Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-wxvwp Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T10:33:28.401Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

A freely suspended robotic swimmer propelled by viscoelastic normal stresses

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  28 June 2022

L.A. Kroo
Affiliation:
Department of Mechanical Engineering, Stanford University, Stanford, CA 94305, United States
Jeremy P. Binagia
Affiliation:
Department of Chemical Engineering, Stanford University, Stanford, CA 94305, United States
Noah Eckman
Affiliation:
Department of Chemical Engineering, Stanford University, Stanford, CA 94305, United States
Manu Prakash
Affiliation:
Department of Bioengineering, Stanford University, Stanford, CA 94305, United States
Eric S.G. Shaqfeh*
Affiliation:
Department of Mechanical Engineering, Stanford University, Stanford, CA 94305, United StatesDepartment of Chemical Engineering, Stanford University, Stanford, CA 94305, United States
*
†Email address for correspondence: esgs@stanford.edu

Abstract

We present a self-propelled axisymmetric low-Reynolds-number swimmer (force- and torque-free) that, while unable to swim in a Newtonian fluid, propels itself in a non-Newtonian fluid as a result of fluid elasticity. The propulsion gait is pure ‘swirling’ and is demonstrated using a robotic swimmer, comprised of a ‘head’ sphere and a ‘tail’ sphere, whose swimming speed is shown to demonstrate good agreement with a microhydrodynamic asymptotic theory and numerical simulations. Schlieren imaging demonstrates that propulsion of the swimmer is driven by a strong viscoelastic jet at the tail, which develops due to the fore–aft asymmetry of the swimmer. Optimized cylindrical and conic tail geometries are shown to double the propulsive signal, relative to the optimal spherical tail. We show that we can use observations of this robot to infer rheological properties of the surrounding fluid. We measure the primary normal stress coefficient $\varPsi _1$ at shear rates ${<}1\,{\rm Hz}$, and show reasonable agreement with extrapolated bench-top measurements ($0.8\unicode{x2013}1.2\,{\rm Pa}\,{\rm s}^2$ difference). We also derive how the head rotation may be used to measure the second normal stress coefficient, $\varPsi _2$. The study demonstrates the exciting potential for a ‘swimming rheometer’, examining the intersection between swimming and sensing in complex fluids.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2022. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.(a) The design of a rotationally symmetric swimming robot. (b) Illustration of the model two-sphere swimmer considered in the asymptotic theory and numerical simulations. See § 1.1 for variable definitions. The axis of revolution or the vertical direction is taken to be the $z$-direction (imagining a cylindrical coordinate system centred at the centre of the swimmer). (c) An actual robot pictured during an experiment. (d) A motor placed in the head drives the head and tail to counter-rotate. The motor rotates a drive shaft within the head, which is coupled magnetically to the tail. The device is battery powered and has closed-loop speed control.

Figure 1

Figure 2.(a) Image analysis (circle detection) was used to determine the trajectory of the swimmer (and thus its propulsion speed) as a function of time. (b) For different tail rotation speeds, the coordinates of the centre of mass were tracked as a function of time. (c) Dimensionless swimming speed $U$ as a function of the Deborah number $De$. The asymptotic theory, valid for small $De$, is shown as the dashed black line and assumes an infinite domain and zero shear-thinning in the fluid. Experimental data are shown as the blue dots, with error bars denoting the standard deviation of measurements over repeated trials. Simulations (orange circles) are performed with a multi-mode Giesekus model (which allows for shear-thinning and second normal stress differences in the fluid), with the mesh domain defined to match approximately the size of the experimental tank (the confinement ratio is $C=2R_L/W=0.32$).

Figure 2

Figure 3.(a) Schlieren imaging was used to image features of the flow field in experiments. Shortly after the rotation of the small sphere is initiated ($t=0$, $t=30$), we observe the formation of hoop-like strands around the small sphere and the creation of a slender jet-like structure at the pole of the small spherical tail. As time progresses ($t=60$), the jet is seen to persist and grow in length. Even at long times ($t=120$), this jet structure is still present behind the rear of the swimmer. (b) We have repeated this imaging process with multiple trials and observe the formation of this jet each time. (c) Numerical simulations visualizing the streamlines of the flow also indicate the presence of an elastic jet. Parameter values used are $\beta =0.46$, ${De}=2$, ${r^*}=0.43$ and ${h^*}=0.17$. (d) Polymer stress and pressure in the surrounding flow field: (i) trace of the polymer stress tensor $\tau _{ii}^p$; (ii) $zz$ component of the polymer stress $\tau ^p_{zz}$; (iii) pressure $p$. To facilitate visualization, the simulations used the single-mode Giesekus equation with $\alpha _m=0.035$ (the value of $\alpha _m$ yielding the best single-mode fit to the shear rheology data). (e) When the head and tail are identical in size, the jet structures appear at both head and tail.

Figure 3

Figure 4.(a) Dimensionless swimming speed $U$ as a function of $De$ for various tail shapes. For all $De$, the swimmer with optimal cylindrical tail ($R_{cyl}/R_H=0.86$ and $H_{cyl}/R_H=0.51$, where $R_H$ denotes the radius of the spherical head) is faster than that with the optimal spherical tail (${r^*}=0.75$). Likewise, the swimmer with the optimal conical frustum tail ($R_{1,fr}/R_H=1.0$, $R_{2,fr}/R_H=0.31$, $H_{fr}/R_H=1.1$, where $R_{1,fr}$ is the radius closest to the head) is faster than that having the cylindrical tail for all $De$. The insets depict the optimal geometry for each shape family. (b) The set of cylindrical tail shapes that were considered in finding the locally optimal tail used in (a). The optimization procedure was performed at $De = 1$ and ${h^*}=0.17$.

Figure 4

Figure 5.The value of the first normal stress coefficient $\varPsi _1$ that the robot infers as it is observed to swim at (dimensional) speed $U'$ at a tail rotation rate $\varOmega _S$. Here, we consider the viscosity to be known a priori from independent measurements ($\mu _0=4.46$ Pa s). The dashed lines denote predictions from our low-$De$ theory (i.e. (1.3) with ${h^*}=0.17$, ${r^*}=0.43$, and assuming $\varPsi _2\approx 0$). The solid lines and markers are predictions from our numerical simulations using the multi-mode Giesekus equation (i.e. the simulation data shown in figure 2, using the fact that $\varPsi _1=2\sum \lambda ^{(i)} \mu ^{(i)}_p$ for a multi-mode model). This figure illustrates the operating characteristics of the swimming robot in terms of its use as a sensor. For example, operating at a small value of $\varOmega _S$ (e.g. $\varOmega _S=0.4$) allows the robot to be more sensitive to small changes in $U'$ but necessarily requires a greater experimental resolution of the observed swimming speed.

Figure 5

Figure 6.Rotation rate of the head of the swimmer ($\varOmega _L$) normalized by that of the tail ($\varOmega _S$) as a function of the Deborah number ($De$) and the viscosity ratio ($\beta$). The markers denote numerical simulations, while the dashed lines denote the asymptotic theory, i.e. (B14); both consider ${h^*}=0.05$ and ${r^*}=0.5$.

Figure 6

Figure 7.Methods for buoyancy tuning. Oil ballast tanks (red) are used for fine tuning during experiments, by the user injecting small volumes of oil into the tanks (displacing air) through a rubber stopper. Modular tungsten weights are used in the head for large adjustments, but these large adjustments require a moderate amount of disassembly.

Figure 7

Figure 8.Modes of swimmer instability.

Figure 8

Figure 9.Balancing rig for aligning the head's centre of mass along the swimming axis.

Figure 9

Figure 10.Imaging system for capturing fluid features in the Boger fluid.

Figure 10

Figure 11.Rheological characterization of the viscoelastic Boger fluid used in this study. (a) Stress relaxation after a step strain of 500 %. Benchtop rheometer data of the relaxation modulus, G, is shown as a function of time. Shown alongside the data (blue markers) are a fit to the longest relaxation time of the fluid (black dashed line) and the prediction from the multi-mode Oldroyd-B fit with $n=3$ (yellow dashed line). (b) Small-amplitude oscillatory shear experiment to characterize the linear viscoelastic response of the fluid (i.e. the storage and loss moduli $G'$ and $G''$). Raw data are shown as markers, with the multi-mode fit shown as dashed lines. (c) Nonlinear shear rheology of the fluid, i.e. the shear viscosity $\mu$, the first normal stress difference $N_1$, and the first normal stress coefficient $\varPsi _1$. The largest shear rate in the experiments was ${\dot \gamma }_{max}=2\varOmega _S\approx 2\,{\rm rad}\,{\rm s}^{-1}$ (i.e. the shear rate present at the equator of the small sphere). The dashed lines denote predictions from the multi-mode Giesekus equation with $\alpha _m^{(0)}=0.2$, $\alpha _m^{(1)}=0.0002$ and $\alpha _m^{(2)}=0.1996$ for the nonlinear rheology (the $\alpha _m^{(i)}$ being determined from a fit to the data for $\varPsi _1$).

Figure 11

Table 1.Summary of the multi-mode fit to the rheological data presented in figure 11. Note that these values of $\lambda ^{(i)}$ and $\mu ^{(i)}_p$ are relevant for both a multi-mode Oldroyd-B and Giesekus fit since the two predict the same linear viscoelastic response (i.e. $G'$ and $G''$). The multi-mode Giesekus fit consists of these parameters plus the following values for the mobility parameters for each mode (determined from a fit to the nonlinear rheology, figure 11c): $\alpha _m^{(0)}=0.2$, $\alpha _m^{(1)}=0.0002$ and $\alpha _m^{(2)}=0.1996$.

Figure 12

Figure 12.(a) Effect of confinement $C=2R_L/W$ on the swimming speed $U$. Simulations were performed using the single-mode Giesekus constitutive equation with $\alpha _m=0.035$, $\beta =0.46$, ${r^*}=0.43$ and ${h^*}=0.17$. As the confinement around the swimmer increases (i.e. increasing $C$), the swimming speed is observed to decrease. (b) Effect of the Giesekus mobility parameter $\alpha _m$ on the swimming speed $U$. For non-zero values of $\alpha _m$, the Giesekus equation exhibits shear-thinning and a non-zero second normal stress coefficient. Simulations for (b) were performed using the single-mode Giesekus constitutive equation with $C=0.1$, $\beta =0.46$, ${r^*}=0.43$ and ${h^*}=0.17$. We find that as $\alpha _m$ increases, the speed of the swimmer decreases for all $De$.

Figure 13

Figure 13.For the optimization study of the frustum, a three-dimensional shape space must be explored. Here we show, for three different cone height values, the forward speed as a function of the other two geometric parameters ($R_{1,fr}$ and $R_{2,fr}$), and the radii of the circular cross-sections at each end of the tail (where $R_{1,fr}$ refers to the radius closest to the swimmer's head).

Kroo et al. supplementary movie 1

Schlieren imaging of a propelling swirler, demonstrating a non-inertial, viscoelastic jet coming off the tail (to the left). The counter-rotating head is on the right, and the robot propels to the right. 8x playback speed.

Download Kroo et al. supplementary movie 1(Video)
Video 8.3 MB

Kroo et al. supplementary movie 2

A torque-free, robotic swimmer self-propelling at low Re in the direction of the "head" sphere, in a viscoelastic polymeric fluid (0.1% polyacrylamide-based Boger fluid).

Download Kroo et al. supplementary movie 2(Video)
Video 7.4 MB

Kroo et al. supplementary movie 3

Swimmer does not propel in Newtonian fluids at low Re. This movie depicts the swimmer failing to propel in pure corn syrup (control experiment).

Download Kroo et al. supplementary movie 3(Video)
Video 8.9 MB