No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 01 February 2005
Yucel Guclu must be congratulated for being the first to complete two important monographs in the English language on two prominent Turkish diplomats. One hopes that his works will be the harbinger of studies about those individuals who have played important roles in Turkish foreign-policy making and implementation. Indeed, this kind of research will make Turkish foreign-policy analysis more nuanced and intriguing. Besides, it is only when the number of studies such as Guclu's increase that scholars interested in Turkish politics will better understand the subtleties of Turkish foreign-policy making.
Although the Ministry of Foreign Affairs has traditionally been one of the most prominent institutions in Turkish politics, there is still a lack of ample understanding of how the ministry works. In addition, the lives and career achievements of Turkish diplomats are largely unknown. This deficiency has two important causes. First, Turkish diplomats have rarely written memoirs, making it very difficult for researchers to find detailed information about them. The “secret” nature of the foreign-policy–making process makes information gathering about diplomats a rather complicated task. Second, and more important, the widely established belief that Turkish foreign-policy making has been guided by Kemalist ideals has led to a style of historiography that reduces individuals to the followers of Kemalist principles. Consequently, many scholars have not felt a need to examine the life and works of Turkish diplomats. Although it is true that Kemalist foreign-policy ideas have guided Turkey's policy orientation, and sometimes reduced the maneuvering capability of Turkish diplomats, individuals and their ideas do matter. Fortunately, the two books by Guclu reviewed here attempt to fill this gap. Eminence Grise and The Life and Career of a Turkish Diplomat are valuable contributions to the literature and important reference books for Turkish historians and foreign-policy scholars.
Guclu's Eminence Grise is about Numan Menemencioglu, a legendary Turkish diplomat; The Life and Career of a Turkish Diplomat covers the life of another renowned Turkish diplomat—namely, Cevat Acikalin. Both books are written with two purposes in mind. The first is to give an account of the accomplishments of these two prominent diplomats, who each served in the late Ottoman–early Turkish Republic periods. The second is to put them in their proper historical contexts (Eminence Grise, p. 7) and examine their impact on Turkish foreign-policy making.
Eminence Grise is divided into six chapters. The first chapter discusses the family and educational background of Menemencioglu, while the second chapter is devoted to his professional service career. Chapter 3 discusses his achievements as the secretary-general of the ministry of foreign affairs. His positions as the minister of foreign affairs and ambassador in Paris are the topics of examination in Chapters 4 and 5. The book's last chapter is devoted to Menemencioglu's personality traits. The Life and Career of a Turkish Diplomat has four chapters. Chapter 1 discusses Acikalin's family and educational background. Chapters 2 and 3 examine his professional and political life, respectively. The author discusses Acikalin's personality traits in Chapter 5. The most important chapters in both books, both qualitatively and quantitatively, are those related to the professional service careers of the two diplomats.
Born in Baghdad in 1893, Menemencioglu was related to the well-known Turkish nationalist Namik Kemal on his mother's side (p. 16). After receiving his law degree from Lausanne University, he joined the Ottoman Foreign Service and served in Vienna, Bern, Bucharest, Athens, Budapest, and Beirut as an Ottoman diplomat. In 1928, he became the director-general of the Political Department of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs at the young age of thirty-five. Menemencioglu's diplomatic experience helped him attract the attention of President Atatürk and Prime Minister Inonu, and he was rapidly promoted to become the deputy to the minister of foreign affairs (p. 41). Menemencioglu was to serve in this post for an uninterrupted period of thirteen years, until 1942, a record that has not yet been broken. He later became the minister of foreign affairs from 1942 to 1944, during the closing phase of World War II, and was influential in keeping Turkey neutral during the war (p. 73). He later served as Turkey's ambassador to Paris, from 1944 and 1956, thereby setting a record (twelve years) for ambassadorship. Menemencioglu retired from active diplomatic service in 1956, was elected to Parliament in 1957, and died a year later in Ankara.
Guclu's account of Menemencioglu's career shows that he was one of the most, if not the most, important powers behind almost all of Turkey's important decisions of the 1930s. A cursory look at the political history of Turkey reveals that the Ministry of Foreign Affairs had to deal with many pressing foreign-policy issues in the 1930s, including the Balkan entente (1934); concluding the Saadabad Pact (1937); and staying out of World War II. The author emphasizes Menemencioglu's role especially in two important foreign-policy issues that dominated the Turkish foreign policy agenda in the 1930s: the question of the Straits of the Bosphorus and the Dardanelles, and the problem of Sancak of Hatay. The Montreux Convention of 1936 recognized the full sovereignty of Turkey over the straits, thus resolving the problem in the best interests of Turkey. The matter of Sancak was also resolved peacefully in 1938, and Hatay became a part of Turkey. In both of these cases, according to Guclu, Menemencioglu was instrumental in the formation of Turkish foreign policy under the guidance of Mustafa Kemal and its implementation. His knowledge of negotiation tactics and realistic approach to the issues at hand contributed to Turkey's success. In addition to his diplomatic successes, the author also mentions Menemencioglu's reform initiatives within the Foreign Affairs Service and his role in creating much needed training programs for young foreign-service officials.
In The Life and Career of a Turkish Diplomat, Guclu meticulously exposes Acikalin's life and achievements as a career diplomat. Born in 1901 in Istanbul, Acikalin joined the ministry of foreign affairs in 1922 after receiving his law degree from the University of Geneva. From 1924 to 1926, he served in Warsaw until he was assigned as legal adviser to the government of Afghanistan (p. 28). After his post in Afghanistan, Acikalin served in Prague, Belgrade, and Tehran. In 1934, Acikalin became the chief of the private cabinet of the secretary-general in the Ministry of Foreign Affairs (p. 41). He later was promoted to the post of the director-general of the Political Department, reaching the rank minister plenipotentiary and extraordinary in January 1938 (p. 46). In 1942, Acikalin was made Turkish ambassador to the Soviet Union, and in 1945 he was dispatched as ambassador to Britain, where he served for some seven years. In 1952, he was asked to resume the post of secretary-general (p. 78). He served in this post until 1954 and was then posted to Rome as ambassador for a period that lasted seven years. Following the 1960 coup d'etat (p. 90), he was nominated as a senator by President General Cemal Gursel, where he served until 1968. Acikalin died on 24 May 1970.
Guclu suggests that Acikalin played a very important role in bringing Turkey into the North Atlantic Treaty Organization by persuading British officials while he was serving as the Turkish ambassador in Britain. The author also shows Acikalin's important position in the Turkish delegation during the Montreux Convention Conference in 1936 and during the negotiations with the French over the Sancak of Hatay problem in 1938–39. In both of these cases, Acikalin worked very closely with Menemencioglu. In fact, Guclu suggests that when Menemencioglu was promoted to minister of foreign affairs in 1943, he asked Acikalin to be his secretary-general because of Acikalin's trustworthiness and experience.
Eminence Grise and The Life and Career of a Turkish Diplomat give important information about these two Turkish diplomats. One wishes, though, that Guclu had added a chapter to one of the books discussing the working relationship between Menemencioglu and Acikalin in greater detail. Such an informative chapter could have added to the overall quality of the author's work. Nevertheless, Guclu has been extremely successful in depicting the lives and achievements of these two great Turkish diplomats. I warmly recommend both books to those interested in the recent diplomatic history of Turkey.