Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-z4zkx Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-17T12:13:55.147Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

“The Notorious Mrs. Clem”: Gender, Class, and Criminality in Gilded Age America1

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  04 July 2012

Wendy Gamber*
Affiliation:
Indiana University
Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

This essay explores the story of Nancy Clem, an outwardly respectable Indianapolis confidence woman and alleged murderess, in the context of changing constructions of class, gender, and criminality. It examines various ways in which lawyers, newspaper reporters, and ordinary citizens struggled to understand a woman who did not fit preexisting conceptions of gender and crime. A series of high-profile cases involving bourgeois criminals and (more than likely) Clem's own social aspirations allowed cultural commentators to portray her as a “genteel murderess.” Upon her release from prison after an abortive fifth trial, Clem could not sustain her newly acquired social identity, in part because her erstwhile refinement was a journalistic creation and in part because the changing nature of class, gender, and space in Gilded Age Indianapolis provided her with fewer opportunities for self-fashioning. Clem's social odyssey from half-literate “Butternut” to genteel murderess to uncultured “capitalist” reflects slippery, yet significant, transitions between social fluidity and relative rigidity, antebellum respectability and Gilded Age gentility.

Information

Type
Essays
Copyright
Copyright © Society for Historians of the Gilded Age and Progressive Era 2012
Figure 0

Figure 1.The only extant image of Nancy Clem appeared in The Cold Spring Tragedy (Indianapolis, 1869), a pamphlet published by the Indianapolis Journal after Clem's second trial. In the wake of her first conviction for murder, the pamphlet's anonymous author described a woman with a “dangerous expression” on her face, a “sinister turn of her eye,” and a “resolute set of her jaws.” Courtesy of Herman B Wells Library, Indiana University.

Figure 1

Figure 2.A portrait of Jacob and Nancy Jane Young, probably based on a photograph, published in The Cold Spring Tragedy (Indianapolis, 1869). Slow to embrace the sensationalism that characterized the East Coast penny press, Indianapolis newspapers did not publish images of the crime scene. Nancy Jane Young's reputation as a “pure [C]hristian woman” (Journal, Dec. 2, 1868) probably discouraged lurid visual depictions of her disfigured corpse. Courtesy of Herman B Wells Library, Indiana University.