Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-2n9c9 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T18:36:46.806Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Global instability in a plane jet with flexible nozzle

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  22 January 2026

Simone Cruciani
Affiliation:
Dipartimento di Scienze e Tecnologie Aerospaziali, Politecnico di Milano, via La Masa 34, 20156 Milano, ItalyFédération ENAC ISAE-SUPAERO ONERA, Département d’Ingénierie des Systèmes Complexes (DISC), Université de Toulouse, 10 avenue Edouard-Belin, 31055 Toulouse, France
Vincenzo Citro
Affiliation:
Dipartimento di Ingegneria Industriale (DIIN), Universitá degli Studi di Salerno, Fisciano 84084, Italy
Michel Fournié
Affiliation:
Fédération ENAC ISAE-SUPAERO ONERA, Département d’Ingénierie des Systèmes Complexes (DISC), Université de Toulouse, 10 avenue Edouard-Belin, 31055 Toulouse, France
Franco Auteri*
Affiliation:
Dipartimento di Scienze e Tecnologie Aerospaziali, Politecnico di Milano, via La Masa 34, 20156 Milano, Italy
*
Corresponding author: Franco Auteri, franco.auteri@polimi.it

Abstract

The stability of free jets is one of the fundamental problems that has driven the development of new theoretical and numerical methods in fluid mechanics. Extensive research has focused on the convective instabilities that characterise their elusive dynamics. However, in real-world configurations, free jets are often confined by solid walls which may exhibit different degrees of flexibility. The present paper presents, for the first time, evidence that even slightly flexible nozzles can lead to global instabilities. To show it, we adopted the classical tools of linear stability analysis, solving the fluid–structure interaction (FSI) problem by an arbitrary Lagrangian–Eulerian method, formulating a monolithic three-field problem. The investigation of the base flow properties reveals the effect of the Reynolds number, based on the bulk velocity and channel height, in the range $[50,200]$ and of the plate stiffness on the nozzle deformation and on the jet flow development. Exploiting an idea first proposed by Luchini and Charru, we develop an ad hoc quasi-one-dimensional model capable of predicting the displacement of elastic boundaries even for large displacements. The stability and sensitivity analysis shows that the interaction of the flow with the flexible structure leads to two categories of globally unstable modes: sinuous (in-phase) modes and varicose (out-of-phase) modes. All the results presented have been cross-checked with direct numerical simulations of the nonlinear FSI system, revealing that the instabilities correspond to supercritical bifurcations. This work has significant implications for many natural and industrial phenomena where a jet is produced by a compliant nozzle.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2026. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.Geometrical configuration: reference, undeformed domain $\varOmega _0$ (a) and deformed domain $\varOmega (t)$ (b). Reference $\varOmega _{\!f,0}$ and deformed ${\varOmega \!}_f(t)$ fluid domain (cyan), reference $\varOmega _{s,0}$ and deformed $\varOmega _s(t)$ structural domain (yellow) and rigid walls (black). Direct mapping from reference to deformed configuration $\mathcal{A}_t$ and inverse mapping from deformed to reference configuration $\mathcal{A}_t^{-1}$.

Figure 1

Figure 2.Schematic representation of the reference configuration (not to scale): reference fluid domain $\varOmega _{\!f,0}$ (white region) and reference solid domain $\varOmega _{s,0}$ (grey region). The fluid region is divided in the channel region $\varOmega _c$ (green dashed boundary) and the external region $\varOmega _\textit{ext}$ (red dashed boundary)$\setminus \varOmega _{s,0}$. The solid region is divided in $\varOmega _\textit{s,up}$ and $\varOmega _\textit{s,down}$. Boundary definition: inlet $\varGamma _\textit{in}$ (dotted line), no-slip walls $\varGamma _{w\textit{all}}$ (continuous black lines), fluid–structure interface $\varGamma _\textit{fsi}$ (continuous blue lines) and external stress-free boundaries $\varGamma _\textit{ext}$ (dashed–dotted lines).

Figure 2

Figure 3.Base flow: vertical displacement ($s_y$) of the upper-plate free end.

Figure 3

Figure 4.Base flow (A): a rigid configuration for $E=10^8$ and $\textit{Re}=50$. Horizontal velocity component (a) and pressure (b).

Figure 4

Figure 5.Base flow (B): a rigid configuration for $E=10^8$ and $\textit{Re}=200$. Horizontal velocity component (a) and pressure (b).

Figure 5

Figure 6.Base flow (C): a flexible configuration $E=10^3$ and $\textit{Re}=50$. Horizontal velocity component (a) and pressure (b).

Figure 6

Figure 7.Base flow (D): a flexible configuration $E=10^3$ and $\textit{Re}=200$. Horizontal velocity component (a) and pressure (b).

Figure 7

Figure 8.Spatial evolution of the horizontal velocity (a) and pressure (b) fields along the centreline of the nozzle for the points A, B, C and D.

Figure 8

Figure 9.Base flow: upper-plate free end vertical displacement ($s_y$) as a function of the plate stiffness and of the Reynolds number. Full ALE formulation, blue dots; quasi-1-D model, red dots.

Figure 9

Figure 10.Neutral curves in the $\textit{Re}-E$ plane (unstable region denoted by the grey colour) (a). Frequency on the neutral curves, compared with the first five natural bending modes of the EB beam corrected by added mass effects (b) for the varicose (dashed line) and sinuous (dotted line) case. For each unstable mode we use a different colour. First sinuous, mode II (green); first varicose, mode III (blue); second sinuous, mode IV (red); second varicose, mode V (yellow).

Figure 10

Figure 11.Structural deformation for the four unstable modes. In each figure, six oscillation phases are shown, moving from the darker colour to the lighter one. Sinuous mode II for $\textit{Re}=150$ and $E=10^4$ (a), sinuous mode IV for $\textit{Re}=150$ and $E=6\times 10^2$ (b), varicose mode III for $\textit{Re}=200$ and $E=6.25\times 10^3$ (c) and varicose mode V for $\textit{Re}=100$ and $E=2\times 10^2$ (d).

Figure 11

Figure 12.Direct (a,b) and adjoint (c,d) mode II at $E=10^4$ and $\textit{Re}=150$. Contour of the real component of the horizontal velocity (a,c) and vertical velocity (b,d). The colour bar indicates the values of each component scaled by its maximum absolute value in the domain.

Figure 12

Figure 13.Mode II at $E=10^4$ and $\textit{Re}=150$: structural sensitivity. Zoom on the nozzle region (a) and outer region (b). The colour bar denotes the structural sensitivity values scaled by its maximum value in the domain $S_{max}$.

Figure 13

Figure 14.Direct (a,b) and adjoint (c,d) mode IV at $\textit{Re}=150$ and $E=6\times 10^2$. Contour of the real component of the horizontal velocity (a,c) and vertical velocity (b,d). The colour bar indicates the values of each component scaled by its maximum absolute value in the domain.

Figure 14

Figure 15.Mode IV at $\textit{Re}=150$ and $E=6\times 10^2$: contour of the structural sensitivity. Zoom on the nozzle region (a) and outer region (b). The colour bar denotes the structural sensitivity values scaled by its maximum value in the domain $S_{max}$.

Figure 15

Figure 16.Direct (a,b) and adjoint (c,d) mode III at $\textit{Re}=200$ and $E=6.25\times 10^3$. Contour of the real component of the horizontal velocity (a,c) and vertical velocity (b,d). The colour bar indicates the values of each component scaled by its maximum absolute value in the domain.

Figure 16

Figure 17.Direct (a,b) and adjoint (c,d) mode V at $\textit{Re}=100$ and $E=2\times 10^2$. Contour of the real component of the horizontal velocity (a,c) and vertical velocity (b,d). The colour bar indicates the values of each component scaled by its maximum absolute value in the domain.

Figure 17

Figure 18.Mode V for $\textit{Re}=100$ and $E=2\times 10^2$. Wavelength $\lambda _x$ for different longitudinal positions compared with the estimated wavelength using as phase velocity a fraction of the base flow horizontal velocity at the position $y=0.4$ and frequency $f=\lambda _i/(2\pi )$.

Figure 18

Figure 19.Mode III at $E=6.25\times 10^3$ and $\textit{Re}=200$: contour of the structural sensitivity. The colour bar denotes the structural sensitivity values scaled by its maximum value in the domain $S_{max}$.

Figure 19

Figure 20.Mode V at $E=2\times 10^2$ and $\textit{Re}=100$: contour of the structural sensitivity. The colour bar denotes the structural sensitivity values scaled by its maximum value in the domain $S_{max}$.

Figure 20

Figure 21.Neutral curves (a) and frequency on the neutral curves (b). Filled circles for the ALE results (see figure 10) and filled squares for the quasi-1-D model. First varicose mode (in blue) and second varicose mode (in yellow).

Figure 21

Figure 22.Contour of the pressure field for the real, direct mode III (a) and V (b). The colour bar indicates the value of the pressure scaled by its maximum value in the domain.

Figure 22

Figure 23.Neutral curves and the two points (, ) in the space of parameters used for the time marching simulations.

Figure 23

Figure 24.Vertical displacement of the free end of the plates $s_y$ in the DNS at $E = 6\times 10^3$ and $\textit{Re} = 100$. Full simulation (a) and zoom for $t \in [2300,\,2400]$ (b). The squared markers (, , , ) denote four different points on the limit cycle.

Figure 24

Figure 25.Vertical displacement of the free end of the plates $s_y$ in the DNS at $E = 10^4$ and $\textit{Re} = 100$.

Figure 25

Figure 26.Velocity field, horizontal component: limit cycle for DNS at $E=6\times 10^3$ and $\textit{Re}=100$ at each marker (a, b, c, d) defined in figure 24. The colour bar indicates the horizontal component of the velocity field.

Figure 26

Figure 27.Pressure field: limit cycle for DNS at $E=6\times 10^3$ and $\textit{Re}=100$ at each marker (a, b, c, d) defined in figure 24. The colour bar indicates the pressure field.

Figure 27

Figure 28.Limit cycle amplitude for $\textit{Re}=100$, $E = [6\times 10^3,\,6.25\times 10^3,\,6.5\times 10^3,\,6.75\times 10^3,\,7\times 10^3]$ and linear fit of the numerical point with the normal mode of a supercritical Hopf bifurcation $A^2 \sim E$. The blue line denotes the critical Young’s modulus computed by means of the LSA.

Figure 28

Table 1.Sensitivity of the vertical displacement ($s_y$) of the upper-plate free end of the base flow to the domain length ($H_o=50$).

Figure 29

Table 2.Sensitivity of the vertical displacement ($s_y$) of the upper-plate free end of the base flow to the domain height ($L_o = 2500$).

Figure 30

Table 3.Sensitivity of the vertical displacement ($s_y$) of the upper-plate free end of the base flow to the spatial discretisation ($L_o = 2500$ and $H_o=50$).

Figure 31

Table 4.Sensitivity of the leading eigenvalue to the domain length ($H_o=50$).

Figure 32

Table 5.Sensitivity of the leading eigenvalue to the domain height ($L_o = 2500$).

Figure 33

Table 6.Sensitivity of the leading eigenvalue to the spatial discretisation ($L_o = 2500$ and $H_o=50$).

Figure 34

Table 7.Added mass effect on the imaginary part of the natural bending modes. Comparison with EB beam model and the results of the LSA for the full ALE scheme at $E=10^3$.

Figure 35

Table 8.Prestress effect on the imaginary part of the natural bending modes. Results of the LSA for the full ALE scheme for $E=10^3$ and deformed configuration obtained for $\textit{Re}=50$ and $E=10^3$.

Figure 36

Table 9.Varicose mode I for $\textit{Re}=100$ and different values of the Young’s modulus.

Figure 37

Table 10.Varicose mode I for $\textit{Re}=100$ and different values of the Young’s modulus.

Figure 38

Figure 29.Root locus analysis. Coupled FSI spectrum for $\textit{Re}=100$ and different values of the Young’s modulus. The eigenvalues for the same sinuous (blue) or varicose (red) modes for different values of the Young’s modulus are connected by continuous lines for the modes II and by dashed lines for modes III. The green line denotes the delimitation between the stable ($\lambda _r\lt 0$) and unstable ($\lambda _r\gt 0$) region of the spectrum.

Figure 39

Figure 30.Effect of wall dissipation on the global unstable modes for $E=4000$ and $\textit{Re}=100$. The green line denotes the delimitation between the stable ($\lambda _r\lt 0$) and unstable ($\lambda _r\gt 0$) region of the spectrum.