As I write this review, Malians are heading to the polls to elect a new president sixteen months after an army coup plunged the country into chaos and led to French military intervention against a Tuareg-originated insurgency in the north. Smugglers and Saints of the Sahara was published just as this crisis was unfolding, following the fall of Muʾammar al-Qaddafi's government and the subsequent declaration of Azawad's (northern Mali) independence by the Mouvement National de Libération de l'Azawad (MNLA), a secularist group largely composed of heavily armed Tuaregs returned from postwar Libya. When the MNLA was outmaneuvered by the Islamist group Ansar Dine and their allies from al-Qaʿida in the Islamic Maghreb's loose organization of Salafi extremists, Mali appealed to the international community for assistance. With the north controlled by Islamists intent upon applying shariʿa, the country's economy grounded to a halt and many Northerners fled their homes to seek refuge in the south or in neighboring Niger. Although French forces invaded and captured northern Mali, the extent to which the country's stability can be guaranteed is far from certain.
Judith Scheele's engaging ethnography of the Mali-Algeria border is based on sixteen months of fieldwork with trading families, scholars, truckers, and smugglers. Although it makes no mention of the recent events in northern Mali, it provides a timely account of Saharan patterns of mobility that complicates enduring stereotypes of desert life. First, there are no rolling dunes punctuated by green oases in this part of the Sahara. Instead, the environment is harsh, unstable, and inhospitable. Four-by-four and truck convoys have replaced camel caravans. In the border towns, adobe edifices have given way to concrete structures. Second, the presumed priority of trans-regional commerce over regional exchange is an “optical illusion” (p. 13). Regional commerce provides critical infrastructure for much of the long-distance trade. Third, though they often carry AK-47s, not every smuggler is an al-Qaʿida operative. Security reports that portray the Sahara as a region overrun by Islamist extremists, cocaine smugglers, and trans-Saharan migrants are problematic for their inattention to the moral ambiguities that drive longstanding regional dynamics.
Corruption is surely part of the picture Scheele paints of the various border towns she studied. Thus, al-Khalil, a new Malian town that serves as a transshipment point for smuggled goods of all kinds, is described as a wild place where proper social values cannot take hold. Its residents “forget truthfulness and religion as soon as they breathe its air” (p. 5), and no reputable women live there. Despite (or perhaps because of) its reputation as a shady town, al-Khalil is thriving. There is a never-ending traffic of smuggled goods ranging from food staples and livestock to gasoline to perfume, appliances, and furniture—not to mention drugs and arms. Al-Khalil's existence as a border town is what makes life possible elsewhere for many families. It is by engaging in profitable smuggling activities along the border that its male residents are able to marry and support households in more “civilized” towns in northern Mali or southern Algeria.
Although Khalilis are said to “act like animals” (p. 5), most smugglers nevertheless view themselves more as entrepreneurs than bandits. They follow a moral code of conduct that enables them to nurture regional commercial networks. In fact, smuggling is widely understood as a respectable way of making a living. Most contemporary business networks have deep Islamic roots. But, as Scheele effectively demonstrates, there is smuggling, and then there is smuggling: the cigarette, arms, and narcotics trade that has taken root in the region since the end of the Cold War is considered immoral and destructive.
Because it supposedly leads to sterility, the money earned by smuggling drugs should not be used to marry and found households. Paradoxically, Scheele argues, drug money is precisely what facilitates the sustenance of truly “moral” places where people pray, children receive a Qurʾanic education, and women are secluded. We thus learn it has even enabled some smugglers to climb the upper echelons of Malian society and marry sharifian women from impoverished but respectable families. Drugs also financed the construction of al-Khalil's two mosques. The power of Smugglers and Saints of the Sahara lies in Scheele's ability to illuminate the ethical nuances, opacities, and contradictions of Sahelian life through her description of how moral and immoral transitions continuously feed into each other. Survival along the border is based on negotiating the “constant tensions between the cultivation of the right kind of connections, and the containment of those, more recalcitrant to moral evaluations, that are potentially corrupting” (p. 201).
Key to Scheele's analysis is the claim that Saharan places are meeting points “in various overlapping networks that derive their power and standing from the outside and that have little to do with each other” (p. 4). Therefore it makes no sense to think of al-Khalil (or for that matter, Adrar and Tamanrasset, in southern Algeria, or Gao, in northern Mali, which are the subject of the final chapter) as an autonomous community. It owes its existence to its close connection with “its Algerian twin” (p. 4), Bordj Badji Mokhtar. Rather than treating place and mobility as two distinct realms of experience, Scheele insists that the two concepts belong to the same register. Al-Khalil residents are always on the move, never permanently settled. Not only are they ready to bolt at the slightest hint of insecurity, but their economic success, social standing, and moral reputation hinge on their ability to gain access to a wide range of resources and claim far-reaching, long-standing connections—through marriage, genealogies, property, and so on.
By demonstrating how Saharan towns are “nodes of particular density in overlapping networks of connectivity” (p. 13), Smugglers and Saints of the Sahara provides a critical counterpoint to the notion that the Sahara is a uniform abode of terror and lawlessness. This is not to say that political instability and religious extremism are not part of the picture. If recent events are any indication, Islamist militancy has found growing support in Algeria and Mali. Yet, as Scheele's fine study makes clear, it would be a mistake not to take into account the complex ways in which legality and illegality, autonomy and independence, as well as connectivity and segregation, intersect, bolster, or contradict each other in the region. The fact that the Sahara is “the fastest changing” (p. 7) region of Africa should not blind us to the continuities that exist. Smugglers and Saints in the Sahara offers a unique glimpse into how long-standing patterns of mobility and connectivity have shaped contemporary local economies as well as political loyalties and social hierarchies. It will appeal both to specialists and to a wide range of scholars in African studies and beyond. It should also be required reading for American security analysts and policymakers.
