The subtitle ‘The Evolution of Pension Policy at National and Supranational Level’ characterises the object of this book. It gives a comprehensive look at the development of pension policy until 2007 for a special selection of countries: Belgium, Cyprus, Estonia, France, Italy, Poland, Slovenia, Sweden and the UK. Additionally the influence of EU policy on pension policy at national level is illustrated and analysed.
The book is well constructed. In the first chapter, the instruments and concepts of the analysis are described. In Chapter 2, the general path of retirement programmes in the selected countries is worked out. It delivers the fundamentals for the following two chapters, which deal with the development of pension policy in the selected countries, differentiated between Western and Eastern Europe. What follows is a description of the EU pension policy, showing the interaction between the national and supranational level. It makes clear why the European Commission and the European Court of Justice have to be taken into account in the analysis of pension policy development. This is done by illustrating the main advancements taking into account the key instruments of EU policy in the field of pension policy: regulation and coordination.
The book gives a profound description of pension policy in selected European countries, delivers essential information and demonstrates the use of key methodological approaches which will be very helpful for future analysis by experts, practitioners and policy makers. It contains a lot of information about the general process of development of pension policy and the direct and indirect influence of EU institutions. It can be seen as a very good demonstration of the application of fundamental and traditional tools in analysing social policy and shows how to use them properly.
The book can be seen as a very good starting point for analysing pension policy, especially with respect to the supranational context. However, some of the general conclusions should be taken with a pinch of salt. Whereas the selection of the countries reflects a wide spectrum of different old age pension systems, pension policies and even cultures, the omission of Germany leaves a void. Where this can generally be said also for the other countries which were left out, e.g. Finland, the Netherlands, Spain, Switzerland, or Austria, the development in Germany over the past decade was rather specific and would have given additional insight on pension policy. Over those years, a paradigm-shift has taken place with quite interesting results. The very strong support and introduction of capital funded private pensions – subsidised by the federal state with 3.2 billion Euro in 2009 and 3.8 billion Euro in 2010 – in times of financial crisis is astounding. However, at first glance, the ‘substitution’ is a policy measure that reduces public pension spending as those expenditures are no longer included in the budget of old age provision. Nonetheless, it is still a burden, now ‘hidden’ in other parts of the public budget. The rather ‘big elephant’ called Germany is an example – even in a situation where it was decided to take a new path – of measures being introduced as a fictitious solution, which delivered serious problems for other countries such as the UK.
Another aspect is worthwhile commenting on. Different starting points for comparisons of pension policy of welfare states can be chosen: it can be the specific social risk, i.e. insurance of living standards regarding longevity; it could be a special group, e.g. employees or self-employed people; or an institutional approach. As the majority has done, David Natali uses the institutional approach to analyse the development of pension policy. A problem with this methodology is that public pension systems not only cover the risk of longevity, but mostly also the risk of widowhood, poverty in old-age, and invalidity, which is normally not the case for the second and third pillar. Public pension systems are therefore not monolithic and comparisons over time or between countries are problematic. Changes in the policy on invalidity or survivors will have effects on the so-called first pillar of pension systems and there is no easy substitution in the second or third pillar. Taking such effects into account in quantitative analyses is important for the interpretation of the amount of public pension spending of the specific system. Public pension spending against this background is difficult to judge as the revenues are not only used for financing pensions. Therefore one has to be careful not to compare apples with oranges. A short discussion on these aspects would have yielded a better grasp of the significance of the conclusions.
Overall, drawing conclusions from a restricted sample of European welfare states and European social policy on the further development of pension systems in European countries as a whole and on the effects of the open method of coordination is somehow tricky. Nonetheless, Natali's analysis indicates, among others, that the characterisation of pension systems as elephants on the move has to be questioned. The book demonstrates that over a very short time span the elephant is not only moving, but also can change direction like a hare hunted by dogs named ‘demography’, ‘economic globalisation’, ‘European integration and ‘international competitiveness’ (Ginn et al., Reference Ginn, Fachinger, Schmähl, Naegele and Walker2009).
With respect to the wide range and numerous publications on pension policy, this book is a very good addition to the existing literature.
