These are two quite different books that both discuss Roman Sardinia in the widest sense of the term. Conceived, set up and realized in very different ways, their contributions and indeed significance could hardly have been further apart. The reason to review them jointly here is not so much that they appeared around the same time but rather because they both claim to study the history of the island of Sardinia as part of the Roman world and to investigate how the island's inhabitants interacted with the outside world (Mastino, 16; Guido, 1).
The differences are clear from the outset, as the former represents a synthesis of recent research that is intended to replace the classic handbook of Roman Sardinia first written by Piero Meloni in 1975 as La Sardegna romana (revised in 1990). Attilio Mastino is furthermore not only himself a distinguished and widely published historian and epigrapher of Roman Sardinia who is eminently qualified to undertake this task but he is also assisted by a team of eleven historians and archaeologists who nearly all hail from his home university of Sassari and who have all added sections and chapters on specialized topics and themes ranging from roads and villae to the Phoenician and early medieval periods. Luca Guido's book, by contrast, is essentially his doctoral dissertation that was defended at the University of Düsseldorf in 2005.
M.'s book is intended not just to update and to replace Meloni's handbook but also to expand on it as a historical study of ancient Sardinia, in which the Roman period takes pride of place among brief but succinct chapters on the Phoenician and Punic (I), Vandal (XI), and medieval periods (XII). The other nine chapters all deal with the Roman period from the first Republican occupation in 238 b.c. until the demise of Roman administration in the early fifth century a.d. The organization of these chapters reflects that of Meloni's seminal study, as only the first three (II–IV) are chronologically organized and cover the course of events from Republican times until the days of the late Empire. The remaining six are thematically organized and discuss the themes of ‘economy and society’ (V), ‘oppida and people of Sardinia’ (VI), Roman roads (VII), army and fleet (VIII), religion (IX), and Christianity (X). As the latter chapter plus the two following post-Roman ones bring back a chronological order, it is clear that the bulk of the evidence that is discussed in the central chapters relates primarily to the Imperial period.
In line with its character as a handbook, the text is without in-text references or notes but each chapter is instead accompanied by a dense bibliographic essay that follows the text and provides a wealth of background information. An extensive chronological overview concludes the text. The book is efficiently illustrated and comes with extensive and very useful indexes.
One key strength of M.'s book is its explicit and resolute historical focus without ignoring the archaeological evidence, wherever relevant. This perspective has most of all guided the choice of themes and topics by emphasizing those that can most profitably be discussed from a historical, including epigraphic, point of view, and giving less attention to more specifically archaeological matters. Because of the thematic organization, M. has succeeded in steering clear of a dry chronological account and has instead delivered a vivid and well-informed social and economic history that is admirably up-to-date. It provides a wealth of evidence that is not just discussed in detail but is also well contextualized and cleverly combined with many other relevant elements. All in all, this is a perceptive and erudite study the significance of which goes well beyond the island and which deserves to be read widely by scholars interested in the histories of the individual Roman provinces both north and south of the Alps as well east and west of Rome.
G.'s book is altogether a very different kettle of fish, not so much because it is a doctoral dissertation but mostly because it is narrowly based on epigraphic and onomastic evidence but yet attempts to provide a grand story of Roman Sardinia. The term ‘romanisation’ figures prominently in the title but the arguments are based on a very narrow and well outdated selection of publications. While it might serve as a useful source of data for epigraphic or onomastic studies, the poor contextualization of the evidence, in particular the near absence of references to recent archaeological research, seriously undermines the wider aspirations of the study and ultimately causes it to fail in this respect.
