Lydia Morris has made an important contribution to the growing body of literature on contemporary migration and asylum policy particularly in relation to the ways in which migrants’ rights have become stratified. As states develop ‘managed migration’ policies which seek to obtain the benefits of migration without the costs, they have become increasingly selective in relation to would-be migrants on the grounds of skills and experience, with those deemed unskilled condemned to insecure status and limited rights. Using and developing Lockwood's term ‘civic stratification’, Morris has shown how the differentiated rights accorded to different groups within the UK and other EU states has become part of a ‘process of governmentality’.
In this latest book, Morris develops the theme of migrants’ rights through a specific focus on asylum. Its starting point is the paradox outlined by Hannah Arendt, writing of stateless people following the First World War, that ‘we became aware of the existence of a right to have rights . . . only when millions of people had emerged who had lost and could not regain those rights’ (Arendt, Reference Arendt1979: 297). The refugee has lost citizenship of a state and therefore has no institutional means of claiming the rights which belong to them as human beings. Morris explores the relationship between human rights, which are seen as universal, and national citizenship which always involves membership of a bounded community and in which there is a presumed ‘national interest’.
This contradictory relationship has been continued in the subsequent development of refugee protection: the refugee instruments which developed in the aftermath of the Second World War, such as the Geneva Convention, embody universal principles, but depend on ratification and implementation by sovereign states. Moreover, they include no obligation on states to offer asylum merely to protect against refoulement – sending people back to a situation where they may be in danger, a notion based in Kant's notion of the ‘hospitality’ due to an alien. As political and economic crises have increased refugees numbers and the range of countries of origin, asylum policies in refugee receiving states have been framed in ever narrower nationalistic terms. While not repudiating their obligations under the Geneva Convention, they have sought to reduce the numbers claiming asylum through controlling borders and deterring entry by cutting the rights of asylum seekers and those appealing a decision, but at the same time adopting strict interpretations of the definition of a refugee so that many people in need of protection are either deported or left with minimal rights. In Britain, official discourse has promoted the idea that most asylum seekers are ‘bogus’ and abusing ‘our’ hospitality.
As Morris shows, the hospitality we owe to non-citizens is the object of continual negotiation. She examines one aspect of this negotiation, a series of legal challenges to measures in UK asylum policy which have restricted the welfare rights of people claiming asylum, or whose claim has been refused asylum, rendering them destitute. These challenges have been based on the argument that such treatment is an abuse of human rights and have thus drawn on universal notions of rights in contrast to the national self-interest which underlies asylum and immigration policy. There have been some notable successes, including the judgement that struck down the measure in the 1996 Asylum Act which denied welfare benefits to all asylum seekers whose claim was made ‘in-country’ rather than on entry people claiming asylum within the country.
Judges have thus become key players in the process of asylum policy-making. Morris argues that, while judicial decision-making in relation to immigration has traditionally been conservative and deferential towards government policy, the introduction of the Human Rights Act has opened up avenues for judges to declare unlawful some restrictive and illiberal elements of national legislation. These cases have also depended on mobilising informal networks of human rights lawyers, who worked with individuals and groups interested in human rights to bring attention to these cases and document the evidence on which they are based.
Morris's analysis involves a detailed examination of the legal arguments and interviews with key players in the judicial processes, including both judges and advocates. She shows how the claiming of rights is a dynamic process involving many different actors who draw on different – and often conflicting – paradigms in deciding whether rights should be conferred. Nationalist and cosmopolitan paradigms, give different answers to the question of whose rights matter, and, in an important contribution to the sociology of rights, she thus shows how the conferral of rights, and the moral obligations these represent, is crucial to the creation and maintenance of group boundaries
The ability to mount such challenges represents an important counterweight to the general trend of policy. As Morris acknowledges, however, the impact is limited on a policy agenda which continues to be based on deterrence. Moreover, under the Conservative-led coalition, cuts in public spending have impacted on organisations such as community law centres which have been central players in these cases, restricting their ability to mount such challenges in future.
