Some years ago, a wise tutor advised me, when I was embarking on a piece of research, not just to look for new facts, but to try to shift perspectives. In many respects, Avis' latest contribution to historical and ecumenical theology is a good example of just that. Of course the reader is treated to a predictably learned and well-annotated monograph containing many facts which may have been unknown or unfamiliar. But the principal motivation behind the writing of this book seems to be to blend together three familiar trajectories in this kind of work in theology.
One is to push further at the way the Reformation is as much about continuity with its medieval past as it is about discontinuity from it. In the face of a new romanticism in certain quarters, which tends to view the Reformation as one big mistake, Avis relies on recent studies, by such scholars as Nigel Biggar, to show how, for example, Aquinas' legacy of natural law influenced all the reformers in different ways. This was not exactly a top priority for an earlier school of teaching ecclesiastical history. Second, Avis examines the development of the conciliar movement in the later Middle Ages, from the time of the Great Schism onwards, as a necessary background to such Reformation figures as King James VI and I, with his desire for an ecumenical council to settle Europe's theological differences. The third strand in this book is the ecumenical significance of these studies for today's continuing ecumenical dialogues – a subject near to Avis' heart and an area over which he has laboured for many years, long before he took up his present post at the Council for Christian Unity for the Church of England, in London.
In this quest, there are a few casualties to the need for brevity in background: for example, I would question whether Augustine really did have little interest in the bigger picture of ecclesiology (p. 20). But the overall thrust of the book is remarkably coherent, given the breadth and range of material. Opening with Von Htigel's three ‘elements in religion’, the mystical, the intellectual and the institutional, which lie between the lines of many a page thereafter, Avis embraces Catholic and Protestant approaches, not fearing to put his Anglican oar in from time to time. He even addresses Anglicanism's current difficulties over gender and sexuality – which to a greater or lesser extent are mirrored in most other international Churches, whether they are prepared to admit it or not. And the fact that the conciliar movement really came alive again at a time when the Western Church was threatened with two (or more) papacies has something of an irony about it:
Christians need to find structures of constructive debate in the sight of God in order to thrash out their differences if they possibly can.
As I read of the movement's prophets, like John of Paris, and then went on to learn more of its exponents, like Dietrich of Niem then Nicholas of Cusa's more ambivalent attitude, I was struck more forcibly than before by a feature of Roman Catholicism that a friendly outsider can easily identify as both a great strength and a great weakness – the need for loyalty to the Holy See, seemingly at all costs. Avis' subsequent narrative shows how doomed the conciliar movement came to be in the face of an ever more assertive papacy, as well as how the majority of the first generation of Reformers came originally from the religious orders and were conciliarists by inclination, having their roots in that mainstream tradition of medieval Catholicism and not the more off-beat, break-away groups, such as the Cathars and the Lollards.
The Reformation chapters throw unfamiliar light on the conciliar tendencies of Luther and Calvin, though Avis struggles to make a great deal of Luther's ecclesiological instincts, which were (admittedly) more concerned with Von Hligel's mystical and intellectual elements, rather than the institutional – which he was happy to leave to Bugenhagen. Predictably, Avis provides a full account of early Anglican writers, including Hooker, a significant and consistently undervalued heir to the medieval tradition of natural law. He shows how all of them, from Andrewes, Field, Thorndike, through to such more recent figures as Creighton and Figgis, were sufficiently imbued with the importance of what we would call historical theology to see the significance of conciliarism in the patristic era for the healing and the ongoing life of the church.
I was left with two main questions. The first concerns how conciliarism should actually work. Possible participation of the laity may have been occasionally broached in the medieval period and it figures, predictably, on the Reformers’ agendas, including Luther's godly prince. But it was not until the nineteenth century that the Church of England even allowed the laity in on Diocesan Conferences, a forerunner of the ‘House of Laity’ of today's General Synod, whereas the Episcopal Church of the USA had lay membership at its first Conventions in the mid-1780s. In today's climate of distrust of power, as Avis notes, it seems a pipedream that a truly ‘ecumenical’ Council could emerge with a papacy divested of those aspects of its theology – and practice – to which Orthodoxy and Protestantism continue to object. On the other hand, are the Churches of the Reformation prepared to submit themselves to a collective discipline which runs against the grain of the bureaucratised ‘free-for-all’ that many of us are accused of living out day-by-day?
The second question, which probably requires a separate study altogether, concerns Avis' interesting treatment of natural law. In some respects, he was taking a bit of a risk in introducing this as a hermeneutical key, given the widely differing interpretations it has received over the centuries and (as he admits) the different ways in which Aquinas himself has been interpreted. Of course the ‘common good’ grounds all that the Christian enterprise is about in the service of others, not as a latter-day exercise in Pelagianism, but as a genuine following in the way of the cross. Natural law must, at the end of the day, relate to our identity as human beings, in the same way that water is about washing and bread and wine are about eating and drinking; yet it must also relate to our vocation, what we are called to be – and that has yet to be fully revealed. In tapping into this part of the church's common memory as a critique of authority, with its background in social awareness and political institutions, Avis leaves us all with some unfinished business, which lies somewhere between what Michael Ramsey, an Archbishop of Canterbury with ecumenism in his bones, used to call the church ‘once given’ and the church ‘in its coming plenitude’.
