Livy on the Hannibalic War is the first English language monograph dedicated to Livy's third decade, and that alone is a significant contribution. The third decade, which offers a gallery of Roman talent rarely equalled or surpassed in the annals of Roman history, has long remained obscured by the shadow of the first pentad, and this despite the foundational status of the Punic Wars, the iconicity of Scipio Africanus, and the enduring popular fascination with Hannibal and his elephants. Even a cinematic reinterpretation in synchronized swimming (Jupiter's Darling (1955)), featuring the improbable love triangle of Fabius Maximus, Hannibal, and Esther Williams, has failed to propel the decade into the limelight. Against this general indifference, Levene's claim that Livy's third decade is ‘the most remarkable and brilliant piece of sustained prose in the whole surviving corpus of classical literature’ (vii) is a refreshing, and much needed, reminder of the pearls to be found in the later books of Livy.
Broadly speaking, Livy on the Hannibalic War explores textual anomalies in Livy's narrative, all the while championing the carefully-crafted unity of the decade. Indeed, irregularity in its various manifestations — in plot or narrative organization, in characterization, in battle narratives, or in sequences of cause and effect — forms the nucleus of each of the five chapters. L.'s brand of enquiry, however, is more generous to Livy than the usual search for gaffes and howlers, for he goes in quest not of mistakes, but rather of the elaborate superstructures to which deliberate inconsistencies point the reader. In this sense, at least, the book fits in well with the traditional interests of Livian historiography (sources and composition), as well as incorporating some more recent, but already critically established approaches (topoi and intertextuality). This is, however, where L.'s scholarly conservatism ends, and indeed he styles his own approach ‘radical’ (x, 382–92).
Even the long-standing view of Livy as a moralizing historian receives a good airing here, and morality is indeed a good example of how this book moves between traditionalism and innovation. After an exhaustive survey of various irregular features of Livy's text, L. concludes that we have been reading Livy with too heavy an expectation of coherence; that is, we have been expecting unity of plot and consistency of characterization as a precondition for good historiographical craftsmanship. Such an assumption, however, has blinded critics to the possibility that other forces might shape the narrative in ways that preclude coherence and consistency, or indeed deliberately disrupt them. L. identifies one such force as a concern for morality. The notion of Livy moralisée is, in fact, as old as Livy himself. The praefatio's interest in didactic exemplarity already establishes that the purpose of the history is to edify, and to do so in moral terms (the avoidance of whatever is ‘foedum inceptu foedum exitu’ in praef. 10 being only one example; on the influence of Sallust in this regard, which has drawn increasing attention, see Oakley (1997), 128–51, and in this book, e.g., 349–51, on the foedification of Scipio's Spanish campaign); but the more general interpretation of morality in Livy as avid partisanship of Roman virtues and imperialism has been part and parcel of the general dismissal of his competence as either historian or writer.
L.'s affirmation of the importance of morality may therefore strike some readers as bolstering the traditional argument for Livy's lack of analytical abilities, albeit in the service of a greater purpose. The views espoused in this book, however, are far more nuanced. If, as L. argues, morality in Livy governs success or failure, the Romans, as their defeats in Trasimene and Cannae imply, do not have a monopoly on moral conduct, while Hannibal's successes imply that Carthage possesses its own brand of morality. Further, as the concluding section on Capua (354–75) suggests, morality is not a reductive force, but rather one that traces and enhances the complexities of the narrative; it controls our understanding of the world, even as the narrative disintegrates into an interwoven set of causal anomalies (375).
This conclusion is reached by way of a systematic reading of such narrative anomalies in Livy, among which L. is most interested in the disruption of linear chains of causation. As he repeatedly demonstrates, Livy often embraces two conflicting chronologies or explanations (e.g. 298), thus displacing rational causality as a primary narrative concern, and replacing it with (the more irrational) morality (e.g., 375). Beyond the problem of chronology and its intersection with book construction and narrative patterning (ch. 1), L. also has a sustained discussion in ch. 3 on how inconsistencies lend depth and complexity to typological characterization (the discussion of Nero and Salinator (187–95) is a particular highlight). Ch. 4, on battle narratives, gives an especially clear demonstration of the problem, since, as L. argues, Livy often explicitly decouples cause and effect in describing battle outcomes, thus deconstructing natural sequences of explanation and acknowledging non-rational modes of comprehending events.
Ch. 4 is also the culmination of another line of argument. L. argues that Livy bolsters his view of morality as a guiding force in history not only through the creation of narrative anomalies, but also through an intertextual rejection of some fundamental Polybian views, chiefly rationality. This necessarily entails weighing in on the question of Polybius' presence in the narrative, as well as Livy's presumed slavish disposition towards his predecessor. In ch. 2, L. takes on and rejects the latter position, as well as Tränkle's assertion that Polybius does not come into heavy use in the third decade before Book 30, at the earliest (126–35, with consistent analysis thereafter). Having reintroduced Polybius to the third decade, L. argues that maintaining the distinction between source and intertext becomes increasingly difficult in light of the sophisticated responsiveness now attributed to historiographic texts no less than poetic traditions (147–8, expanding on work done by Gavin Kelly on Ammianus Marcellinus (2008), e.g. 222). Building on this theoretical premise, L. compellingly demonstrates a much more dynamic relationship between the two texts than the mechanical copy-and-paste traditionally assumed (Hannibal's crossing of the Alps is the extended example in 136–57, but Scipio's speech at New Carthage is even cleverer (157–9)). The chapter thus stands on its own merits as an important re-evaluation of Livy's debt to Polybius, as well as an integral part of the larger argument concerning morality.
This is, in conclusion, an intricate, dense, and important book, which not only alters our understanding of Livy's craft, but also underscores his importance in the historiographical canon. It engages some of the oldest problems in Livian scholarship, and intelligently argues for novel solutions. Not every reader will agree with L.'s conclusions, and some might be discomfited, but every reader will find here something to provoke thought and stimulate interest.
The production of the book is a credit to OUP. The few technical errors include: Wölfflin (p. 190 n. 59) is missing from the bibliography; Campania should be followed by ‘and Rome’ on p. 225; there is a redundant ‘more’ on p. 237; and on p. 346 ‘refised’ should be ‘refused’.
