The combination of violin and cello has contributed relatively little to the canon, save for a few examples: Ravel’s Sonata (1922), Kodály’s Duo op. 7 (1922) and Johan Halvorsen’s Passacaglia (1896), an arrangement for violin and cello of the Passacaille from Handel’s Suite in G minor HWV 432. This is even more true of double concertos for violin and cello. Apart from a handful of eighteenth-century works by Vivaldi, J. C. Bach and others, the only canonic contender is the concerto by Brahms.Footnote 1 But in fact there is a not inconsiderable repertoire of duos for violin and cello from the nineteenth century, written for players with a wide range of technical ability from the modestly gifted amateur to the virtuoso. In general, such works were composed by performing string players for their own use. The Ravel Duo may well be the first important chamber work for this combination by a non-string-playing composer (Halvorsen was a violinist; Kodály played both instruments). Some were composed by two players, such as Andreas and Berhard Romberg, Anton and Max Bohrer, Adrien Servais with Hubert Léonard or Joseph Ghys, or, as here, Frédéric Kummer and François Schubert. Others were by a single composer, whether a violinist such as Viotti, Campagnoli or Spohr, or a cellist like Bréval or, again, Kummer. The violin/cello duo was frequently a vehicle for technical display for one or both instruments; Campagnoli’s op. 6 collection of duos is full of violin virtuosity, rather at the expense of the cello.Footnote 2 The anecdote about Crosdill and Viotti performing for the Queen of France highlights another cellist’s virtuosity. For some reason Viotti failed to appear, so Duport, ‘an artist in a thousand’, read the violin part on the cello at sight, ‘better than Viotti himself could have played it’.Footnote 3
Friedrich Kummer (1797–1879) was a prominent cellist from the first half of the nineteenth century, studying with J. J. F. Dotzauer, and teaching in his turn equally influential cellists such as Bernhard Cossmann and Julius Goltermann. When Friedrich Grützmacher succeeded him as principal cello in the Leipzig Gewandhaus, there were those who preferred Kummer’s superior tone. Kummer was more enthusiastic about vibrato than his Dresden predecessors Dotzauer and Romberg, treating it as an aspect of tone rather than as simply an ornament. His cello method and studies are of interest, and this pedagogical material is still in use. However, his published teaching does not deal with the often extravagantly virtuosic techniques found in these duos. François Schubert (1808–1878) played quartets with Kummer and led the Dresden orchestra from 1861. He composed several violin works including operatic divertissements and sets of variations on operatic themes; some piano works were also published under his name, but it may have been a pseudonym for someone else. Although he appears to be a less substantial figure than Kummer, this is not reflected in the violin writing, which is every bit as virtuosic as that for cello.
This duo repertoire has been very little performed or recorded in modern times, probably because its combination of virtuoso techniques with popular forms (variations on operatic themes, fantasias on national airs) that are seen as less substantial than sonatas or concertos. The range of textures in these duos is an essential part of their appeal. Extravagant combinations of double stops, octaves, harmonics, rich accompanying harmonies from the cello, trills, up-bow staccato, spiccato, jeté – every trick at the virtuoso’s disposal is used here. The thematic material is not particularly characterful (to be kind), but the sheer élan of the technical dexterity on show here goes a long way to make up for this. Sometimes the overall sonority is almost orchestral, as in Kummer’s duo on Swiss themes. It should be noted that the popular genre of the Nationallied (Kummer wrote such works on Russian and Tyrolean themes) was taken seriously by Bernhard Romberg, who singled it out for attention in his 1840 Violoncellschule.
The technical requirements are considerable, and this recording by Eichhorn and Hülshoff is exemplary in this respect. These performances are superb examples of modern string playing. Technically impeccable, with totally unanimous ensemble, beautifully balanced, these remarkable players are recorded quite close but with no hint of any rough edges. It is obvious that they are entirely uninfluenced by any of the research on nineteenth-century performance practices that has emerged in recent decades. Readers of Nineteenth-Century Music Review will know where they stand on this issue, but it is worth saying that the performances convey a sense of sheer enthusiasm at all times. I listened to this disk with total delight, but I would still very much like to hear some of this unfamiliar repertoire – perhaps the duos by the Bohrer brothers? – given a full HIP treatment.
W.H. Squire (1871–1963) was one of the most important British cellists of the early twentieth century, but his playing style was more firmly rooted in the nineteenth. His numerous recordings – he was one of the first cellists to exploit the new technology, and his 1898 recording of Thomas’s Simple Aveu remained popular for many years – show that although he could play with considerable sentiment, he also had a very secure technique. His reputation beyond Britain is evidenced in his being the dedicatee of the cello version of Fauré’s Sicilienne. Squire’s recording of the Elgar concerto with Hamilton Harty (also his regular piano accompanist) and the Hallé makes a fascinating contrast with that of Beatrice Harrison with the composer, both recorded in 1928. Her more sophisticated style is perhaps more attuned to the 1920s, while much in Squire’s performance would have been familiar to a cellist of the previous generation or even earlier. Nonetheless, Henry Wood admired the playing of his favoured principal cellist, ‘Billy’ Squire.
Squire was an active composer of works for the cello and of songs (he shares the latter genre with two other prominent cellists, Alfredo Piatti and Karl Davidoff). Oliver Gledhill performs 20 of his attractive cello compositions here. Many of these became standard works for graded music examinations – four are in the current ABRSM syllabus. They are generally light, charming pieces, and even when they appear more technically challenging (such as the Tarantella, or the Humoreske op. 26) or use harmonics (natural in the Gavotte humoristique op. 6, artificial in Tzig-Tzig), they mostly remain well within the scope of the amateur cellist, although Tzig-Tzig would challenge many. However, to play them with the skill and stylistic sensitivity shown here requires an altogether higher level of skill. Gledhill’s familiarity with the portamento of the period is evident in every piece where it is appropriate. Regarding Gledhill’s informative liner notes, I would only point out that although the so-called ‘L-shift’ (a slide using the finger for the last note) is more common later in the nineteenth century onwards, there are many earlier notated examples of a same-finger shift, which has a very similar effect, and many of Friedrich Grützmacher’s notated portamenti imply an ‘L-shift’. In addition to Squire’s own recordings, he also published editions of other pieces with additional detailed fingering that clearly entails its use. If anything, I would say that Gledhill’s portamento is more refined than at least some of Squire’s own recorded examples, which attracted specific negative criticism at least twice in the 1920s.Footnote 4 Gledhill’s accompanist Tadashi Imai matches him to perfection, vividly setting the mood of the piece with just a few introductory bars. This recording conveys very well the simple charm of this repertoire, and I hope that other cellists will be encouraged to explore it further.
