During the past few years, the study of modern Chinese religions has been blessed by the publication of a series of pioneering studies.Footnote 3 However, none has attained the level of this book, which makes much of this new data easily accessible to the general reader. Chinese Religious Life, which in part grew out of a 2007 international conference on the topic, clearly introduces the social dimensions of Chinese religions, demonstrates the manifold ways in which religion is practiced, and assesses the impact of its revival in China today. The editors deserve particular credit for allowing the authors to express a diversity of viewpoints, which befits a religious culture as vibrantly varied as China's. The introduction, by Philip Wickeri, aptly explains how religious practice in China cuts across different traditions, as well as religion's role in the “public negotiation” of relations. These trends are considered in subsequent chapters from Part I (“Ways of Being Religious in the Chinese World”), beginning with Fan Lizhu and James Whitehead's study of Shenzhen, which shows that contemporary Chinese urban settings are home to many different forms of individually oriented practice centering on vegetarian restaurants, bookstores, and household shrines. The persistence of religious life in rural south China is expertly documented by Tam Wai-lun, who draws on years of painstaking fieldwork to delineate the importance of ancestor worship and temple cults, as well as the roles played by religious specialists. Philip Wickeri and Tam Yik-Fai describe the wide range of beliefs and practices among non-Han communities, including Tibetan Buddhism, Islam, and Christianity. There is also a case study of Dongba religion among the Naxi people (which regrettably fails to cite relevant research by Charles F. McKhann). Chapter 4, by Adam Chau, summarizes his work on five modalities of Chinese religious practice, namely discursive/scriptural, personal-cultivational, liturgical, immediate-practical, and relational, providing useful accounts of phenomena ranging from composing morality books and engaging in self-cultivation to jiao offering rituals and rites for “beating the mean person.”
Part II (“Religion, Culture, and Society”) opens with David A. Palmer's highly stimulating treatment of Chinese religious understandings of the body and healing practices, including the martial arts (Meir Shahar's book on the Shaolin Monastery and Chinese martial arts would also be relevant here). This chapter is noteworthy for its fine analysis of etiologies for illnesses, as well as the links between representations of the body and cosmology. Chapter 6, co-authored by C. Julia Huang, Elena Valussi, and David A. Palmer, expertly examines Chinese religious constructs of gender and sexuality (one only wishes Brigitte Baptandier's thought-provoking scholarship on this topic had been included). Other topics covered in this chapter include the ways in which women have helped shape ancestor worship, monastic and lay Buddhism, and the religious revival in China today. The chapter concludes with a fascinating discussion of Chinese masculinity (see also Avron Boretz's recent book on this topic). Robert Weller's examination of cosmology and the environment covers a number of highly relevant topics, particularly Chinese understandings of religion and nature, as well as how these views can contribute to global ecological movements today. Weller presents important data on religion's role in environmental resistance movements, starting with trends in postwar Taiwan that are now beginning to have an impact on China. This is followed by chapter 8 (by André Laliberté, David A. Palmer, and Wu Keping), which presents a broad-based perspective of Chinese religious philanthropy, including its historical development and manifestations in China today as part of the revival of temple cults that contribute to local welfare.
The first two chapters of Part III (“Religion, Politics, and the Economy”) adopt a more historical perspective, starting with Palmer's summary of Chinese religious history, ranging from oracle bone inscriptions to the Boxer Rebellion. Chapter 10, by Vincent Goossaert, succinctly documents how changes in modern religious institutions have shaped modes of belonging in Chinese communities today. Goossaert's research reveals the impact of Western notions of religion, as well as the current dynamic growth of Buddhism and Christianity, especially in cities. There is also a thoughtful consideration of the problem of trying to quantify contemporary religious life, which merits careful reading by scholars of secularization in East Asia. André Laliberté's chapter on contemporary state-religion relations provides highly useful information on the evolution of the Chinese Communist Party's religious policies. Readers will also benefit from the straightforward discussion of Tibet and the detailed information about Taiwan. This is followed by Yang Fenggang's thoughtful study of the impact of capitalism and other economic changes on Chinese religious life. Yang shows how believers have responded to (and also helped shape?) the market economy in China, as well as how religion interacts with the state.
The final section of the book (Part IV: “Global Perspectives”) contains a solitary chapter by Richard Madsen and Elijah Siegler on the globalization of Chinese religious traditions, which treats the significance of transnational religions and how they challenge state power (see also Kenneth Dean's work on this topic), as well as the Westernization of Chinese religions. Glenn Shive's conclusion effectively summarizes all of the papers while also raising questions for future research, including the impact of urbanization, the future of rural and non-Han traditions, and the significance of Chinese religion in global politics.
Chinese Religious Life makes a major contribution to the “spirit of promoting a wider understanding of Chinese religious life” (p. vii) by adeptly covering a broad scope of key topics while avoiding academic jargon and specialized terms. Readers will also appreciate the numerous inserts, illustrations, and maps, as well as the lists of selected readings. This book is currently available via open access (http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/view/10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199731398.001.0001/acprof-9780199731398), and a Chinese edition is due to be published by Hong Kong University Press.
As with any effort of this magnitude, there are a few issues that merit further consideration, beginning with the inserts, which are of varying effectiveness. For example, those in the Weller chapter about Chinese ideas of sacred space, pilgrimage, and nature tourism work just fine, but one wonders why it was necessary to include two by Francesca Tarocco on Buddhist music (pp. 23–24 and 233–34). In addition, the Christian impact may be overemphasized at times, especially in the chapter on non-Han religion, which discusses both Korean missionaries in China and Christianity among the Miao, while largely downplaying the importance of indigenous religious traditions (which are given the label “shamanistic”). This is also the case with Palmer's chapter on Chinese religious history, which credits Christianity as shaping the “beginnings of Chinese modernity” (p. 169). Outdated terms such as “folk religion” (p. 6) should also have been avoided.
Despite these few flaws, however, the overall impact of Chinese Religious Life can hardly be overstated. By presenting a wealth of new knowledge on this topic for general readers, the volume's editors and authors have performed a great service to the field, one that will contribute to the edification of future generations of scholars.
