Recasting Folk in the Himalayas: Indian Music, Media, and Social Mobility by Stefan Fiol is a book that meticulously examines the concept of “the folk” (lok) in South Asia, specifically the Himalayas. It presents a study of music culture in the Indian Himalayan state of Uttarakhand and investigates the conceptualisation of folk music (lok geet) and related musical practices shaped by colonialist, nationalist, and regionalist ideologies. It uses a combination of historical and ethnographic approaches to explore the dynamics of these ideologies and how they are connected to discourses of identity, authenticity, status, caste, and gender that are shaped, shifted, and transformed over time across different historical, geographical, and cultural settings in Uttarakhand.
The introduction opens with a short ethnographic vignette from a video shoot of the singer Mehindra Chauhan’s new album, Meenu Ai. The filming raises a number of questions for Fiol on the idea of “folk” that he discusses throughout his book. He views the phenomenon of folklorisation in Uttarakhand as a dual process, one revivalist—“turning dying folk into living folk”—and the other rhizophonic—“separating the folk sound from the folk performer’s body” (3).
Chapter 1 gives a deep and detailed exploration of the “folk” concept in the European colonial era. Fiol discusses how the European and Indian elites used the notion of folk as a critical instrument to theorise that the Pahari (now known as Uttarakhand) cultural practices were backward vis-à-vis their own “advanced” practices. Chapter 2 describes the process of reclaiming and reimagining the colonial emerged “folk” concept from the margins of society and making it a natural vehicle for the expression of cultural regionalism and cultural nationalism in mid-twentieth-century India. Fiol highlights the work of Kumaoni composer, performer, director, political activist, cultural advocate, and folklorist Mohan Upreti in the dissemination and codification of folk music. These two chapters form the backbone of the book and set the historical framework for the following chapters.
Chapter 3 discusses the artistic life of Uttarakhand’s influential and successful vernacular recording artist and songwriter Narendra Singh Negi. Concurrently, it also documents the process of denaturalising the folk concept in India due to the development of media and sound technologies (in the 1980s and 1990s), resulting in the establishment of the vernacular recording industry. Chapter 4 presents a case study of Shilpakar musician Sohan Lal and discusses the social stigma and hardship of hereditary musicians in live performances and studio recording settings. Through the lens of reflexive technique, Fiol examines the vernacular music industry’s fixation on folk culture by separating folk sound from Shilpakar’s body using studio processes. He views this phenomenon as evidence of the “desirability of folk music and undesirability of the folk musicians” (127) and defines the practice as rhizophonia.
Chapter 5 presents two contrasting stories of Baddi caste performer Bachan Dei and middle-class urban singer Meena Rana. Fiol illuminates sexual and caste discrimination; exploitation and marginalisation; eroticisation; discrepancies in payment; and lack of control of female folk artists in village performances and in the vernacular recording industry. Chapter 6 studies the transformation of the jagar possession ritual from a practice regarded as backward and shameful to a marker of regional cultural identification. Fiol highlights the role of hereditary drummer and healer Pritam Bhartwan as well as the recording industry in this change.
Fiol clearly connects various issues discussed in the book with layers of rich historical context, and simultaneously, through many evocative, engaging ethnographic and narrative passages, embeds the reader in that context. Just as in Anna Morcom’s (Reference Morcom2013) study of courtesan and hereditary female performers in colonial and post-colonial India, Fiol examines the stigmatisation, exclusion, hardship, and collapse of sociocultural status of hereditary folk artists. His work also shares similarities with Anna Marie Stirr’s (Reference Stirr2017) study of Nepalese lok dohori (dialogic, conversational sung poetry) in central Himalayan country Nepal.
Overall, Recasting Folk in the Himalayas is unique in terms of its rigorous study of “the folk” concept in the Indian Himalayas. It makes a valuable contribution to the growing field of scholarship on both Himalayan and South Asian studies. The book is of particular interest to scholars and students of South Asian music, Himalayan music, folk music, and regional music, as well as ethnomusicology, social and cultural anthropology, and religious studies.
