Much scholarly attention has been paid to the dramatic biography of Eugene O'Neill, particularly in regard to the autobiographical nature of The Iceman Cometh and Long Day's Journey into Night, the late plays often considered his masterworks. Yet as Eileen J. Herrmann and Robert M. Dowling, the editors of Eugene O'Neill and His Early Contemporaries: Bohemians, Radicals, Progressives and the Avant Garde note, relatively little work has been done concerning the impact of his early acquaintances on the playwright's personal ideology and art. In addressing this gap in the extensive field of O'Neill research, Herrmann and Dowling aim to “locate O'Neill's sociophilosophical identity squarely within his time” (3), exploring the influence of his early contemporaries on his later plays, his relationship to Bohemian, radical, and leftist ideals, the influence of the Abbey Theatre on his stagecraft, and his work with the Provincetown Players and artists of Greenwich Village. The fourteen-essay volume consists primarily of original work but does reprint two classic pieces of O'Neill scholarship: “‘Vital Contact’: Eugene O'Neill and the Working Class,” by Patrick J. Chura, and “Hugo of The Iceman Cometh: Realism and O'Neill,” by Doris M. Alexander. The resulting combination of essays successfully constructs a socially, culturally, and artistically contextual understanding of O'Neill as forged through his interactions and environment. The editors do not intend either to provide a holistic biography of early O'Neill or to create a fully synthesized portrait of the playwright, but rather to uncover to what extent his early acquaintances and experiences affected his plays, and how those plays demonstrate and reflect his evolving sociophilosophical identity.
Herrmann and Dowling provide a thorough introduction that both surveys extant O'Neill scholarship and clearly supports their articulation of the scholarly gap surrounding the influence of his early contemporaries. By drawing upon a wide range of subject matter for their anthology, the editors provide a complex and captivating narrative that operates through biographical insight, play analysis, and theoretical intervention. Highlights of the compilation include Robert A. Richter's “The Maritime Roots of O'Neill's Radicalism,” which looks at the impact on O'Neill's work of unionization and the shift from sail vessels to steamships, particularly in The Hairy Ape and The Personal Equation; Drew Eisenhauer's “‘A Lot of Crazy Socialists and Anarchists’: O'Neill and the Artist Social Problem Play,” which explores O'Neill's use of irony to subvert the sentimentalism surrounding theatrical depictions of artists; and Donald P. Gagnon's “‘You Needn't be Scared of Me!’: Joe Mott and the Politics of Isolation and Interdependence in The Iceman Cometh,” which argues for the importance of community in O'Neill's work and describes the racial slurs of Iceman as a democratizing rhetoric of inclusion that helps forge an interdependent community. Equally compelling, Jeff Kennedy's “Probing Legends in Bohemia: The Symbiotic Dance between O'Neill and the Provincetown Players” exposes the many myths surrounding this pairing. Kennedy's corrective essay manages both to relay a factual history of O'Neill's interaction with the group and, simultaneously, to endorse the importance of the mythic in cultural imagination.
Contributions from Richter, Cynthia McCown, Nelson O'Ceallaigh Ritschell, and Thierry Dubost further contextualize O'Neill's work in response to historical events of 1911 and 1912, and in a deft blending of theatre, film, literary, and biographical analysis, Zander Brietzke compares the fictional O'Neill in Warren Beatty's Reds to the real-life O'Neill, exploring the connection of the playwright's ambiguous play endings to his ambiguous politics. Several essays, including Herrmann's “Saints and Hounds: Modernism's Pursuit of Dorothy Day and O'Neill,” David Roessel's “‘What Made You Leave the Movement?’: O'Neill, Mike Gold, and the Radicalism of the Provincetown Players,” and Joseph Dorinson's “O'Neill and Paul Robeson: Climbing Jacob's Ladder,” use O'Neill as the foundation to explore one of his critical, early contacts. These essays provide an unusual, yet exciting, approach to O'Neill scholarship: in them, O'Neill serves not as the primary subject of study, but instead as both the catalyst to inquiry and the lens through which said inquiry is focused. As a result, this work helps to contextualize O'Neill within—as well as to note his impact on—his social milieu.
Herrmann and Dowling have carefully crafted this volume; its essays build upon each other thematically and loosely mirror O'Neill's own chronological biography. The resulting narrative begins with discussion of O'Neill's theatrical exploration of “vital contact” and class consciousness through his maritime roots; proceeds to examination of the weight of his Irish heritage coupled with the influence exerted by the 1911 American tour of Dublin's Abbey Theatre; and finally considers the personal relationships that provided sources for his characters and dramatic explorations. The volume ends with “On O'Neill's ‘Philosophical Anarchism,’” an exceptional essay by Dowling that weaves sociocultural and biographical history with play analysis to explore the definition of philosophical anarchism and how O'Neill both related to and endorsed the concept. Originally written for the 2006 American Library Association conference (from which the idea for this volume stems) and expanded for inclusion here, this provocative and insightful essay serves the collection as an effective conclusion, drawing as it does on all of the major ideas expressed throughout to successfully articulate O'Neill's sociophilosophical identity as shaped by his historical and personal context. The volume also includes one appendix, a chronology of O'Neill's life and work. Detailed without being overwhelming, this timeline would nevertheless benefit from the inclusion of information regarding the sociocultural events and the individuals who influenced O'Neill's development in order to fit the volume's expressed intention better.
The breadth of topics and approaches contained in Eugene O'Neill and His Early Contemporaries, the quality of the book's essays, and the effective structuring of this project's overall narrative fulfill its editors’ objectives. By examining both O'Neill through his milieu and vice versa, the volume contributes to and exceeds the boundaries of current O'Neill and Modernist scholarship. It provides a welcome addition to biographical and literary studies of O'Neill as well as to the study of early-twentieth-century theatre, culture, and society.
