Scholars interested in Venezuela, press freedom or popular politics will find Naomi Schiller's book Channeling the State a carefully argued political ethnography of the transformation of the state in Venezuela. Schiller succeeds in capturing the micropolitics crafted between community-media producers and the Venezuelan state. Schiller, an anthropologist with a keen eye for detail, grasps the state as a ‘messy collection of ideas, practices, individuals and institutions’ (p. 4), as well as an unfinished process in which social movements participate actively in figuring out what the state means and how to co-produce what the state can become. Schiller's main argument is that these rich flows of relations between community-media producers and the state embody a mode of statecraft.
The book is retrospective. It draws on fieldwork Schiller conducted between 2006 and 2007 in Caracas, at Catia TVe: the most renowned community television station in Venezuela. Catia TVe transitioned from being a film club that started in 1989 in the barrio of Manicomio in Caracas, to a television station operating clandestinely for a few years, and finally in 2001 to the first community television station in Venezuela to obtain a broadcast licence. Catia TVe's operations and content are run by mostly self-trained residents from the poor urban communities of Catia and Caño Amarillo in the western side of Caracas. Barrio residents embraced media to counteract negative images of barrios by Venezuelan corporate television while demystifying media production as a field reserved for a technically skilled elite. A quick search on YouTube shows how Catia TVe broadcasts the everyday life, events, rallies and voices of the urban poor committed to a Chavista line. However, Channeling the State debunks popular views on this media outlet as a pawn of the state. Schiller shows the manifold struggles Catia TVe faces to assert its autonomy in a politically polarised context and its reliance on the state's financial support. One of the key messages of the book is that the relationships between the state and Catia TVe are imbued with ‘radical interdependency’ (p. 17). That is, the state and social movements need each other in shifting ways while engaging in ‘mutual instrumentality’ (p. 17). However, implicit in the analysis lies the question of to what extent social movements such as Catia TVe can be truly autonomous under this radical interdependency or are doomed to be co-opted. The answer is not straightforward. Channeling the State is cogent in refusing binary approaches and interpretations; early in the introduction Schiller dissolves the limits embedded in ‘bottom-up’ and ‘top-down’ approaches to analyse the state and civil society relations by inviting us to grasp the breadth of these relations as dialectical.
In six ethnographic chapters, Schiller amplifies the voices and intersecting positionalities of her informants who grapple with a contradictory state. Chapter 1 lays out the energetic start of Catia TVe after Venezuela's biggest uprising, in 1989, known as ‘El Caracazo’. Schiller notes that the political climate under the government of Hugo Chávez (1998–2013) enabled Catia TVe to contribute to the process of state formation while cognisant that its movement could be co-opted. Chapter 2 deftly explores how Catia TVe navigates the thorny lines between its autonomy, state financial support and commitment to the Bolivarian project. Chapter 3 skilfully shows spaces for both solidarities and tensions that arise between members of Catia TVe and ViVe TV – a state-funded television station – due to class divisions and power hierarchies. Chapter 4 is a fascinating account of how Catia TVe navigated the ambiguous strategic uses of the term ‘el pueblo’ under the Bolivarian Revolution. Schiller disentangles ‘el pueblo’ as a catch-all label used by Hugo Chávez to ignite popular participation as well as unite disparate groups under loyalties to the Bolivarian project. While ‘el pueblo’ enabled popular participation, such a definition quickly became self-serving. It crushed dissidence in the Chavista ranks, facilitated the centralisation of decision-making and furthered the dynamics of patronage that the government discursively rejected.
Chapter 5 offers a refreshing intersectional analysis. It captures the everyday experiences of women in Catia TVe while being attentive to the intersections of race, class, gender and sexuality. Schiller notes that men in Catia TVe devoted more energy to challenging class inequalities while being less willing to critique gendered inequalities. She shows how men prevented women from asserting themselves in positions of leadership, public speaking and gaining confidence in executing technical tasks. Chapter 6 explores what the Catia TVe movement understood as press freedom. Schiller's informants note that liberal notions of press freedom – understood as complete autonomy from the state – are too narrow to embrace how the state ‘might expand poor communities’ access to rights and resources to participate in media production’ (p. 206). The conclusion offers reflections on the start of the crisis in Venezuela and Catia TVe's loss of momentum during the early years of Nicolás Maduro's tenure.
The strength of Schiller's Channeling the State is her reflexivity and textured treatment of popular politics in Venezuela. She offers a fine-grained analysis of the early cementation of contradictory practices by a new elite under the Bolivarian Revolution. Schiller's ethnography is an excellent scholarly addition that scaffolds our understanding of how Venezuela reached its current profound crisis. Similarly, this is a novel anthropological work on press freedom. It shows how statecraft strategies to diversify perspectives in the media by community producers wrestle uneasily with the state's resistance to structurally redistribute power. After reading the book I wondered if Catia TVe producers too hastily claimed the Bolivarian Revolution was committed to sowing the practices for meaningful inclusion and social change that it sought to reap. Perhaps instead, for their own survival, they overlooked how the state planted the seeds for refined modes of centralisation while quelling dissent and bolstering patronage. This paradox will resonate with scholars and activists interested in Venezuela, social movements, the state and the media.
