Last May, Mexican President Andrés Manuel López Obrador surprised public opinion when he demanded an official apology from the Spanish Crown for the violence caused during the Conquest of the Americas. A heated debate ensued, boosted by social media, with commentators taking sides and rooting for López Obrador or King Felipe and Queen Letizia. Even though an official apology may never be offered by the Spanish Crown, the controversy is just another moment in a long debate on the nature of Mexican identity and the legacy of European colonisation. It is also a permanent reminder for Mexicans of an event that occurred 500 years ago in April 1519 with the fall of Tenochtitlan at the hands of Hernán Cortés.
Given this particular background, Mestizo Modernity could not have appeared at a more auspicious moment. It constitutes a necessary reference that provides an interdisciplinary insight into the López Obrador–Spanish Crown affair as well as key enduring themes such as identity, nation-state building and technoscience in Latin America. David S. Dalton conjures authors like Néstor García Canclini and Donna Haraway to problematise the convoluted trajectory of Mexican bodies and how they were perceived by a new cultural and political machinery in the aftermath of Porfirismo. The author focuses on four specific aspects in order to revisit the debates on the mestizo Mexican state: the writing of José Vasconcelos; the murals of Diego Rivera and José Clemente Orozco; the film-making of Emilio ‘El Indio’ Fernández and Gabriel Figueroa; and the science-fiction productions of El Santo and Carlos Olvera.
Such varied platforms offer a distinctive route to understanding how modern Mexican history and culture were carefully articulated through the notion of national bodies as ‘cyborgs’. If the ultimate goal of the revolutionary Mexican founding fathers was to engineer a mestizo state where citizens could recognise themselves regardless of their race – hence cancelling any potential friction and thus operating as a collective entity in search of progress – it was a task that proved problematic, to say the least. The notion of a cyborg as a hybrid entity allows Dalton to place mestizos and mestizo identity as an enduring conundrum beyond policy-makers and citizens. The four areas selected by the author serve to observe the contradictions in the discourse and the practice of the state project. They also allow readers to move forward in time and incorporate other actors such as the United States and narrative styles such as science fiction.
Mexican policy-makers sought to expose indigenous bodies to science and technology in order to turn them into modern citizens. In contrast to other countries, where eugenics became the chosen and invasive method to ‘improve’ populations, the Mexican formula opted for rural development, education and vaccination. As the author astutely reveals, the mestizo identity might have also been instrumentalised to advance other goals, such as internal colonialism in areas deemed backward and in urgent need of intervention. One of the most intriguing aspects of this project is how mestizo identity engaged in the tensions of the Cold War era. Therefore El Santo, the masked popular hero of lucha libre, embodies the Vasconcelos ideal of a ‘cosmic race’ by featuring a super-human mestizo capable of defending the nation from an alien attack.
The book challenges readers to revisit Mexico's recent past by introducing science and technology as conflictive yet crucial instruments of policy-makers and intellectuals to generate mestizo citizens, in both discourse and practice. The book features technoscience at two intertwined levels. On the one hand, it showcases how policy-makers sought science and technology as a means to convert indigenous bodies into mestizos. On the other hand, every chapter examines how technology is in permanent tension with proponents of science and technology (writers, artists or film-makers) and the narrative that emerges from that struggle.
Reading the book as a historian of science and technology, sometimes I found it difficult to follow. Although the concept of racial hybridity pushes our intellectual contours of what we understand about technology – by expanding it to a very broad conceptualisation – this also may dilute its theoretical clarity and utility. The idea of a ‘technologized body’ that sustains the idea of a Mexican cyborg requires more explanation (p. 12), especially regarding what kind of technology permeates the Mexican population and how, even if it comes from a discursive approach. While reading, I sometimes wished for more context on both the juncture and the project itself in order to better understand how the written and visual narrative influenced public opinion, or if it was confined to the intellectual and artistic sphere. By following the official narrative on how technology penetrated indigenous bodies to turn them into hybrid entities, we miss part of the interaction and wonder how these measures effectively occurred or if they were just desires. Context would be useful in these moments. The best parts of the book are when the author establishes a dialogue between the artistic and intellectual works and the social milieu. Although some of these aspects have already been analysed by scholars – Vasconcelos’ racial theory or the work of muralists, for example – I found the examination of Mexican film-makers a rich and original addition to the central argument.
Mestizo Modernity brings a fresh insight into new debates on race in scholarly literature. While a recent body of scholarship focuses on how race, history and genetics inform each other, this book extends the possibilities of examining the role of technology to areas such as literary criticism and theory. The mestizo state project may have disappeared a while ago, especially with the resurfacing of long-hidden communities like Afro-Mexicans and internal/international migration, but it is still a helpful analytical tool for understanding ambitious national identity projects that flourished over the last century in various parts of the region.
