No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 31 January 2005
This book is the second of a three-volume series, which, in the author's words, addresses “the role of certain forms of change in human population history.” Specifically, the author's aim is to establish that demographic phenomena are subject to regular growth patterns. The most important pattern, by far, that he identifies is a constant proportionate decrease in the growth rate leading eventually to zero growth (an improved version of the Lotka logistic curve). The author calls this the G curve. His position is that most historical demographic phenomena have followed the G form or occasionally, what he calls the G1 form, which is the first derivative of G. The alternatives, the E curve where the growth rate accelerates; the F curve where the growth rate is constant and the H curve where the growth rate decelerates more slowly than in G are, according to the author, rarely encountered, and never before 1500. The first volume aimed to demonstrate that natural increase followed this pattern in most cases. This volume attempts to demonstrate that the same pattern applies to migration.
In order to demonstrate the point, Harris examines a very large amount of data from an impressive number of publications. He demonstrates that growth rates followed a G pattern in the growth of variables as diverse as emigration streams, emigrant populations, many of the different slave trades, and the growth of urban populations. More controversially, for example, he also shows that the share of children in emigrant populations, the gender composition of slave cargos, and the time taken by slave voyages also followed a G curve pattern.
This approach raises several issues. The fundamental question is obvious. Like trees, no variable can grow indefinitely; the G pattern must be true by definition because the growth rate must slow down or decline. Hence, the observation that this occurs in a large number of cases may have little historical value. Secondly, Harris argues that the pattern is determined by demographic growth patterns (which he discussed in the first volume of the series). In other words, Harris argues that history, including, for example, technical change and the development of the international economy, does not matter. This seems difficult to reconcile with what we know about the causes of emigration streams and other variables—including those variables mentioned previously. To take one example, the author explains the common timing of emigration flows from Britain to Australia, New Zealand, and the United States in the late nineteenth century by demographic developments in Britain. (p. 40).
There is also a problem with the G pattern itself. Many of the variables show, not G pattern growth, but a series of G pattern growth curves—i.e., alternating periods of faster and slower growth. This pattern intuitively fits historical reality, but it is not clear if it is compatible with the author's position that a G pattern dominates.
Hence, we have a book that is not historical but structured around the shape of the growth curves of variables. It seems at $99.99 a rather expensive way of discovering these patterns.