No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 01 September 2004
This book promises to make “an additional contribution” to intellectual histories of free trade and historical studies of particular episodes “by reviewing and integrating doctrinal history and past policy debates and events bearing on the issue of free trade and protection” (p. ix). This would be an interesting and valuable exercise in both economic history and the history of economics. Unfortunately the book does not live up to this promise. Most of the book surveys either economic theories bearing on free trade versus protection or particular economists' views on that issue. It is thus a book in the history of economic thought; such economic history as it contains is taken from secondary sources.
The five chapters of Part 1 review mercantilism; Adam Smith and David Ricardo, with some attention to Robert Torrens and James Mill with respect to the origins of the law of comparative advantage, concluding that it was “simply a case of multiple discovery” (p. 42); Friedrich List and other protectionist national economists; what the author calls “the economics of trade and protection in the age of Marshall”; and the move to general equilibrium theories of international trade in the 1930s and 1940s (plus a few pages on the new trade theory of the last two decades). The “age of Marshall” is defined as “the transition period from the classical age to the early development of neoclassical economics” (p. 92), and extends from Augustin Cournot through Alfred Marshall himself, F. Y. Edgeworth, A. C. Pigou and C. F. Bickerdike, Enrico Barone and Vilfredo Pareto, to Robert Schuller, Mihail Manoilescu, Frank Graham, and the Australian case for protection of the late 1920s–1930s (all treated very briefly except the first and the last), even though the changing views of J. M. Keynes are saved for a chapter 8 in Part 2 on “The first era of globalisation and after 1870–1960.” Even more curiously and unhelpfully, Marshall on the effects of tariffs on the terms of trade is discussed 100 pages before John Stuart Mill on the same topic in another chapter in Part 2.
It is in Part II, which is advertised as dealing with “rhetoric, events, policies and ideology” (p. 169) as distinct from the economics in Part 1, that the reader expects to find the integration of economic thought and economic history. One finds instead two chapters surveying individual economists' views on the repeal of the U.K. Corn Laws in 1846 and in the U.K. tariff reform debate of 1903, before the already mentioned chapter 8. Given the intentions of the book it would surely have been better to include this material alongside the descriptions of the same economists' theories. As it is, the early writings of Pigou and Bickerdike on tariff theory, which the author acknowledges (p. 113) were stimulated by the tariff reform controversy are discussed 100 pages before the controversy itself. Part 2 of the book ends with (the author's) “reflections on globalisation” which bear little relation to the rest of the book.
The book is usually very readable, but the author has an unfortunate habit of referring to diagrams without illustrating them: for instance, he mentions a supposedly famous “back to back” diagram several times without further explanation. The only diagrams in the book are a world production possibility frontier for the constant costs case, which appears in the discussion of classical trade theory (p. 49), and an isoquant diagram to illustrate the Stolper-Samuelson theorem (p. 156). At times the book reads like a textbook, but then there are the descriptions of diagrams with which the reader is assumed to be fully familiar. It is not clear to this reviewer who the intended readership is.