In the United States, caesarean sections account for about one in three births; in the UK, around one in four. The operation brings major abdominal surgery into the realm of the routine – most of us will know someone who has undergone the procedure. Yet it remains contentious, implicated in competing but intertwined narratives: one of which views the operation's prevalence as the result of growing demands from expectant mothers ‘too posh to push’, and another which depicts it as the inevitable end point of medical authoritarianism, where obstetricians present women with little choice but to deliver their babies surgically. In 2018 the World Health Organization took the unprecedented step of introducing new guidelines aimed at reducing the number of ‘unnecessary’ caesarean sections. Thus Jacqueline H. Wolf's history of the operation in North America is a timely piece of work with a crystal-clear relevance to medicine today.
While accounts of caesarean section are dotted across the historical record, Wolf traces the beginning of the operation in its modern incarnation to the nineteenth century. In 1830 the first published report of the operation appeared in the American press; in it an Ohio physician, John L. Richmond, starkly recounted the daunting scene he was confronted with when summoned to the house of a patient in the throes of an exhausting and life-threatening labour. Armed with ‘only a case of common pocket instruments’ (p. 18), Richmond decided to attempt a caesarean section. The child died, but the operation saved the mother's life. Such episodes were rare, however, and the operation remained shrouded in obscurity to most practitioners and patients. When it was practised, there was a propensity for it to be undertaken upon enslaved black women, whose bodies proved malleable material for doctors’ experimental work.
The visibility of caesarean section grew in the latter part of the century as surgeons, buoyed by the protective powers of antiseptics, began to operate with greater success. By the 1910s maternal death rates from caesareans had plummeted to 8 per cent (p. 53). With success came a profound conceptual shift. Surgical principles had traditionally given precedence to the mother's life over that of the baby; thus procedures such as the grisly craniotomy, in which the foetus's skull was punctured to enable its body to be removed through the birth canal – meaning the loss of the child but frequently the saving of the mother – were almost invariably favoured over the risks of the caesarean section. That doctrine was increasingly questioned as caesarean section became safer. Childbirth risk came to be understood in terms of that presented to both mother and child. With the foetus enacted as an equal – or perhaps more valuable – object of surgical salvation, the dynamics of the procedure were irrevocably changed.
The most substantive analysis in Wolf's book comes as she turns to the second half of the twentieth century and the phenomenal increase in caesareans during this time. Between 1965 and 1987 the caesarean section rate soared from 4.5 to 25 per cent of births in the United States (p. 3). For Wolf, the normalization of the caesarean section during this period is only comprehensible through the wider nexus of reproductive technologies that were emerging, in which both the pathologization of prolonged labour and an unprecedented surveillance of the foetus were implicated. It was the development of electronic foetal monitoring (EFM), Wolf argues, that cemented the caesarean section into the everyday of obstetrics. Enabling doctors to continuously monitor the baby's heart rate, its introduction signified the complexity of obstetrical intervention; EFM was designed to minimize the caesarean rate by ensuring that obstetricians had a more accurate picture of what was happening during labour, thus avoiding unnecessary caesareans. In fact, it augmented their use as practitioners became alert to any hint of foetal distress which might require a caesarean to ensure safe delivery. The operation became totemic of risk minimization.
The impact of its increased use was financial and organizational as much as it was medical. The ability of the caesarean to shift the temporality of the birth experience, to compact it into a pre-planned intervention, saw it become a marker of convenience, allowing time-poor practitioners to schedule their attendance at births and for hospitals to assume a profitable production line of surgical births. In the litigious culture of modern American medicine, the risk of malpractice suits in the event of not performing a timely caesarean became a distinct possibility, underpinned by electronic foetal monitoring, which could provide seemingly incontrovertible proof of foetal distress. Lawsuits against obstetricians increased in its wake.
Birth rights activists in the 1980s viewed the rapid uptake of the operation as an exercise in money making. However, Wolf reveals a complex dynamic between the operation and emerging feminist critiques of medicine. Caesarean sections did not play the central role one might expect. Seminal feminist health texts of the 1960s and 1970s such as Our Bodies, Ourselves (1973), authored by the Boston Women's Health Book Collective, made little commentary on rising caesarean section rates and indeed encouraged readers to trust the judgement of doctors in the event of a caesarean being recommended. The growing cohort of female obstetricians in the United States also did little to reduce its practice. Many expressed equal – if not more – enthusiasm for interventions than did their male counterparts, often favouring elective caesarean sections for their own births. Wolf acknowledges that, increasingly, for women, a caesarean section was a choice rather than an act of medical compulsion, as shifts in feminist thinking in the 1980s and 1990s reframed the operation as an empowering experience, an assertion of control when confronted with the unpredictability of childbirth. That for some women a planned surgical birth, despite its risks, might be preferable to the alternative perhaps warranted deeper critical interrogation in the book; the stress, pain and trauma that can arise from a ‘natural’ vaginal birth, all too often viewed as something simply to be endured, are surely deeply connected to the history of caesarean section.
Cesarean Section is a rich and readable tale of an operation which bears the brunt of cultural and gendered assumptions associated with both surgery and reproduction. The introduction aside, its focus is almost entirely upon North America, and given the current disparity in national rates of caesarean section some further comparative work in this regard might have enriched the book. Nonetheless Wolf's monograph will prove useful for historians wishing to explore reproductive technologies in other national contexts. Wolf concludes with the consequences for present-day practice of the huge increase in caesarean sections. In something of a volte-face, obstetricians are now increasingly vocal about the long-term negative health associations of caesarean section for both mother and child. By articulating the operation's history, Wolf provides much-needed context to a complex issue within contemporary healthcare.
