
Only a few months into my first sabbatical leave from the history department at the University of Virginia, my husband accepted a new job and we unexpectedly decided to relocate to Washington, DC. Knowing how important community is to productive scholarship, I scrambled to find an office in the DC area, but I had already missed every fellowship deadline in my field. Then a contact at a DC think tank mentioned APSA's Centennial Center, which had ample room for scholars in the marvelous neighborhood of Dupont Circle.
Though I am a historian rather than a political scientist, my specialty is American political history. My first book, Goddess of the Market: Ayn Rand and the American Right (Oxford, 2009), is an intellectual biography of the famous libertarian novelist and philosopher that charts her influence upon the conservative movement and her impact on seminal figures like Alan Greenspan. For years, I've been a regular at the Policy History Conference, a semi-annual conference at which historians and political scientists meet, greet, and collaborate. Through seminars and talks sponsored by UVA's Miller Center of Public Affairs, I have come to appreciate the overlap between political science and history and how the border between the two disciplines can be the site of innovative scholarship and unexpected insight. For all these reasons, I thought that a residency at the Centennial Center would be immensely beneficial to my work, and I was thrilled when APSA accepted my application for a 10-month stay and offered me additional support through the Warren Miller Fellowship for Electoral Affairs.
At the Centennial Center, I've found the time and resources needed to transition from one major project to the next. Rand drew my attention because she was the rare intellectual who managed to create a social movement around her ideas. I was also intrigued by how her ideas about religion and morality clashed with the beliefs of many conservatives, even as their economic ideas were similar. My next work builds on these dynamics to examine the longer history of American conservative thought and the political coalition that underlies its success.
Modern American conservatism has often been described as a “marriage of convenience” between free-market thinkers and conservative Christians who are brought together on the grounds of political expediency. As such, the durability and cohesiveness of political conservatism is always subject to question, particularly by liberal commentators. But periodically, libertarians, too, become restive with this political alliance, and conservatives worry about a “conservative crack up.” At these moments of crisis, both conservatives and their opponents wonder how long this unstable coalition can last.
My project looks beyond these periodic rumblings to the longer history of Anglo-American thought, tracing out the ways in which free market thought and Christian social beliefs came to be seen as reinforcing rather than contradictory. Although there is a rich literature on the historic origins and development of progressivism, little scholarly work has been done on the other side of this story. I begin my inquiry by tracing the shifting fortunes of a key intellectual concept, the idea of objective truth. In the late nineteenth century, the idea of objective, unitary truth was undermined by developments in science, particularly Darwinian evolution, which transformed the intellectual landscape. By the close of the nineteenth century, most intellectual elites had signed on to the modernist questioning of absolutes, which would culminate in a political philosophy of liberalism that was experimental, experiential, and fundamentally pragmatic. Standing alone in defense of the older ideal of objective truth were two significant parties: classical economists and fundamentalist religious believers.
In the twentieth century, political radicalism gave free-market thinkers and conservative Christians a shared enemy and served to reinforce the profound similarities between the two. Fears of revolution—grounded in very real political change on the European continent—ultimately became a loaded and powerful rhetorical strategy in domestic politics. These fears became politically operative by drawing on a shared assumption that deviation from established truths would serve to loose anarchy upon the world. Within the American political context, movement away from individualism and free markets marked the slippery slope to socialism. Within conservative religious circles, Biblical interpretation or theological modernism became a menace that could dethrone Christian revelation from its central place in Western culture and make it into just another ethical teaching among many. Both sides thus united in the conviction that the search for absolute truth—and the grounding of politics upon that truth, be it economic or spiritual—was the fundamental task to which they as citizens and political actors must commit.
Although my project is historical in nature, it holds insights relevant to our understanding of contemporary politics—most significantly a caution to those who would assume that the political alliance between social conservatives and free-market thinkers is weak and near collapse. Building on recent scholarship that traces the institutional connections between Christianity and free market thought, my work underscores these connections on the deepest cognitive and structural levels. Second, my project proposes both a theoretical and empirical way of thinking about political coalition building that can inform our understanding on the state and local level, as well as in other democratic countries. Finally, tracing the underlying sinews of the conservative coalition suggests that recent hand-wringing about the negative tone of politics obscures the way in which Manichean views of the world undergird conservative rhetoric more broadly and serve to cement the allegiance of both base and non-aligned voters by drawing clear and simple contrasts between not just political parties, but also the broadly figured categories of “liberal” and “conservative.”
At base, the goal of my scholarship is tracing how ideas move from the elite circles of their creators, attract adherents and a broader base of support, and finally manifest themselves in our everyday assumptions about markets, morality, and governance. Should I forget how important intellectual history is to the shaping of policy and politics, I need only look on the walls of my Centennial Center office at the framed political cartoons of Woodrow Wilson.
Research Funding Available
APSA sponsors a number of funds to help finance research. Many of these funds can support your stay at the Centennial Center or elsewhere.
Rita Mae Kelly Fund
Supports research on the intersection of gender, race, ethnicity, and political power.
The Presidency Research Fund
Provides supplemental support for examination of the presidency.
Special Study for the Study of Women and Politics
Provides supplemental support for the study of women and politics.
Warren E. Miller Fellowship for Electoral Politics
Provides supplemental support for research residencies in national and comparative electoral politics.
Ed Artinian Endowment for Advancing Publishing
Provides supplemental support to assist young scholars in publishing their research.
Fund for Latino Scholarship
Provides support to individuals or programs that promote the recruitment, retention, and promotion of Latino and Latina political scientists.
James Bryce Fund for International Political Science
Provides supplemental support for research residencies, collaborative research workshops, and teaching and curriculum development programs for emerging political science communities.
Additional Funding Opportunities
To see all available funding opportunities offered by APSA, please visit http://www.apsanet.org/centennialcenter.
