p. 1010). The role of Richard Ely as Campbell’s sponsor in the economics profession paralleled Carroll Wright’s support of de Graffenreid’s career; in contrast, Katharine Coman, secure at a women’s college, had no need for such male sponsorship.Footnote 2
V. PRIZEWINNING FEMALE ECONOMISTS IN THE NINETEENTH AND EARLY TWENTIETH CENTURIES
Prize essay competitions provided several female economists with a path to scholarly publication and a degree of professional recognition in the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, although such prizes led to regular academic positions in economics only for post-1920 prizewinners Hazel Kyrk and Dorothy Wolff Douglas. Clémence Royer’s two-volume treatise on the theory of taxation (Royer Reference Royer1862) was published as an “ouvrage couronné par le Conseil d’état du canton de Vaud” in the same year as her translation of Darwin’s Origin of Species, and several chapters from her work on taxation were published in Italian translation in Turin in 1868 in the prestigious series Bibliotheca dell’economista (see Fraisse Reference Fraisse1985, and Forget’s entry on Royer in Dimand, Dimand, and Forget Reference Dimand, Dimand and Forget2000). Julie-Victoire Daubié managed, in 1862, to be the first woman permitted to take the baccalaureate examination, thanks to the support of the Empress Eugénie, but also thanks to having a prize from the Academy of Lyons in 1859 for her essay La femme pauvre au XIXe siècle, published as a series of articles in the Journal des économistes in 1862 and 1863 and as a book in 1866 (see Daubié Reference Daubié1866; and Christine Ivory’s entry on Daubié in Dimand, Dimand, and Forget Reference Dimand, Dimand and Forget2000). Royer and Daubié received scholarly and public recognition and publication following their prizes, but not academic positions: until after World War II, the only woman to hold a professorship in France was Marie Curie, named to her late husband’s chair several years after the first of her two Nobel Prizes. Hazel Kyrk won the $1000 Hart, Schaffner & Marx Prize for research in economics for her University of Chicago doctoral dissertation, published as The Theory of Consumption (Kyrk Reference Kyrk1923). Her application of economic principles to consumption and the household is now considered (along with the work of Margaret Reid) as part of the Chicago background to Gary Becker’s “new home economics.” With the help of that recognition, Kyrk returned to the University of Chicago from Iowa State College in 1925, with a joint appointment in the departments of Economics and Home Economics (full professor from 1941), the first woman appointed to Chicago’s Department of Economics (although not the first female economist in the university, because she was preceded by Edith Abbott and Sophonisba Breckenridge when the School of Civics and Philanthropy became the university’s Graduate School of Social Service Administration, with Abbott, author of nineteen JPE articles, as dean, and Breckenridge, author of eight JPE articles, as a full professor). Yetta Scheftel, who had received a University of Chicago MA in sociology in 1907 with a thesis on “Persistence of Poverty,” also won the Hart, Schaffner & Marx Prize with a book on The Taxation of Land Value (Scheftel Reference Scheftel1916), but made no further appearance in the scholarly literature (see Madden, Seiz, and Pujol Reference Madden, Seiz and Pujol2004). Dorothy Wolff Douglas, later a Smith College economics professor and radical economist, coauthored (with her then-husband, Paul Douglas of the Cobb–Douglas production function) one of the two Kestrel Prize essays on “What Can a Man Afford?” that were published as a supplement to the American Economic Review (Douglas and Douglas Reference Douglas and Douglas1921), almost the last prize essays published by the American Economic Association (a Babson Prize Essay on “Forecasting the Price of Hogs” was published as an AER supplement in 1925).
VI. WOMEN IN THE PUBLICATIONS OF THE AMERICAN ECONOMIC ASSOCIATION
Clare de Graffenreid was the first of four women to publish substantial monographs in the three series of Publications of the American Economic Association that preceded the emergence of the American Economic Review in 1911. There were also a few shorter pieces, notably Crystal Eastman (Reference Eastman1909) on industrial accidents and a comment by Charlotte Perkins Gilman (Reference Gilman1907). Hannah Robie Sewall’s 1898 University of Minnesota doctoral dissertation The Theory of Value before Adam Smith was published by the AEA in 1901 (reissued in Kelley’s Reprints of Economic Classics in 1968 and 1971), her first publication—at the age of forty (Sewall Reference Sewall1901). The same year, Carroll D. Wright hired her as a special agent to investigate child labor (Sewall Reference Sewall1904). In 1903 the AEA published a monograph on the “History of Contract Labor in the Hawaiian Islands” (Coman Reference Coman1903a) by Katharine Coman, since 1883 a professor of political economy at Wellesley College—the first woman to hold an economics professorship in any country and the only woman at the organizing meeting of the AEA in 1885 (see Robin Bartlett on Coman in Dimand, Dimand, and Forget Reference Dimand, Dimand and Forget2000). Like her books on The Industrial History of the United States (1903b) and The Economic Beginnings of the Far West (1912), Coman’s monograph on Hawaiian labor was reprinted long after her death. Already in 1891, she published a short article on “The Tailoring Trade and the Sweating System” in the proceedings of the AEA’s fourth annual meeting (Coman Reference Coman1891), and she contributed to the second volume of the Journal of Political Economy (Coman Reference Coman1893), later publishing in the Journal of the American Statistical Association and the Economic Journal. Fittingly, in 1911 (when Edith Abbott was the first woman to serve as AEA vice-president) Coman wrote the lead article in the first issue of the American Economic Review, and then, the next month, published an article in the first conference supplement to the American Economic Review (Coman Reference Coman1911a, Reference Coman1911b), both articles derived from her then-forthcoming two-volume work on the early economic history of the western US (Coman Reference Coman1912). A year later, Emily Greene Balch contributed to two roundtable discussions published in the AER’s second conference supplement, and Edith Abbott (Reference Abbott1913a, Reference Abbott1913b) published in the AER’s third volume. Like Clare de Graffenreid and Helen Campbell, Katharine Coman spoke at Chautauqua and published in the Chautauquan, but, unlike them, Coman was a university graduate (from the University of Michigan) with a secure position as a full professor and department head, publishing in all the leading English-language professional journals in economics. Coman’s younger colleague Emily Greene Balch, whose book-length monograph on “Public Assistance of the Poor in France” was published by the AEA in 1893 as a double-issue of its first series of publications (Balch Reference Balch1893), is also noteworthy as a prizewinner, although not of a prize awarded by the American Economic Association: she shared the Nobel Peace Prize in 1946 for the same antiwar activism for which she was not reappointed at Wellesley College after eighteen years as a full professor of economics and sociology (see Balch Reference Balch and Randall1972; Dimand, Dimand, and Forget Reference Dimand, Dimand and Forget2000). She was thus the first economist to win a Nobel Prize, although Léon Walras was a candidate in 1905 (Sandmo Reference Sandmo2007), and John Maynard Keynes was considered for the Peace Prize for his critique of the Versailles Peace Treaty. Not until 2009 did another female political economist, Elinor Ostrom, win the Royal Bank of Sweden Prize in Economic Science in Memory of Alfred Nobel.
As with de Graffenreid’s mission to Belgium in 1892, Balch (Reference Balch1893) and Coman (Reference Coman1915) studied social programs in Europe as guides to social reform in the United States (William F. Willougby also published four QJE articles on French labor legislation from 1898 to 1901). De Graffenreid’s and Campbell’s writings, like Sewall (Reference Sewall1904) and the only AEA contribution by the feminist writer Charlotte Perkins Gilman (Reference Gilman1907), dealt with traditional “women’s issues” such as child labor, women’s wages, and working-class housing conditions. The employment of de Graffenreid and Sewall by the Bureau of Labor presumably influenced their choice of topic: Sewall’s dissertation on The Theory of Value before Adam Smith (Sewall Reference Sewall1901), written before she joined the bureau, was not on such a topic, while Coman and Balch, teaching at a leading private college for women, ranged far beyond such topics.
The American Economic Association was predominantly, but not entirely, male in its early years: there were 7 women among the 182 members in 1886, and 59 women among 1510 members in 1910 (see Forget Reference Forget, Dimand, Dimand and Forget1995; Folbre Reference Folbre and Silverberg1998; Dimand, Black, and Forget Reference Dimand, Dimand and Forget2011). The women, although not nearly as numerous as the men in the AEA, were noteworthy: Katharine Coman, the eminent economic historian and teacher of economics who published the first AER article (Coman Reference Coman1911a); Emily Greene Balch, the Nobel laureate, pacifist, and defender of the economic, social, and cultural value of immigration (Balch Reference Balch and Randall1972); Helen Stuart Campbell, denouncer of women’s poverty and pioneer of household economics (and mentor of such feminists as Charlotte Perkins Gilman); Hannah Robie Sewall, the distinguished historian of economic thought who became an investigator of child labor; and, no less interesting than the others, Clare de Graffenreid, the outspoken social investigator and reformer, and the only person to win more than one of the AEA’s prize essay competitions. Some women were also involved in the early days of other national economic associations, such as Clara Collet, the only person to publish in both the first and the fiftieth volume of the Economic Journal, who was a member of the Council of the Royal Economic Society from 1918 until 1941 and of the Council of the Royal Statistical Society from 1919 to 1935. Caroline Healey Dall served on the executive committee of the American Social Science Association from its formation in 1865 until 1905, initially as a director and from 1880 as a vice-president (Dall Reference Dall1914, Dimand Reference Dimand2000). Clare de Graffenreid’s position among these pioneers has been largely overlooked (even by Dimand, Dimand, and Forget Reference Dimand, Dimand and Forget2000, although that will change with the second edition) because the sparse literature on her (Steelman Reference Steelman and Steelman1966, Reference Steelman and James1971; Whites Reference Whites1988) has been interested in the furor over “The Georgia Cracker in the Cotton Mills” rather than in de Graffenreid’s winning of two AEA prize essay competitions. A rich heritage of women’s participation in economics is being rediscovered (as documented in that marvellous resource, Madden, Seiz, and Pujol Reference Madden, Seiz and Pujol2004), and Clare de Graffenreid—and Edith Abbott, Emily Greene Balch, Helen Bosanquet (author of ten Economic Journal articles, including one in the journal’s first volume), Sophonisba Breckenridge, Helen Campbell, Clara Collet, Katharine Coman, Anna Julia Cooper, to go no further in the alphabet—contributed to that heritage.
