According to its publisher, the conservative Intercollegiate Studies Institute, the new book series “Lives of the Founders” intends to introduce readers to unjustly neglected figures of the early American republic. The choice of Gouverneur Morris as one of its first subjects is odd, given that Morris has been celebrated in four admiring biographies within the last five years, including Melanie Randolph Miller's Envoy to the Terror: Gouverneur Morris and the French Revolution. In her new book, Miller declares candidly her intention to rescue Morris (once more) from historical oblivion and to establish his rightful place in “the Founding Fathers Club, that little group of wise men we like to imagine perched on a heavenly cloud, watching and protecting our country” (xv). She ascribes Morris's low profile to his professed indifference to his historical legacy and to historians' hostility toward Federalist ideology. (The latter claim is harder to credit considering the recent beatifications of John Adams and Alexander Hamilton.) The more likely reason for Morris's relative obscurity seems to me that he spent the most memorable period of his life outside the United States, in France from 1788 to 1794. His cosmopolitan career fits uncomfortably into a nationalist founding story. Paradoxically, Miller is so focused on Morris's importance to America and on extolling his life as “a gift to the nation” (xvi) that she neglects to explain the transatlantic context that is indispensable for understanding Morris's achievements.
Morris's years in France, which Miller researched extensively for her previous book, take up more than half of this brief volume. The early chapters on Morris's family background, his initially reluctant involvement in the American Revolution, and his service in the Continental Congress and as an assistant to Superintendent of Finances Robert Morris (no relation) rely heavily, as Miller acknowledges, on earlier biographies. Remarkably, Miller passes over one of the turning points in Morris's life—his decision to join the Patriot cause despite his patrician background and hostility toward popular politics, even as parts of his family, including his mother, remained loyal to Britain—with the mere observation that it presents “one of the extraordinary ponderables of the American Revolution” (21).
It is only in chapter 6, which follows Morris to the Constitutional Convention, that he comes alive as an individual. Morris spoke more often during the convention than any other delegate, and Miller makes good use of what James Madison called his “fondness for saying things and advancing doctrines that no one else would.” Drawing on Arthur Kaufman's unpublished dissertation, Miller describes Morris's belief that a sound republican constitution needed to balance orders of society, rather than just institutions of government. Only a strong central government and a divided legislature, Morris argued, would be capable of containing the hostility between the rich and the poor. Privileging personality over ideas (like many founding father biographies), Miller makes no attempt to explain how Morris formed these views or how common or unusual they were.
Once Morris arrives in France, Miller can draw on a unique source that she knows better than anyone: the diary that Morris began in 1789 and kept for the rest of his life, and of which Miller is preparing a scholarly edition. The diary is a riveting and insightful record of Morris's complex business dealings, his passionate affair with the salon hostess and novelist Adélaïde de Flahaut, and his deepening involvement in French politics. It enables Miller to provide a vivid account of Morris's efforts to exert a moderating influence on the early French Revolution, his failed diplomatic mission to Britain, and his desperate attempts to help the royal family escape from Paris. After his appointment as minister to France in 1792, Morris struggled tirelessly with French authorities for the release of imprisoned Americans and the restitution of seized property. Against all odds, he managed to preserve diplomatic relations between the American and French republics in the midst of war and terror.
Miller's attempts to sketch the historical context of Morris's actions in France are less successful. For her, the defining characteristics of the French Revolution from the very beginning are violence and mob rule, and she largely ignores the revolution's internal divisions and gradual radicalization. For example, discussing the convening of the Estates-General in 1789, she writes about Morris's “frank skepticism about the ability of France to operate under a republican form of government” (89). However, in 1789, no one in France envisioned the establishment of a republic. Instead, the political debate that year centered on the creation of a constitutional monarchy, a fact that Miller does not explain until fifty pages later. Relying exclusively on Morris's point of view, Miller depicts all French revolutionaries as corrupt or as impractical, weak, and unappreciative of Morris's wise counsel. She never questions the assumption that Americans, having only very recently established their own fragile republic, were in a position to judge how much liberty the French people could handle.
Just as the reader was left to ponder why Morris came to support the American Revolution, his deep investment in the outcome of the French Revolution remains a mystery. Miller speculates that “as a representative of a new republic that owed its existence to the French,” Morris felt duty-bound to help them (158). While gratitude for French assistance in the war against Britain certainly played a part, Morris, like most Americans at the time, regarded the French Revolution as crucial in determining the prospects of the American republican experiment. As Americans breathlessly followed each of the French Revolution's twists and turns, they increasingly divided into those who hailed the French example as an inspiration and those who feared it as a menace. Yet everyone agreed that whatever happened in France would have significant repercussions in the United States. By excluding this transatlantic context, Miller makes it difficult for readers to understand why Morris's nomination as minister became so controversial in America. She attributes opposition to his appointment to the personal animosity of several individuals rather than to the pervasive popular support for the French republic. A transatlantic perspective also would have enabled the reader to appreciate more fully Morris's thankless position as the intermediary between two deeply divided republics.
Miller covers the four years that Morris traveled through Europe after his recall in 1794 in two pages and correctly notes that “much research remains to be done in this area” (188). The final chapter hurries through Morris's term in the U.S. Senate (1800–1803), his contributions to city planning in New York and the construction of the Erie Canal, his marriage to Anne Randolph, and his opposition to the war of 1812, including his participation in the secessionist Hartford Convention. In closing, Miller declares that the “example of Gouverneur Morris should continue to instruct and inspire us” (207), but its lessons remain vague. Without an acknowledgment of the deep connection between America and France at end of the eighteenth century, Morris's career appears doomed to be regarded as a footnote to the American Revolution rather than as an extraordinary chapter in the Age of Revolution.
