The rapidly expanding field of the “cognitive humanities” encourages scholars and artists to use theories and data culled from cognitive, neurological, and life sciences to inform and extend their work in the humanities. This cross-fertilization is far from one-directional, producing exciting new research that, while benefiting from scientific sources, also often exposes the limitations of lab-based investigations, demonstrating the range of insights the humanities are better placed to produce.
Blair and Cook's edited collection can be read as a series of provocations for this emerging endeavor. Focusing upon performance and/as cognition, each chapter is written by a different author, who considers a different aspect of the convergence between performance and science. The chapters are arranged into three parts. Part 1 addresses aspects of performance, cognition, and language; Part 2 addresses how scientific models can be applied to “particular problems in training, rehearsal and performance” (76), suggesting “concrete tools” (77) for actors and dancers; and Part 3 addresses bodies in performance, both onstage and off. Each part is rounded off by a respondent, who summarizes its main contributions and integrates these within a brief explanation of his or her own work.
The introduction to the volume, written by the coeditors, is accessible to a broad spectrum of nonspecialist readers, and it outlines the potential of this vein of inquiry for performance scholars and practitioners. While cautious to avoid insensitivity to methodological variants between the humanities and the sciences, and between different disciplines within those broad categories, the coeditors’ main objective is to “revel[ ] in the complex and contradictory aspects” (10) of interdisciplinarity. Thus, the introduction serves not as a survey or digest of the advances made in the various fields of cognitive criticism in the past two decades (for which, see the work of Alan Richardson, Bruce McConachie, Nicola Shaughnessy, and Lisa Zunshine), but rather as a kind of disclaimer, which prepares for “the use of science as a springboard” (11) to engage with the creative elements of theatre, dance, and performance, and their experiential efficacy. The focus of the collection is primarily work informed by this approach to epistemology and cultural production, and it includes interviews with theatre practitioners who integrate scientific precepts in their performance practices.
The chapters cover a broad array of performance arenas: from ancient Greece, in Vera Tobin's chapter on irony, to Shakespeare's stage in Barbara Dancygier's and Laura Seymour's chapters—which consider objects, gestures, and bodily presence onstage as conceptual anchors for key features of the dramatic tale—to reality TV shows in Evelyn B. Tribble's exposition of “distributed cognition.” Matt Hayler examines online media in his extension of postphenomenological thought to study the impact of technologies upon perception, and indeed our very conceptions of “how we understand our physicality and the set of default practices that we consider ourselves able to achieve” (161).
Two chapters warrant special commendation for their outstanding rigor, combining artistic creativity with academic precision: those by Neal Utterback and Edward C. Warburton, each drawing upon a challenging practice-as-research project. Utterback, recognizing that actors and athletes both need to stay confident, calm, focused, and perform best under pressure, sets out an “Olympic Actor” training model, which combines “power posing,” “mental imagery and positive self-talk” (80) that “induce neurochemical changes in actors that will allow them to make confident, braver choices in their explorations” (83). Thoughtful, sensitive, meticulously researched, and tested by the author, this splendid piece exemplifies just the kind of innovative potential the cognitive humanities can yield. Warburton, drawing on “enactivist” principles (77), examines how “memory of, and felt understanding for” dance choreography (93) can emerge alongside freedom to “respond creatively” in the moment, through deploying “marking” (93, 94). Warburton and his colleagues (choreographers, dancers, psychologists, and theorists) confirm the “embodied-cognitive-load hypothesis” (101; emphasis in original), according to which marking, rather than full-out dancing of a routine, reduces cognitive load and thus aids effective memory encoding and energy conservation; it also reduces stress and “improves the quality of the final dance performance” (102).
Another promising study is Christopher J. Jackman's deployment of the enactive model of cognition, although his research has not yet been sufficiently tested in studios. Jackman examines “flow”: the “fluidic immersion in the task at hand” (116) that allows economical, accurate, and graceful performance (of tasks, sports, dance, or theatre) without spontaneous, creative risk-taking being marred by “self-conscious affectations” (107). Flow, he argues, in conjunction with “mindfulness” (119), encourages “full-body awareness of co-relevant contingencies between the subject's actions and the world they disclose” (119), heightening sensory acuity and contributing to an “increasingly precise phenomenology of experiences, including those which precede conscious awareness” (113).
Finally, Sara E. McCaroll's analysis of nineteenth-century women's fashion in light of recent theories of embodied cognition is thought provoking (although its literary criticism does not go as far as its theorizing). Focusing especially on corseted dresses, McCaroll argues that not only do clothes reflect taste and social hierarchies that define cultural preferences, but they dictate which features of which bodies are accentuated, restricted, or even neutralized, providing a “culturally pervasive body map” (141), the biological imprint of a culture. Above and beyond the “prenoetic” (175) bodily processes that require “no conscious attention” to function (143), conscious processing is located in and inseparable from the body. Marshaling that body, therefore, impacts thought, not only influencing cultural norms but also “permeat[ing] the pre-conscious body schema” (146).
In his response to Part 3, cognitive philosopher Shaun Gallagher observes that actors are “experts in being novices. Actors may have certain techniques that allow them to perform with excellence. But for each character they have to begin from scratch, or more precisely, with whatever knowledge they have” (179). This collection is aimed at just such novices—eager to discover how they may expand their range. (More experienced graduates and academics will have to supplement their reading, and some useful indicators for such studies are provided at the end of the volume.) Appealing to readers from diverse disciplines, the collection is for those beginning to explore the rich terrain of the cognitive humanities.
