In July 1893, three Croatan Indians from North Carolina (now known as Lumbee Indians) murdered a white man in the small town of Ailey, in Montgomery County, Georgia. The man, Alex Peterson, belonged to a prominent local family—locals named the town after his mother, and his assailants worked on his brother's turpentine plantation. The murderers—their names were Hite Brewington, Lucian Manuel, and Hiram Jacobs—never denied their involvement with the crime and did not try to run far after committing it. Manuel and Brewington went back to work for William Peterson. Jacobs was found fifteen miles away, clean shaven; he bragged to a barber that he needed to shave his mustache because he “had got into trouble at Ailey and wished to disguise himself.” The barber took his money and told the police. The men probably did not even premeditate murder; young and impulsive, they simply panicked when they failed to intimidate Peterson and then mortally wounded him accidentally. At trial they confessed that they hoped to steal enough money to get home and open a saloon.
To commit the robbery, the men disguised their faces by blacking them with burned cork, causing Peterson to remark “you look like a pied man,” when Lucian Manuel stepped across the threshold of his office, pistol in hand. “Pied” is a description of an animal, such as a cow or a dog, which is dappled, spotted, or multicolored. Because the robbers had blacked their faces imperfectly, leaving large areas of lighter skin showing around their eyes, undoubtedly they looked multicolored. When Peterson, apparently unruffled by the pistol, attempted to grab it, the robbers panicked and shot him four times. The newspapers reported that he died four days later, in the belief that his assailants were “white men blacked.” That notion sifted through the attitudes of elites in Montgomery County and beyond, as they caught, tried, and executed Manuel, Brewington, and Jacobs. After turning up no white men who could be linked to the crime, authorities figured out that the perpetrators were not in fact white, but were “Crowatanians, better known in this county as Scuffletonians.”Footnote 1
I uncovered this incident in local newspapers as I was researching Croatan Indian migration to Bulloch County, Georgia, for the turpentine industry. There, Croatans formed a distinct community and sustained their identity as Indians around turpentine labor, farming, and their own separate school and church. Bulloch County whites recognized this community as Indian, and the “Crowatanian” label appeared to be a straightforward acknowledgment of the criminals' identities as Indians. Furthermore, Georgians had identified other troublemakers in their state: men who conspired, murdered, or stole, as Croatan Indians.Footnote 2 The above report indicated that while the public vaguely understood Peterson's murderers as Indians, they were “better known” for their affiliation with a particular place in North Carolina, “Scuffletown.” White Georgians—the people we now label the Progressives—had Croatan Indians on their minds and found themselves at a moment to consider the forms and meanings of the racial hierarchies that had emerged alongside the economic and political revolutions of the late nineteenth century. When we uncover these stories, historians can also wrestle with how these outsiders might contribute to Progressives' ongoing social and political creation of a racial binary. The case of Manuel, Jacobs, and Brewington teaches us that Jim Crow segregation emerged from a collision between local systems of knowledge about race and the work of ordinary people to resist expectations, not just about color and ancestry but about place and behavior.
In particular, the Alex Peterson murder forced white residents of Montgomery County, Georgia, to reckon with the threat that racial ambiguity posted to white supremacy. These Croatan murderers made expert use of this ambiguity, while local whites struggled to characterize the men in terms that would make sense in the ordered society they attempted to create. When we restore Indians to this history, we see that segregation did not grow out of a racially binary society, but originated with it. Segregation's creators had to first see the world in terms of essentially “black” and essentially “white” people. The maintenance of white supremacy without slavery necessitated a more rigid definition of who belonged to what racial group, and a growing urbanization and industrialization also brought strangers of all races into communities where individuals had previously known one another all of their lives.
Manuel, Jacobs, and Brewington did not fit easily into “black” or “white” categories, and they unsettled the economic and political hierarchies of southeast Georgia. Likewise, Indians did not conform to the categories and hierarchies necessary to create and enforce Jim Crow segregation, one of the major legacies of the Gilded Age and Progressive Era. The murder, trial, and executions overlapped with three specific processes in this period that are central to our understanding of it. First, how did politics and the economy influence the creation of racial categories? The murders occurred just after the advent of the naval stores industry and the growth of the railroad in Montgomery County, and just as Jim Crow laws emerged in earnest: three watershed events in the region's history. Why did these phenomena coincide, in this place, at this time, and hastened by these unusual outsiders?Footnote 3
Second, how have Indians been reclassified and erased from this period? We see evidence of an erasure of Indian identity in how locals labeled the murderers. Newspapers changed the labels from “Crowatanian” or “Scuffletonian” to “mongrel,” “negro,” and “bright mulatto” as the investigation progressed. “Crowatanian” or “Scuffletonian” evoked a separate, acknowledged group, but “mongrel,” “negro,” and “bright mulatto” all evoked a combined otherness, darkness, and inferiority that highlighted a biracial color line. These changes in categories did not progress linearly, but they reflected a complex interplay between color, status, ancestry, and history that many scholars have eliminated from this period's narrative about citizenship, inclusion, and belonging.Footnote 4
Third, the blackface disguise—if it was supposed to be a disguise, why did Manuel, Brewington, and Jacobs do such a poor job? Criminals may not be in a consciously symbolic state of mind, and they may not be interested in explaining their actions. Yet, their actions proved significant to the victim's perceptions of them, and the authorities' ability to apprehend them. Perhaps their sloppy disguise reveals a social impulse we would not otherwise be able to consider, an ironic ploy meant to capitalize on the confusion created by the very attempt to generate ordered racial hierarchies out of a disorderly spectrum of belonging and mobility.Footnote 5
This incident raises another set of questions about the authority of historians who have embraced a master narrative of American history that traces a story from slavery to freedom to inclusion and citizenship.Footnote 6 This narrative is useful, but it does two things that exclude Indians from Progressive Era historiography. First, it reinforces a biracial story, a black-and-white narrative, particularly in Southern history; and second, it glosses over questions about the advent of race as a lens through which we understand American history. Looking at Indians in unexpected places such as Montgomery County may reveal exceptions to the rules and, at the same time, help us rethink the integrity of these master narratives. In particular, this story illuminates the role of racial ambiguity in the entrenchment of white supremacy through Jim Crow-style segregation.
Historians acknowledge that the 1896 Plessy v. Ferguson decision instituted a national, legal social order out of a set of heterogeneous cultural customs, but we have not fully analyzed the racial complexity of the actors involved in this process, nor the ways that ideas about race and identity were evolving at this time. We do know that mixed-race people such as Homer Plessy consistently objected to racial segregation, and that part of their objection was based on their elevated class status. But these creole dissenters were not simply “negro,” and they continued to insist that the dichotomy between white and black was false.Footnote 7 Indeed, just as evidence of black mobility and black achievement challenged white supremacy, the very existence of mixed-race people threatened presumptions of nonwhite inferiority upon which segregation rested.Footnote 8
Southern Indians are frequently grouped with nonwhites and racial outsiders in Southern history, since for many years scholars simply assumed that the policies of Indian removal left the region with few distinctive tribes, and that most of those who were left behind were so “mixed” that they had no stories of their own, other than an attempt to escape their color, appeal to white norms, and avoid classification with blacks.Footnote 9 Such assumptions affirm the ongoing colonial practice of rendering Indigenous people invisible. On the other hand, these assumptions also move Indians into the historical record alongside other Americans in the Progressive Era. Since Indians can be found in newspapers, census, vital records, memoirs, and every other type of source from the Progressive Era, historians have no reason not to find them, so long as they know what questions to ask. We can see, for example, how Indians actively participated in local and national reckonings around segregation and white privilege.Footnote 10
Some tribes, such as the Mississippi Band of Choctaws, the Eastern Band of Cherokees, or Florida Seminoles, carried on legal or financial relationships with the federal government that, in part, hinged upon bureaucratic interference with Indians' own ways of defining ancestry and identity. This interference could entail the exclusion of community members whose appearance manifested a supposed black ancestor (though members with white ancestors were often not subject to the same exclusion). These tribes perhaps have no more or less non-Indian ancestry than the Lumbees or other groups in North and South Carolina, Virginia, and Louisiana, but the authenticity of these tribes that did not maintain these relationships with the federal government are questioned. Consequently, historians of Native America, the South, and the Progressive Era have largely excluded their histories, or collapsed them into the stories of other racial outsiders while reinforcing the seeming integrity of “black” and “white” as logical, natural categories. Members of both types of Native communities, those who had relations with the federal government and those who did not, negotiated, resisted, and accommodated local and state systems of racial control defined by an emerging black-white binary, in ways that other Americans did.Footnote 11
In Montgomery County, Indians presented a complex opportunity to address whether and how whites could be separate socially, if not physically, from nonwhites, and whether such separation had to be reserved for nonwhites who were strangers to Montgomery County. Local county residents resolved this tension by renaming the men's identities, and erasing their ambiguity from the picture. In this case, Manuel's, Jacobs's, and Brewington's actions challenged a stable social order based on notions of white supremacy, and the way that county residents dealt with their identity demonstrated how Southerners who identified as neither black nor white, but were a mixture of both or something else entirely, contributed—even unwittingly—to a society that divided itself into two racial groups.
In 1893, matters of race were perhaps so ambiguous in Montgomery County that when local whites figured out that Alex Peterson's murderers were not white, they first named them after a place: “Scuffletown.” “None of these people were our citizens,” wrote the reporter for the Montgomery Monitor, who called them “North Carolina Scuffletonians.” The Savannah Morning News described the murderers as “half breeds of the Scuffletown, N.C. type, which has become so notorious in this section.” For some portion of the nineteenth century, whites knew Croatans' home community in North Carolina by that name. Some of Montgomery County's oldest settler families came from that area of North Carolina; it is possible that they had passed down the nickname of a unique community in their past, but apparently their notoriety was more recent as well. There are also Scuffletowns in Kentucky, South Carolina, and Virginia. Some link it to a family named Coffell or Scoville, and perhaps to a British Loyalist who terrorized the South Carolina backcountry during the American Revolution. Perhaps over the years Georgians morphed his name into a Loyalist slur and a reference to outlaws in general.Footnote 12 In any case, locals recognized that Manuel, Jacobs, and Brewington did not easily fit into an existing racial category, and so word spread of their identification with a place, not a race.
Montgomery County locals used that “Scuffletonian” moniker to situate the men as outsiders, and the county's thriving, but new, industrial economy brought many outsiders into the area. Montgomery County underwent profound social and economic change in the years preceding and following the murder, brought by the naval stores industry—the production of tar, pitch, rosin, and turpentine from pine trees—and the railroad. Indeed, naval stores production transformed the entire Southern pine belt—a region stretching from North Carolina to Mississippi. A micro-historical look at the area's economic pressures helps us understand what employers and landowners such as Peterson, along with their workers, might have been thinking in 1893, and why they responded to the murder the way that they did.
Like other Southern places, Montgomery County's economy changed radically after the Civil War. Prior to the advent of mass transportation in the 1870s, Montgomery County had an exchange-based economy, dominated by the livestock husbandry and “safety first” agriculture typical of the southeastern Georgia region known as the Wiregrass.Footnote 13 After the 1870s, the black and white populations increased over fivefold in Montgomery County, due to the cheap land available to naval stores manufacturers and the influx of workers needed to operate the industry. Local whites snubbed turpentine work, considering it “nigger work,” and at the same time they resented the nonwhite laborers that naval stores manufacturers imported into the county. County resident Julian C. Wilkes remembered how “These blacks brought … dogs with them, the dogs developed into sheep killers, and the turpentine flowing from the boxed trees got into the wool of the sheep, making it useless. Between these two evils, the great flocks of sheep rapidly vanished. When the timber and sheep vanished, newcomers crowded in, bought lands and put it in cultivation. The plow destroyed the last vestige of our primitive life, we were nailed to the mast of progress and were on our way.”Footnote 14
In 1893, Native white Montgomery County residents could not control this so-called progress, which destroyed the self-sufficient, herding lifestyle they had previously created. Wilkes understood these changes in consciously symbolic terms. He described how whites sacrificed their simplicity for a modern world, full of new tasks, a new life, and new evils. Like many others, Wilkes associated the turpentine industry with multiple social ills—the railroad, sawmills, turpentine stills, laborers—all contributed to the fall from paradise. He carried the association so far as to metaphorically equate the trees themselves with a ship's mast, made from the tallest pine trees, to which local residents were nailed.
In particular, locals seized upon Manuel's, Jacobs's, and Brewington's status as outsiders and their criminal behavior to categorize them and the blacks around them. One Montgomery Monitor reporter wrote, “None of [them] … were native citizens of Montgomery County. Our colored population do not commit such crimes as have to be atoned for upon the gallows.…[W]hen it comes to murder and such like, the Montgomery County negro is not in it.”Footnote 15 Unlike the foreign “Scuffletonians,” “our colored population” did not exhibit this type of depravity, a statement that amounted to the newspaper's definition of a black person—someone who they knew, and who would never make such an offense to whites. In this way, the crime, and the men who committed it, were explicitly linked to the economic changes that brought so many outsiders into their midst.
Peterson's death was, at bottom, simply coincidental with industrialization. But these social, political, and economic changes did not converge accidentally. The racialized labels attached to the men reveal that a larger change was coming, even to seemingly isolated places such as Montgomery County. In this small Georgia community, white residents named and then renamed the outsiders who killed Peterson. Because of the nearby Bulloch County Croatan community, or the memory of a place called Scuffletown in North Carolina, Montgomery County residents were likely familiar with Croatans and may have indeed assigned a separate category to them. Yet the men's appearance transgressed the boundaries of whiteness: “their light complexion explained Mr. Peterson's mistake in supposing that they were white men,” according to one reporter.Footnote 16
In light of their confusion, we can begin to appreciate how the category of “colored” emerged from a definitional process that homogenized people of very different origins and phenotypes. Embedded in this “colored” category were elements as diverse as skin color and phenotype, knowledge of origin and ancestry, and class status.Footnote 17 Croatans provided white Montgomery residents an opportunity to grapple with the changes in their society and emerge with a sense of order. Their appearance, their aggressive act of murder, their status as outsiders, their attempt at disguise and deception, all seemed to prevent whites from simply categorizing the men as “Negro,” though they worked and lived among black turpentine laborers. Out of the confrontation between Croatan behavior and white elites' anxiety would come the creation of a “colored”-white binary in Montgomery County.
Peterson's Indian murderers confounded whites' expectations in regard to skin color, and so “Crowatanian, better known in this county as Scuffletonian,” became the useful label. And yet, while both labels were accurate, the newspapers quickly dispensed with “Crowatanian,” the one that most directly tied them to a known Indian community. Instead, “Scuffletonian,” “mongrel,” and “bright mulatto” became the preferred labels as the Montgomery County community learned more about them and the crime. Indianness, it seems, was erased in favor of a system that placed people in essentially “white” or essentially “black” categories. A category previously identified with a place, then, became associated more firmly with notions of biological difference and inferiority.
These “Scuffletonians” occupied a space distinct from the “colored population” with which whites were familiar, but it was not a space of Indianness. Instead, whites came to see these Indians as belonging to the “Scuffletown stock of North Carolina.” Reporters believed that the men were “incapable of remorse,” and went further to generalize about the physical characteristics of the entire group: “like all scuffletonians, they are small in stature, weighing about 125 or 130 lbs. each.” Newspapers linked specific behavioral and physical traits to the men's “stock,” in addition to their status as outsiders. Replacing “Crowatanian” with “Scuffletonian” also allowed reporters to speculate freely about the racial mixture that had so confused Alex Peterson and others in the immediate aftermath of the murder. One reporter explained that “Scuffletonians” were “a mongrel race composed of the Caucasian, the African, and the Indian.” One of the murderers had “a predominance of white blood,” while the other two were “scuffletonians with the negro blood predominant.”Footnote 18 “Scuffletonian,” which had been a third category associated with a place, became a label used to describe the trio's racial ancestry.
By the time of the execution, newspaper reports also used “bright mulatto” alongside “Scuffletonian” or “Negro” to label the men. As a result of erasing the Croatans' connections to an Indian community, Montgomery residents had to cope with the reality of mixed racial ancestry among their neighbors, both insiders and outsiders. “Bright mulatto” may have been a more comfortable, and less colorful, term than “Scuffletonian,” because it acknowledged the men's ambiguous racial markers while also placing them on the “colored” side of the emerging racial line. Historian Joel Williamson has documented how necessary it was for white southerners to label mixed-race people as “colored.” Refuting mulattoes' existence enabled white southerners to “condemn the whole of the Negro community as a body, out of hand and without regard to variations in color,” while they politely ignored the fact that whites, in fact, had also created this population of ambiguous people.Footnote 19
Manuel, Brewington, and Jacobs left behind very few words to explain themselves, but changing ideas about race resonated in their actions, especially their use of burned cork as an imperfect disguise. Alex Peterson “died in the belief that they were white men blacked,” and indeed, the police arrested two white men by mistake before they caught Manuel, Jacobs, and Brewington.Footnote 20 Certainly they intended to mislead. But given the sloppy way they applied the burned cork, surely the perpetrators did not expect to fool Peterson into believing that blacks committed the crime? Perhaps they intended to cast suspicion on whites. The irony of Indians blacking their faces to “pass” as white probably did not escape the robbers, who had undoubtedly been exposed to the idea that a light-skinned, nonwhite person could pass as white. Passing was a “double-edged sword,” carrying with it a triumph over the vagaries of racial classification and “an acquiescence to the rules of white privilege.”Footnote 21 But nonwhites customarily passed as white to gain esteem among whites, or to receive first-class treatment in segregated facilities, not to commit a crime. Such a counterintuitive act requires more context.
On the stage, blackface allowed its wearer to critique society and question self. In embracing blackface minstrel shows, working-class whites articulated their belief that society treated them like it treated blacks. Minstrelsy was evidence of whites' “panic, anxiety, terror, and pleasure” concerning the racial hierarchy; it promised an outlet for social and economic frustration through violence, but did not necessarily deliver violence itself. By disguising themselves and identifying with that disguise, blackface minstrels and their white audiences maintained control over their act of rebellion against the white elite, albeit on terms established by the elite—in an entertainment setting, “safe” from retribution and hidden behind the obvious ridicule of blacks. Blacks who donned blackface in minstrel shows not only had an opportunity to trump whites with their skills, but they offered an imitation of whites imitating them, its own subversive critique that offered an “unsettling authenticity” to the performance, according to historian Eric Lott.Footnote 22
The trio's use of blackface similarly points to performance and representation, and the implication of violence. In particular, Manuel, Jacobs, and Brewington used it to “blur the boundaries between the real and the representational,” in the words of historian Dale Cockrell. Burned cork was an apt disguise at the moment of twilight, between day and night, when they stepped up to Alex Peterson's door. Their use of blackface also points to the myth of a racial binary rather than its fact. Perhaps their imperfect mask was an inside joke, an attempt to articulate and embrace their misfit selves. They performed their foreignness and darkness by exaggerating it, meanwhile imitating both binary racial categories—black and white—at the same time. The blackface may have been subtle signal to their white employers that the men were neither black nor white, and that such categories did not truly exist. They wanted to show that they were outsiders in every sense to Montgomery County's developing racial binary. Blacking their faces emphasized this marginality and their separation from both the white and black communities by playing with the ideas of “white” and “black.”
Indeed, ideas about racial categories were still developing in 1893, as the newspapers showed when they named and renamed the men's identities. Manuel, Jacobs, and Brewington then performed this ambiguity in their blackface disguise. Their actions ask us to look at racial segregation itself as a kind of performance, one that attempted to erase these kinds of uncertainties in favor of a systematic, orderly system that Progressives could use as another means to reform their societies, assert their authority, and sustain their power. Historians have concluded that, like many policy schemes, segregation was in theory a one-size-fits-all system that could be universally applied. It was intended to reform a society that, in the late nineteenth century, was dealing with a specific form of chaos brought about by emancipation, migration, and industrialization in rural spaces.
This story shows that in practice, the system of segregation emerged from small places with vastly different histories, social and economic trends, and ways of constructing race. When we consider how Native Americans, who fit neither the white nor colored categories easily, navigated this emerging biracial social order, and how non-Natives also put them in a separate category, we see vividly how the biracial order was a new way of policing whiteness in the absence of slavery. While nonwhite oppression was omnipresent in the Jim Crow era, the rules governing that society were relatively undefined and unenforced in many places, late in coming, or simply nonexistent.
Although in their crime and execution Lucian Manuel, Hiram Jacobs, and Hite Brewington ultimately succumbed to the authority of white supremacy, Indians are not necessarily subject to the same fate for those who study the Progressive Era. Scholars are beginning to appreciate how Indigenous people pushed back against white supremacy by openly resisting policies and practices designed to assimilate and eliminate them. Behind the story of these three Indian criminals lies an alternate point of view on Indian history in this period, beyond the racial and cultural binaries imposed by federal policies of assimilation and local policies of segregation. Indian identity both shapes, and conforms to, local attitudes about race and class, sometimes driven by individuals who express the most hidden transcripts of resistance.Footnote 23
