Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-z4zkx Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T06:21:34.513Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Cessation and reversals of large-scale structures in square Rayleigh–Bénard cells

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  02 September 2019

Andrés Castillo-Castellanos
Affiliation:
CNRS, Sorbonne Université, Institut Jean Le Rond d’Alembert, F-75005 Paris, FranceCNRS, LIMSI, Université Paris-Saclay, F-91405 Orsay, France
Anne Sergent*
Affiliation:
CNRS, LIMSI, Université Paris-Saclay, F-91405 Orsay, FranceSorbonne Université, UFR d’Ingénierie, F-75005 Paris, France
Bérengère Podvin
Affiliation:
CNRS, LIMSI, Université Paris-Saclay, F-91405 Orsay, France
Maurice Rossi
Affiliation:
CNRS, Sorbonne Université, Institut Jean Le Rond d’Alembert, F-75005 Paris, France
*
†Email address for correspondence: anne.sergent@limsi.fr

Abstract

We consider direct numerical simulations of turbulent Rayleigh–Bénard convection inside two-dimensional square cells. For Rayleigh numbers $Ra=10^{6}$ to $Ra=5\times 10^{8}$ and Prandtl numbers $Pr=3$ and $Pr=4.3$, two types of flow regimes are observed intermittently: consecutive flow reversals (CR), and extended cessations (EC). For each regime, we combine proper orthogonal decomposition (POD) and statistical tools on long-term data to characterise the dynamics of large-scale structures. For the CR regime, centrosymmetric modes are dominant and display a coherent dynamics, while non-centrosymmetric modes fluctuate randomly. For the EC regime, all POD modes follow Poissonian statistics and a non-centrosymmetric mode is dominant. To explore further the differences between the CR and EC regimes, an analysis based on a cluster partition of the POD phase space is proposed. This data-driven approach confirms the successive mechanisms of the generic reversal cycle in CR as proposed in Castillo-Castellanos et al. (J. Fluid Mech., vol. 808, 2016, pp. 614–640). However, these mechanisms may take one of multiple paths in the POD phase space. Inside the EC regime, this approach reveals the presence of two types of coherent time sequences (weak reversals and actual cessations) and more rarely intense plume crossings. Finally, we analyse within a range of Rayleigh numbers up to turbulent flow, the relation between dynamical regimes and the POD energetic contents as well as the residence time in each cluster.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© 2019 Cambridge University Press 
Figure 0

Table 1.Simulation parameters: $Ra$ and $Pr$, number of grid points $n_{x}n_{y}$, simulation length $t_{s}$ in convective time units and number of events $n_{e}$ where the global angular momentum $A_{2D}(t)$ (defined in (3.1)) changes sign during the simulation length. Numerical convergence of the Nusselt number: average Nusselt number and maximum relative difference between different definitions, see text.

Figure 1

Table 2.Definition of modes based on symmetry properties. In each case, we indicate whether the mode is symmetric (S) or antisymmetric (AS) with respect to $\mathbb{S}_{x}$, $\mathbb{S}_{y}$, and $R_{\unicode[STIX]{x03C0}}$.

Figure 2

Figure 1.Leading POD modes obtained from the complete series for $Ra=5\times 10^{7}$ and $Pr=4.3$. For each figure, colour corresponds to the temperature modes $\unicode[STIX]{x1D719}_{k}^{\unicode[STIX]{x1D703}}$ (a) and to the streamfunction of the velocity modes $(\unicode[STIX]{x1D719}_{k}^{u},\unicode[STIX]{x1D719}_{k}^{v})$ (b). Streamlines are also presented in the bottom row with dashed lines for negative streamfunction values.

Figure 3

Figure 2.(a) Time evolution of $A_{2D}(t)$ scaled by $\overline{|A_{2D}|}$ for $(Ra=5\times 10^{7},Pr=3)$. The threshold separating the CR and EC regimes set to $A_{thres}=\overline{|A_{2D}|}+\unicode[STIX]{x1D70E}(|A_{2D}|)$ is shown in red. White areas correspond to CR, while grey areas correspond to EC. Panel (b) (respectively (c)) displays snapshots taken inside the CR (respectively EC) regime. Colour indicates temperature field $\unicode[STIX]{x1D703}(\boldsymbol{x},t)$ and lines are streamlines (negative values shown in dashed).

Figure 4

Figure 3.Conditional POD analysis of the CR and EC subsets. Normalised eigenvalues for the first 20 modes for $Ra=5\times 10^{7}$ for (a) $Pr=3.0$ and (b) $Pr=4.3$.

Figure 5

Figure 4.Leading POD modes of the CR subset obtained for $Ra=5\times 10^{7}$ and $Pr=3.0$. For each panel, colour corresponds to the temperature modes $\unicode[STIX]{x1D719}_{k}^{\unicode[STIX]{x1D703}}$ (a) and to the streamfunction of the velocity modes $(\unicode[STIX]{x1D719}_{k}^{u},\unicode[STIX]{x1D719}_{k}^{v})$ (b). Streamlines are also presented in the bottom row with dashed lines for negative streamfunction values.

Figure 6

Figure 5.Most energetic POD modes of the EC subset obtained for $Ra=5\times 10^{7}$ and $Pr=3.0$. Temperature and velocity modes are displayed as in figure 4.

Figure 7

Figure 6.Scaled amplitudes $\unicode[STIX]{x1D6FC}_{k}(t)/\overline{|L|}$ and the scaled angular impulse $A_{2D}/\overline{|A_{2D}|}$ for $(Ra=5\times 10^{7},Pr=3)$. White (respectively shaded) regions belong to the CR (respectively EC) subset. Red solid lines on the top figure pinpoint the threshold separating the CR and EC subsets. The presented time series correspond to approximately $1/16$ of the total simulation length.

Figure 8

Figure 7.Probability distributions of the scaled amplitudes $\unicode[STIX]{x1D6FC}_{k}(t)/\overline{|L|}$ for $(Ra=5\times 10^{7},Pr=3)$. Probability distribution functions inside the CR regime are displayed in blue, while conditional PDFs inside EC regime are displayed in red.

Figure 9

Figure 8.Distribution of waiting times $\unicode[STIX]{x1D70F}_{M}$ of modes $M=\{L,L^{\ast },S,S^{\ast }\}$ for $(Ra=5\times 10^{7},Pr=3)$. (a) Displays the CR regime and (b) the EC regime. Probability distribution functions are obtained using histograms with fixed bins of 2.5 t.u. width. Exponential (solid) and gamma distributions with $k\neq 1$ (dashed) are drawn using parameters from table 3.

Figure 10

Table 3.(a) CR subset and (b) EC subset for ($Ra=5\times 10^{7},Pr=3$). Values $k$ and $m$ define the fit of the probability distributions of waiting times $\unicode[STIX]{x1D70F}_{M}$ to either exponential (in that case $k$ is set to 1) or gamma distributions with $k\neq 1$. The coefficient $R^{2}$ quantifies the goodness of the fit (see text). Finally $n$ denotes the number of events where a mode changes signs.

Figure 11

Figure 9.Bivariate histograms of the global kinetic energy $E_{kin}$, available potential energy $E_{apot}$ and of the modal amplitudes as function of re-scaled time $t_{o}$ during a generic reversal for $(Ra=5\times 10^{7},Pr=3)$. Generic curves are displayed in solid lines, while dotted lines indicate one standard deviation. Colour intensity indicates the probability density (here shown for the blue phase, but equivalent for the other colours), while the colour indicates the three phases of a generic reversal in energetic viewpoint: accumulation (blue), release (orange) and acceleration (green). A precursory region to the flow reversal is enclosed between vertical blue lines, see text.

Figure 12

Figure 10.Flow patterns corresponding to the $K=12$ cluster centroids extracted from the CR subset for $(Ra=5\times 10^{7},Pr=3)$. Colour indicates the temperature field, and lines correspond to the streamlines (negative values of streamfunction are dashed). The five groups are identified by a different colour of the bottom ruler.

Figure 13

Figure 11.Time series of the cluster $\unicode[STIX]{x1D707}_{k}$ visited at time $t$ and the corresponding amplitudes of modes $L$, $Q$ and $S$, during a series of particular flow reversals observed for $(Ra=5\times 10^{7},Pr=3)$. Data points inside the EC subset correspond to the shaded areas, whereas data points from the CR subset are coloured to match the groups $G_{k}^{cr}$, see colour code at the top part of the figure.

Figure 14

Figure 12.Phase diagram in the $(L,Q)$ and $(L,S)$ planes for $(Ra=5\times 10^{7},Pr=3)$ inside the CR subset. For reference, the generic reversal from § 5.3 is displayed in solid lines. Data points are coloured to match the groups $G_{k}^{cr}$, see colour code at the top of the figure. Solid marks indicate the corresponding centroids.

Figure 15

Table 4.Conditional averages over each of the groups extracted from the (a) CR and (b) EC regimes for $(Ra=5\times 10^{7},Pr=3)$. $p_{cr}$ (respectively $p_{ec}$) denotes the probability for the system to be inside $G_{k}^{cr}$ (respectively $G_{k}^{ec}$) while $E[a]$ denotes the conditional average of $a(t)$ over a cluster normalised by the average $\overline{a}$ over the complete series.

Figure 16

Figure 13.Flow patterns corresponding to the 11 cluster centroids extracted from the EC subset for $(Ra=5\times 10^{7},Pr=3)$. Colour indicates the temperature field, while lines correspond to streamlines (negative values of streamfunction are dashed). The five groups of centroids are identified by a different colour as shown at the bottom ruler of the figure.

Figure 17

Figure 14.Time series indicating the cluster $c_{k}^{ec}$ visited at time $t$ and the corresponding amplitudes of modes $L$, $Q$ and $S$, during a series of extended cessations interspersed by several periods of consecutive flow reversals for $(Ra=5\times 10^{7},Pr=3)$. The EC subset corresponds to white areas. Data points from the EC subset are coloured to match the groups $G_{k}^{ec}$, see colour code at the top part of the figure.

Figure 18

Figure 15.Phase diagram in the ($L,S$) and ($L,S^{\ast }$) planes for$(Ra=5\times 10^{7},Pr=3)$ inside the EC subset. Colour is used to identify each cluster group, see colour code at the top of the figure: $G_{1}^{ec}$, and $G_{2}^{ec}$ predominantly associated with weak reversals, and $G_{3}^{ec}$, $G_{4}^{ec}$ and $G_{5}^{ec}$ predominantly associated with extended cessations. Solid marks indicate the corresponding centroids.

Figure 19

Figure 16.Sequence of instantaneous fields observed during actual cessations for $(Ra=5\times 10^{7},Pr=3)$. Colour indicates the temperature field $\unicode[STIX]{x1D703}(\boldsymbol{x},t)$, lines are streamlines (negative streamfunction values in dashed). The coloured symbol of the top-right corner indicates the current cluster group (colour code at the top of the figure). Snapshots (a) to (f) are taken every 20 t.u. from $t=9090$ to $t=9190$, whereas snapshots (g) to (l) are taken every 4 t.u. from $t=9882$ to $t=9902$ illustrating a short excursion.

Figure 20

Figure 17.Dynamical regimes as a function of $Ra$ for (a,c) $Pr=3$ and (b,d) $Pr=4.3$. Marks i to v separate the different dynamical regimes (see text). (a,b) Display the rescaled values of $\overline{\unicode[STIX]{x1D6FC}_{k}\unicode[STIX]{x1D6FC}_{k}}$, where $\unicode[STIX]{x1D6FC}_{k}$ is obtained by projection into CR modes for $Ra=5\times 10^{7}$. Combined energy $\overline{E}_{comb}$ is shown for reference. (c,d) Display the probability $\%p_{ec}$ of the system being inside the cluster groups: $G_{1}^{ec}$ is predominantly associated with plateaus; $G_{2}^{ec}$ with transitions between plateaus; $G_{3}^{ec}$ with short excursions; and $G_{4}^{ec}$ and $G_{5}^{ec}$ with extended cessations.

Figure 21

Figure 18.Time series of the angular impulse $A_{2D}$ for $Pr=3$ and different $Ra$ illustrating the different flow regimes: (a) periodic reversals for $Ra=3\times 10^{5}$, (b) chaotic reversals for $Ra=2\times 10^{6}$, (c) appearance of long plateaus for $Ra=8\times 10^{6}$, (d) flow reversals and extended cessations for $Ra=3\times 10^{7}$, (e) flow reversals for $Ra=1\times 10^{8}$ and (f) long plateaus for $Ra=5\times 10^{8}$.

Figure 22

Figure 19.Phase diagram in the $(L,S)$ plane for $Pr=3$ and different $Ra$ illustrating the different flow regimes presented in figure 18. Cluster groups are obtained from the EC regime for $Ra=5\times 10^{7}$, see colour code at the bottom of the figure: $G_{1}^{ec}$ is predominantly associated with plateaus; $G_{2}^{ec}$ with transitions between plateaus; $G_{3}^{ec}$ with short excursions; and $G_{4}^{ec}$ and $G_{5}^{ec}$ with extended cessations.

Figure 23

Figure 20.Normalised squared error $J(K)/J(K=1)$ as function of the number of clusters $K$ for $(Ra=5\times 10^{7},Pr=3)$ inside the CR and EC regimes. The insets illustrate the clusters (in colour) and the cluster centroids (in white marks) of the partitioned POD subspace for the CR regime using different values of $K$.