Robert Hornback's important monograph traces the development of blackface performance from the medieval period to the present day. Racism and Early Blackface Comic Traditions offers a sweeping transnational and transhistorical account, and in doing so makes a vital contribution to early modern race studies while offering a persuasive assessment of the ways that older racist tropes continue to inform our culture today.
The book begins with a brief but useful overview of the rise of the African slave trade in early modern Europe and its colonies before outlining its two central claims. The first, which will be familiar to students and scholars of early modern race studies, draws on the foundational scholarship of Imtiaz Habib, Kim Hall, Margo Hendricks, and Ania Loomba (among others) to assert that that a narrow definition of racism as exclusively derived from pseudoscientific hierarchies has blinded us to the importance of a “proto-racism” grounded in theology, or a “supposed rational and moral inferiority of blackness drawn from religious texts and interpretations” (2). The second, related claim is that allegorical blackface types, particularly comic stage figures, offer an understudied archive of such theologically based protoracism, and that an early transnational history of blackface “unearths a lost history informing modern racism” (25). In this introductory chapter and throughout, the book positions itself as a strong intervention against those critics who have posited that the Renaissance is preracial or “race neutral” (1) by making a clear case for the importance of addressing racism's long history.
The second chapter, “Harlequin as Theatergram,” explores the “prehistory of modern racism” (35). This chapter takes up the concept of the “theatergram,” an easily identifiable and often-repeated stage bit such as a stock character or plot device, to contend that the figure of Harlequin “recycled and retransmitted timeworn, migrating theatergrams from age-old blackface traditions” (35). Hornback draws on a dizzying array of sources as he traces Harlequin's precursors and afterlives, beginning with examples drawn from Greco-Roman theatre in which Blackness is typed as foolish, touching on subjects including Dutch medieval drama and Italian moresca dances, and ending with minstrel burlesques. The chapter identifies a list of characteristics associated with blackface—“ignorance . . . , childishness, lustfulness, dandyism, and inept misspeaking” (36)—to argue that minstrelsy is not, as some have argued, a particularly American tradition; rather, “the logic of demeaning associations with blackness in comic contexts is less inventive than retentive” (64).
The third chapter, “Beyond Good and Evil Symbolism,” asks that we look beyond “associations of blackness with evil alone” because “the most important negative association with blackness in shaping anti-black racial prejudice” was instead the “belief in a stereotype of inherent black irrationality, likewise derived chiefly from religion” (73). The chapter draws on Aristotle's notion of the “natural slave,” along with medieval theology and mystery cycles, to make a case for a long history of linking Blackness with foolishness. The chapter ends by suggesting that older metaphysical frameworks, as much as later discourses of pseudobiology, undergird anti-Black racism in the United States today (102).
Chapters 4 and 5 turn more specifically to the early history of minstrel shows in the United States and their Old World prototypes. Chapter 4, “From Allegorical Type and Sartorial Satire to Minstrel Dandy Stereotype, Zip Coon, Jim Crow, and Blackface-on-Black Violence,” argues that the “black dandy” of the American minstrel show tradition has its roots in medieval European theatre and that “medieval allegorical drama made devils and diabolical Vices figures of black dandyism, and often deployed them in moralizing satire attacking the sumptuary excess of elites” (117). Chapter 5, “Sambo Dialects,” brings the American minstrel tradition into dialogue with the Spanish and Portuguese dramatic corpus of habla de negro / fala de preto (or “Black speech”) plays and skits.
The book then applies the insights Hornback has gleaned from working through a less-familiar archive to the most canonical of early modern authors. Chapter 6, “Shakespeare in Blackface,” focuses on Antony and Cleopatra, Othello, and The Tempest, arguing that these plays use blackface theatergrams “in ways that complicate audience responses to both moral allegory and racial difference” (175). Hornback suggests that the morality play The Marriage of Wit and Science may be a source for Antony and Cleopatra, arguing that Antony is analogous to the everyman figure of Wit and Cleopatra to the blackface seductress Idleness; the connection is reinforced by the fact that Shakespeare's play itself suggests that Cleopatra would have been played in black- or brownface makeup. The chapter's overarching argument is that each of these three plays restores dignity to figures generally depicted as debased racial stereotypes: Antony and Cleopatra are given a heroic death, Caliban appears as capable of growth and change in his repentance at the end of the play, and Othello commands an eloquence that “challenged previous racist stereotypes” (206).
The following chapter, “Blackface in Shakespeare,” traces the history of African American performances of Shakespeare alongside the rise of minstrel burlesques, arguing that the “foolish, misspeaking minstrel stereotype not only had roots in Old World performance traditions but also emerged in response to black Shakespeareans claiming Shakespeare as part of their American cultural heritage” (211). In both Chapters 6 and 7, the evidence Hornback presents connecting Shakespeare with blackface comic traditions is persuasive; nonetheless, his argument becomes less nuanced in its attempts to champion Shakespeare's plays as uncomplicatedly “pos[ing] a profound challenge to white supremacists” (240). In implicitly assigning Shakespeare a uniquely progressive perspective on race, Hornback elides the ways that his plays at times reinforce racist discourse and overlooks the complexity of representations of race in other early modern texts.
Hornback is especially persuasive in his Conclusion and Afterword, ably drawing connections between theological and metaphysical early modern race thinking and the white nationalism embraced by some strands of the religious right. He highlights the “unique power” of mockery to unite imagined communities in a fantasy of superiority to a demonized stranger, whether through a medieval theatergram or a Twitter meme (274–5). In these concluding sections and throughout, Racism and Early Comic Blackface Traditions brings together careful research and a timely and urgent message. Its focus on blackface performance highlights an understudied history relevant not only to early modernists but also to those who wish to understand the fraught racial dynamics of our current moment.
