“Never before in our country has there been such grave dangers at this very point to the youth of the nation. … Cheap literature, the sensational attractions of the picture show, the low and sensual plays of the theatre, the vile and vulgar tendencies of the modern dance, make a united and well-nigh irresistible appeal to the sex instinct of the young.”Footnote 1 So began an article written by Newel K. Whitney, a prominent educator in The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints (Mormon Church), printed in The Improvement Era in 1917. The article appeared at the height of the Church's campaign to draw their youth away from the new commercial entertainments. In the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, a variety of commercial entertainments, dance halls, theaters, amusement halls and parks, saloons, and the like, emerged in urban areas. These establishments “spun people in search of pleasure from the home into the world,” shifting American ideas about urbanization, amusement, youth, and sexuality in ways that focused concern on American adolescents.Footnote 2 The introductory quotation above from Newel K. Whitney illustrates the anxieties Mormons shared with other progressives about these new forms of heterosocial amusement. Writings in The Improvement Era and The Young Woman's Journal, Mormon publications directed at young men and young women respectively, reveal Mormon anxieties about Mormon young peoples’ participation in these new entertainments. Mormon responses both reflected and refracted the concerns of other middle-class progressive reformers who sought to reform the new youth culture of “going out.”Footnote 3
This article examines how Mormon leaders responded to the ever-increasing threat of the new commercial entertainments during the early twentieth century. Around the turn of the century, the Church engaged in a “massive project directed at the training of their young people.”Footnote 4 Part of this campaign was directed at protecting youth from the pernicious influences of the new commercial entertainments. Mormons took on this threat in ways that both reflected national progressive trends and maintained Mormon distinctiveness. While most progressives focused on reforming women's new participation in forms of amusement that were previously restricted to male participation, Mormons rejected the double standard of most progressive reformers and focused equally, if not more, on reforming and redirecting men's participation in commercial leisure to participation in Church amusements. While, like other progressives, they recognized that participation in public amusements could be more sexually perilous for young women, Mormons also rejected most, though not all, aspects of the sexual double standard that held women more responsible for sexual transgression than men. While other reformers largely failed at attempts to offer alternative, more wholesome entertainments, Mormons succeeded by cultivating an ethic of self-restraint among their youth and offering amusements both in the home and more formally through the Church. Lastly, while other reformers devoted the bulk of their efforts to regulating existing commercial amusements, Mormons put their effort toward providing viable alternative entertainments, some of which mimicked the form of popular entertainments but in Church contexts, which youth would and did actually patronize.
Two factors drew Mormon youth to Mormon entertainments, and thus away from commercial ones. First, for youth invested in a Mormon identity, participating in family and Church entertainments provided a way to embrace and express that identity. Second, the imperative to marry within the faith influenced the dynamic of Mormon heterosocial and heterosexual contact. This influenced how Mormon women, especially, participated in entertainment; they were looking for marriage more than just a good time.Footnote 5 These two pull factors increased Mormon youth participation in family and Church amusements in ways other reform organizations could not replicate.
I rely primarily on prescriptive literature in The Improvement Era and The Young Woman's Journal to investigate how Mormon leaders responded to these changes. To be sure, this approach and the sources used have some limitations. It is difficult to tell from these sources, for example, how religious and generational conflicts between parents and children over participation in the new entertainments played out in lived Mormon experiences. We also know very little about whether and how frequently Mormon youth participated in the new commercial entertainments, and how they felt about them. However, we can tell that youth participation in these entertainments was frequent and enthusiastic enough to draw much concern from Church leaders who often remarked about the dangers of “our youth” going out.
The focus on Mormon leaders also leads to an imbalance between men's and women's voices. Women's voices were very much involved in discussions of popular entertainment, but for the most part they helped the Mormons responsible for providing home and Church entertainments answer the calls of their male leadership. Moreover, women's voices tended to be more frequently published anonymously than more authoritative men's voices, and women's writings were generally only published in The Young Woman's Journal. Concerns about youth going out drew much attention and provoked much action as the Church responded by providing their own family- and Church-based entertainments. While we cannot measure participation in these entertainments in any precise way either, we can tell that they were successful enough to last the test of time—many of these entertainments continued to be offered and well attended into the twentieth century, and some even into the twenty-first. Moreover, by the 1920s, the Church built an entire institutional bureaucracy around Church entertainments that lasted, though in different configurations, into the twenty-first century. This indicates both the Church's commitment to providing entertainments to its membership and its success in doing so; enough people patronized Church entertainments to justify an entire bureaucracy to provide them.
Mormon responses to the new commercial entertainments emerged in the context of a broader Mormon relationship to progressivism.Footnote 6 As nineteenth-century Mormonism, shaped by polygamy and millennialism, began to wane with the Woodruff Manifesto in 1890, “progressivism gave [Mormons] the concepts, language, and tools to preserve their distinctiveness within adaptation.”Footnote 7 As Matthew Bowman argues, Mormonism found in progressivism an expression of religious ideals always present in the faith but coming newly to its center—eternal progression and the perfectibility of humankind. Progressive optimism about the potential for human progress and the perfectibility of civilization lent itself well to Mormonism's reinvigorated commitment to the doctrine of eternal progression—that through proper education, training, and effort human beings could become like God.Footnote 8 Mormons, like other progressives, believed in the power of organizations and bureaucracies to solve social problems and increase human moral rectitude.Footnote 9 As Bowman suggests, “The institution of the Church replaced: the old kinship networks of polygamy as the ground on which salvation was worked out.”Footnote 10 The Church expanded and formalized its auxiliary organizations, the Relief Society, the Young Ladies Mutual Improvement Association (YLMIA) and the Young Men's Mutual Improvement Association (YMMIA), and the Primary (an auxiliary organization that directed children's education and activities). Under the leadership of Joseph F. Smith, Church president from 1901 to 1918, “participation in these auxiliaries was standardized and expectations of participation began to rise.”Footnote 11
Both Mormons’ and Americans’ broad concerns about their youth were linked to the “discovery” of adolescence in the decades surrounding the turn of the century. Many historians agree that the decades around the turn of the century were a critical period in the development of ideas about adolescence as a discreet period of development between childhood and adulthood.Footnote 12 American educator and psychologist G. Stanley Hall was perhaps most credited with the discovery of adolescence as a “turbulent period of storm and stress linked to puberty.”Footnote 13 Hall suggested in 1904 that “never has youth been exposed to such dangers of both perversion and arrest as in our own land today,” including “increasing urban life with its temptations, prematurities, sedentary occupations, and passive stimuli.”Footnote 14 For Hall, urbanization presented American adolescents with unique challenges and temptations.
As for other progressive reformers, the central question for Mormons, was how to properly direct this period of storm and stress into successful adulthood. One location at which that question crystalized was in concerns over new forms of popular entertainment at which adolescents, often out from underneath the rules that regulated adult life, might let their sexualities and unruliness run wild. No religious organization gave more attention to the entertainment and amusement of their membership than did Mormons, and no attempt at providing cleaner, more respectable entertainments was as successful.Footnote 15
Early in their history, Mormons recognized the need for amusement. Mormonism's founding prophet, Joseph Smith, was a proponent of recreation of many sorts, and even hosted dances in his own home.Footnote 16 In 1868, Church President Brigham Young, also an avid dancer, declared that “we must have exercise and amusement for the mind as well as the body.”Footnote 17 Church leaders have always been concerned that those amusements be proper and pure. However, controlling the amusement of young people became much more difficult for both Mormons and other Americans around the turn of the century. As Kathy Peiss and David Nasaw have pointed out, the rapid urbanization of the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries was critical to the emergence of the new commercial amusements that adolescents and young adults patronized.Footnote 18 Large numbers of young, single, working urban-dwellers created an initial audience for these new amusements and a heterosocial youth peer culture developed in dance halls, amusement parks, movie theaters, and other commercial entertainments. Participation in commercialized entertainments was also linked to emerging shifts in labor. As work hours became more clearly separated from free time, entertainment emerged as an avenue in which young people expressed personal freedom and choice.Footnote 19 By 1900, leisure time came to be seen as a distinctive sphere of life to be, in Peiss's terms, “consciously protected.”Footnote 20 Youth participated in unprecedented numbers in a new culture of leisure that involved patronizing what Peiss calls “cheap amusements”—dance halls, amusement resorts, theaters, and the like.
Peiss shows that fashion was central to women's participation in this emerging commercial youth culture. Adorning themselves in the latest finery and promenading the streets, amusement resorts, and dance halls became important cultural expressions of self for many young women.Footnote 21 The women in Peiss's study closely linked these fashionable expressions to dancing, which became a young woman's “greatest passion” in the early twentieth century.Footnote 22 Once a “family amusement and neighborhood event” that typically involved community members of all ages, dancing now occurred in new commercial ballrooms and dance palaces catering primarily to single youth.Footnote 23 As the place and organization of dancing changed, commercial dance halls opened in unprecedented numbers. New dances also emerged, such as the Turkey Trot, the Bunny Hug, the Grizzly Bear, and the Shimmy, which entailed significant bodily contact and had no standard body positions. Peiss calls these new dance forms “tough dancing.” Reformers found immorality and vice in the new sexual expressiveness in dancing and worried that the new dances simulated sexual acts.Footnote 24
Entertainment was both a heterosocial and homosocial activity. Peiss and Nasaw emphasize the heterosocial and heterosexual nature of the peer culture that developed alongside and within the new commercial entertainments. Entertainments allowed youth to experiment with new gender identities, develop a peer culture apart from parental and community supervision, and mingle more freely with members of the opposite sex. While heterosociality was certainly central to the success of new amusements, Randy McBee and Andrea Radke-Moss find that it was balanced with homosociality among both men and women. Men, who had been accustomed to homosocial leisure in saloons and clubs that excluded most women, struggled to acclimate to the increased presence of women in spaces of public leisure and often maintained homosociality in the presence of women.Footnote 25 Young women attended dances together in groups, and while they danced with young men, they socialized primarily with each other. Nonetheless, young men and women developed a peer culture in these new spaces of amusement that was at once homo- and heterosocial, and they defined their own social forms and codes of conduct out of reach of parental and community control.
These rapid shifts in amusement and youth culture concerned a variety of religious and secular middle-class progressive reformers, including Mormons.Footnote 26 Protestants especially expressed concern over the demand for amusement.Footnote 27 Conservative Protestants opposed amusement altogether, advocating complete abstinence from commercial entertainments.Footnote 28 Other more liberal Protestants, like Washington Gladden of Massachusetts, believed that “There is a right way and a wrong way of using these amusements and they [young people] can easily discern between them.”Footnote 29 They attempted to guide youth to patronize amusements appropriately. The commercialization of entertainment also concerned more secular progressive reformers. For them, as historian LeRoy Ashby suggests, “[T]he problem was not play, but with the way in which commercial hucksters perverted it, fostering elicit thoughts and actions.”Footnote 30
Progressive reformers focused on reforming, not abstaining from, popular amusements; they took a two-pronged approach. First, some progressive reformers offered “other types of amusement in different venues where they believed [young working] women would be safer.”Footnote 31 These reformers sought to provide more wholesome, uplifting amusement opportunities for American youth. They campaigned for parks and playgrounds where people could gather apart from the influence of commercialism. Organizations like the YMCA promoted sports and athletics as a form of good clean fun that also improved physical health.Footnote 32 Some reformers offered more “uplifting” alternatives to commercial entertainments. Jane Addams, a progressive reformer in Chicago, for example, offered free concerts and “uplift theater.” Other settlement houses offered more regulated dances and other amusements in an attempt to draw young people away from the evils of commercial entertainment.Footnote 33 However, most of these efforts failed because their desired constituency simply refused to show up.Footnote 34 As Maureen Flanagan points out, for most youth, these were no competition for the easy, cheap, available popular amusements.Footnote 35
Second, in part because of the failure of more wholesome amusement options, many progressive reformers worked to regulate, if not close down, commercial entertainments. They called on cities and states to regulate public dance halls and censor what could appear on nickelodeon and theater screens, and waged war against the prostitution occurring in saloons and brothels. In response, many municipalities passed legislation that regulated the lighting and environment of dance halls as well as the serving of alcohol and the age of patrons who could enter. Dance halls where “indecent acts” or “disorderly conduct” occurred could have their licenses revoked. These reforms were never as successful as their proponents hoped, however, because enforcement was lax and patrons found myriad ways of skirting the rules and regulations and evading vice investigators and police.Footnote 36 Overall, progressive attempts to reform the commercial amusements of the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries met with very limited success, ensuring that the new commercial amusements would continue to provide youth the sociality they demanded.
Mormon concerns about new heterosocial amusements paralleled that of other progressive reformers, but with uniquely Mormon twists that enabled the Church to become an institution of amusement and sociality as well as worship. While it is likely that the immediate concerns of Church leaders emerged from the development of commercial entertainments in Salt Lake City, Ogden, and other urban areas in Utah, Church leaders saw local developments as a microcosm for a broader national problem. Leaders spoke not in local terms, but in broad generalities about the challenges commercial entertainments posed. Over the early twentieth century, Mormon leaders increasingly saw amusement as an important problem the Church must face. They witnessed their youth patronizing the new commercial amusements and responded with a demand for the Mormon community to provide alternative amusements in the home and the Church. In 1904, LDS Prophet Joseph F. Smith, the Church leader perhaps most concerned with the provision of proper entertainment, declared, “The character and variety of our amusements have so much to do with the welfare and character of our young people that they should be guarded with the utmost jealousy for the preservation of the morals and stamina of the youth of Zion.”Footnote 37 This sentiment characterized Mormon approaches to amusement throughout the early twentieth century.
As Richard Ian Kimball points out, one way the Church guarded the welfare and character of their youth was to offer outdoor programs, often through the Boy Scouts, and athletic programs catering mostly to boys and young men.Footnote 38 To be sure, these programs were intended to draw boys and young men away from commercial entertainments. However, the attention paid here to the Church's concerns about girls and young women alongside boys and young men yields a broader picture of the Church's response to new commercial entertainments aimed at both genders.
Concerns about the amusement of Mormon youth increased dramatically around the turn of the century for several reasons. The influx of non-Mormons created by the completion of the transcontinental railroad in 1869 had made Mormons less isolated and introduced them to increased temptations. Over the next thirty years, non-Mormons established a cultural and political foothold in Utah that, by the early twentieth century, had increased the availability and accessibility of the new commercial entertainments. Non-Mormons owned and operated many of the new forms of commercial entertainment that emerged in Utah cities. Many of these amusements catered to adolescents and young adults who patronized them out from beneath parental and community supervision.
Moreover, new patterns of heterosexual courtship emerged in the wake of the 1890 Woodruff Manifesto that paralleled national trends. As Karen Lystra has demonstrated, romantic love emerged in much of the rest of the nation in the mid- to late nineteenth century.Footnote 39 But romance came late to Mormon courtship. Before the Manifesto, romance was discouraged among Mormons, considered secondary to religious and spiritual concerns in marriage.Footnote 40 While some patterns of romance began to emerge among Mormons before 1890, especially in monogamous relationships, among post-Manifesto young women, romance took its place alongside religion as an important factor in courtship.Footnote 41
Around the turn of the century, national systems of courtship moved out from underneath parental and community supervision to peer cultures of dating and going out.Footnote 42 According to Beth Bailey, the shift from courtship to dating was accompanied by a shift in power from female-controlled courtship, which occurred at the invitation and supervision of women as men called upon young women in their homes, to male-controlled dating as young men invited women on a date in the male-identified public sphere.Footnote 43 It is important to note that until 1890, Mormons under polygamy never had quite the same kind of courtship systems as the rest of the nation. Polygamous and sometimes monogamous courtship in the nineteenth century was sometimes done in secret and usually happened fairly quickly or even not at all.Footnote 44 However, in the thirty years following the manifesto, the temptations of new models of courtship and new commercial entertainments threatened to draw Mormons into the same new dating patterns as the rest of the nation. Religion remained central to Mormon courtship, however, as young Mormon women generally courted not just for pleasure, as did many of their non-Mormon counterparts, but with the expectation of marriage; their courtship practices were more marriage-centered than the average American young women's because “the prospect of marriage was a powerful motivation for young women to conform to certain accepted social norms in the Latter-day Saint community.”Footnote 45 Marriage was “a prize that promised the emotional security of a ‘complete’ and universally appreciated place in Mormon society.”Footnote 46
Relatedly, the official discontinuation of polygamy upset Mormon gender norms as young women and young men struggled to redefine Mormon masculinity and femininity. Young women wrestled with new ideas of “modern” femininity, which competed with the maternal and family-centered demands on Mormon women.Footnote 47 Young men, too, struggled to redefine the meaning of manhood as the Church moved away from one central aspect of Mormon manhood—polygamy.Footnote 48 Moreover, bachelorhood was on the rise both in Utah and nationally, creating a subculture of young men detached from households. Many of these men were invested in creating and maintaining a peer-controlled youth culture of entertainment.Footnote 49 One location where Mormon leaders worked to redefine young masculinity and femininity was in their amusements.
For many Mormons, as with other reformers, the central problem with the new commercial entertainments emerging in cities was that they were moneymaking ventures. One writer for The Improvement Era remarked that Mormons “should remember that amusements and entertainments [should not be] gotten up primarily for the object of making money.”Footnote 50 Many Mormons thought proprietors of commercial amusements were concerned only with profit, and not with social well-being or morality. As early as 1903, one article in The Improvement Era declared that “…one of the evils in many of our towns is that the ownership of dance halls is in the hands of men who are not responsible. We should discourage the patronage of such halls.”Footnote 51 Church President Joseph F. Smith remarked in 1908 that “Those who cater to the public, of course, seek to provide what the public will pay for. It is a matter of dollars and cents with them; and with the public, it is a matter of being amused and entertained.”Footnote 52 Dance halls and other commercial amusements appealed to the basest pleasures of humankind in order to make money.Footnote 53
Mormons rejected, and in some ways reversed, the gender-based double standard pervasive among many Americans that was often more lenient regarding young men's participation in commercial entertainments, while censuring young women's participation in similar behaviors.Footnote 54 Women, after all, were new to public leisure, and their presence in new amusement spaces created opportunities for the heterosocial and heterosexual interactions reformers found so distasteful. Mormons censured both women's and men's participation in these new amusements. Church leaders worried in equal measure that young women and men were going about the cities without adult guidance and engaging in new forms of commercial pleasure. “Many of our girls may be given their freedom to come and go as they please, without a chaperon [sic]. They too often go unguarded and as free as the birds of the air.”Footnote 55
Girls on the loose in urban areas concerned Church leaders, but leaders were more concerned with male participation in certain forms of leisure. Perhaps this was because men had greater opportunities for leisure than their female counterparts.Footnote 56 This may also be because public leisure had been, in the decades after the Civil War, a homosocial, male-only space that posed its own dangers to Mormon men. Men socialized with other men in poolrooms, billiard halls, lodges, and clubs, and the women who were present in these spaces were often prostitutes.Footnote 57 Before 1890, reformers attempted to regulate prostitution even while they also condemned and legislated against the practice of polygamy in Utah.Footnote 58 Both Mormons and non-Mormons condemned prostitution, but non-Mormons claimed prostitution and polygamy were cut from the same cloth—both were examples of lascivious men's exploitation of women's sexuality. Mormons, for their part, tried to distance polygamy from prostitution, arguing that polygamy prevented prostitution by containing men's sexuality in polygamy.Footnote 59 Nonetheless, poolrooms, billiard halls, lodges, and clubs increasingly accompanied the non-Mormon population arriving in Utah after 1869, and concerns increased as urbanization made saloons and pool halls more accessible to city dwellers. While the influx of non-Mormons no doubt hastened the development of saloons, pool halls, and other such institutions, Jeffrey Nichols argues that such institutions likely would have developed even without non-Mormon influence.Footnote 60 Thus, the concern about men's participation in same-sex forms of leisure were rooted in anxieties about both Mormon men's interactions with non-Mormon men and the potential of these sites to encourage prostitution.
Nationally, concerns about increased numbers of bachelors in cities emerged around the turn of the century and continued into the 1930s. As Howard P. Chudacoff points out, bachelors were considered “useless to both family and society” and “seemed to be individuals who had slipped their social moorings and were drifting in an open sea.”Footnote 61 Mormons argued that cities posed particular dangers to young men because they offered a bachelor lifestyle detached from the grounding influence of home life. They worried that young men, detached from their moorings in households and turned loose as bachelors in the cities, “have broken loose from all healthy restraint; they do as they please; they incline to deviltry and rowdyism; love fast living; … and have abandoned home living because it abridges them in their revelries.”Footnote 62 The “revelries” emerging in cities imperiled the moral values of young Mormon men.
Mormons, then, fretted about the dangers of commercial entertainments for both genders. They also rejected, at least in part, the sexual double standard; they were both frustrated and emboldened by laws that prosecuted prostitutes but not their patrons, which often held women more responsible for sexual indiscretion than men.Footnote 63 Mormon anxieties about sexuality unleashed, however, were framed by theological concerns that went beyond the worries of other progressives. To be sure, both Mormons and other reformers fretted about sexual immorality and unwed pregnancy, but Mormon theology added an additional dimension to these concerns. For Mormons, sexuality was an eternal characteristic of all humans and must be contained within marriage not simply in this mortal life, but in the afterlife as well, to engage in spiritual reproduction in heaven.Footnote 64 Thus, when an adolescent's sexuality was corrupted, she or he not only jeopardized her or his earthly morality, but a position in the afterlife. Sexual purity was an eternal as well as an earthly concern for both young men and young women.
One anonymous poem in The Improvement Era best illustrates Mormons’ rejection of the sexual double standard. It read, in part:
Like this anonymous writer, President Smith clarified the nature of the danger of commercial pleasures to both girls and boys: “More cases than one are constantly coming to our notice where sons and daughters have been led astray through their being turned loose at night, going to miserable shows, dance halls, resorts, and cheap penny entertainments.”Footnote 66 Apostle John Henry Smith warned parents and young people of the sexual dangers inherent in the sort of free associations between women and men that commercial entertainments facilitated: “The children entrusted to our watchcare should not be turned loose thoughtlessly … into the companionship of men who scheme and devise for the injury and overthrow of [young women]” or “abandoned and impure women, whose companionship is a menace to thoughtless and imprudent boys … apt to be led from the path of rectitude and the mark of shame written upon their brows by some overt act of an impure character.”Footnote 67 For Mormons, both young men and young women set loose into the commercial entertainments of the city, were vulnerable to the entrapments of impure members of the opposite sex.
On some level, Church leaders did recognize that new commercial entertainments were more sexually perilous for girls and young women. President Smith recognized, though somewhat obliquely, the threat of sexual assault to unchaperoned young women. He warned that “girls associating with men they do not know, and never saw before—being free and unsuspecting in their natures, willing to accept the offers of courtesy and kindness,” may find themselves “in a ball room, dance hall, theatre, or in other places, where they may happen to be, and the first thing they know, they are entrapped and ruined.”Footnote 68 Young women who engaged in these new forms of commercial entertainment might be either tempted into sexual indiscretions of their own accord or, perhaps worse, sexually assaulted and ruined by wicked men. Indeed, like some of his contemporaries, Joseph F. Smith argued that young women too often entered prostitution after being “despoiled and betrayed through undue confidence in man.”Footnote 69
Although women were not entirely innocent, for Smith it was men, more than women, who ruined the opposite sex. He declared that “it is a deplorable fact that society persists in holding woman to stricter account than man in the matter of sexual offense.”Footnote 70 He recognized that while men often blamed women for sexual indiscretion, “in so far as man's injustice inflicts upon her the consequence of his offenses, he stands convicted of multiple guilt. And man is largely responsible for the sins against decency and virtue, the burden of which is too often fastened upon the weaker participant in the crime.”Footnote 71 He went on to say that “whatever of palliation through stress of circumstance may be found for the woman, guilty lust is too generally the primal motive of the man. If the passions of men were kept in natural and wholesome restraint, female virtue would cease to be a purchaseable [sic] commodity.”Footnote 72 While men and women were equally vulnerable to sexual temptation, they were not equally predatory; in this, men held the upper hand.
Statements like these were especially striking in light of anti-prostitution reform in Utah. Especially after 1890, Mormon and anti-Mormon reformers worked together to regulate prostitution in Utah. By the 1870s, it had been formally outlawed, but in practice, reformers agreed to keep prostitution contained in certain areas of Salt Lake City, minimizing the risk that young girls might fall into its trap.Footnote 73 Women arrested for prostitution paid a fine that served as an unofficial licensing fee; men generally got off scot free.Footnote 74 Because it was in the economic interests of the city, Mormons and non-Mormons alike settled for regulating, not abolishing, prostitution, and the legal responsibility for the practice was placed on women, despite the rhetoric that held men more accountable.
The solution to the problem of sexual temptation among the youth, to some extent, relied on the young women of the Church to dress and conduct themselves modestly so as not to arouse men's desires: “[W]e plead with the girls with all the strength and fervency that we possess, be guarded in your manner, be reserved, modest, and dignified. Avoid even the appearance of sin, lest you be wrongfully accused, or be led on step by step until, in an evil moment, you fall, blasting and ruining the prospects of your future life, bringing shame and sorrow to your parents.”Footnote 75 Young women must be modest in their appearance and behavior so as not to tempt young men into indiscretion. The concern about women's fashion illustrates that while leaders held men and women equally accountable for sexual transgression, leaders’ emphasis on dress for young women indicated an underlying double standard when it came to expectations about modesty. Mormon women in the early twentieth century were subject to regulation of their fashion habits in ways that Mormon men never have been.
Though concerns about modesty have been somewhat consistent across Church history, what was different in the early twentieth century, at least according to Relief Society and Young Ladies Mutual Improvement Association (YLMIA) leaders, was that new trends in women's fashion were different enough and immodest enough to invite particular comment and action from Church leaders. In 1902, The Young Woman's Journal expressed concern “with ball costumes and for thin materials. There is a tendency among our girls to have dresses made quite low in the neck and with short sleeves or no sleeves at all … showing the neck and arms through the delicate covering of muslin or other thin material to a somewhat shocking degree.”Footnote 76 They contended that “Dress has a great effect upon our actions,” and “the craving for expensive and showy clothing makes otherwise attractive girls thoughtless and selfish.”Footnote 77 Moreover, immodest dress “calls forth only the disapproval of pure minded men and the hearty disgust of her genteel sisters.”Footnote 78 Church leaders empowered modest dress to call forth “dignified, respectful treatment from others.”Footnote 79
Concern about the immodest fashions of young women peaked in 1916. Two articles by Church officials exhibited these worries. In the June issue of The Young Woman's Journal, Church apostle George F. Richards published an article entitled “Modesty,” calling immodest dress “one of the current evils with which we have to cope.”Footnote 80 Modesty, Richards argued, protected girls from reputations of immorality, and, should a lustful eye look upon her, she may be at fault for a man's “loss of spirituality, and in some instances a loss of virtue.”Footnote 81 The next issue of The Young Woman's Journal, published an address delivered at the YLMIA Officers Meeting in June of 1916 by Church President Joseph F. Smith, which warned again against immodest dress. He claimed that decent men preferred women who were “modestly and neatly dressed in apparel designed to shield, rather than to expose herself to public gaze, as against those who go about the streets half clad.”Footnote 82 Smith then expressed concern that the young women of the Church were associating with strangers that “have no true conception of virtue, nor of that purity which alone can endure throughout time and throughout all eternity.”Footnote 83 The logic of this talk indicated that immodest dress led to associations with non-members, which led to marrying outside of the faith and being denied the blessings of eternity.Footnote 84 At worst, it resulted in incidents of immorality that forced young women to marry to hide their “shame,” obliquely referencing unwed pregnancy.Footnote 85
While Church leaders focused particular attention on modesty, they also emphasized decorum in dancing, especially as dancing gained popularity in the 1910s and 1920s. In 1919, Church apostle Stephen L. Richards suggested in retrospect why dancing attracted such concern when he said, “We regard this work of dancing as being particularly important, not because dancing itself is so important, but because a great many of our people seem to have chosen dancing as almost the exclusive form of recreation to which they give themselves over.”Footnote 86 Church leaders also claimed that modesty in dress was intimately related to modesty in dancing. In 1916, apostle George F. Richards stated: “Immodesty in dress becomes more dangerous and disastrous in its effects when associated with immodesty in the dance. Girls who in immodest attire permit themselves to be wrapped in the close embrace of men in the wriggling, suggestive movements of some of our new dances set to ragtime music or something worse, are subjecting themselves and others to very great temptations.”Footnote 87 The increased popularity of round dances such as the waltz, the foxtrot, and the two-step, and perhaps even the close and “tough” dancing to which Peiss refers, concerned Church leaders.Footnote 88 One article on ballroom etiquette remarked, “Round dancing is often indecent and immodest, and is even more dangerous, physically, than the plain ‘square’ dance or quadrille.”Footnote 89 Despite Church leaders’ concerns, round dances like the waltz and the foxtrot made their way into Church dances by the early twentieth century, though some Church leaders had tried to limit them in favor of the more modest square and quadrille dances.Footnote 90
Although dancing attracted more attention from Church leaders than other forms of amusement, Church leaders tried to temper the new temptations of them all. Perhaps because of their history of embracing leisure and dance as legitimate human expressions, Mormons did not advocate total abstinence from amusement. Salt Lake City and other areas in Utah regulated dance halls by 1920.Footnote 91 However, the emphasis of Mormonism's campaign against the new amusements was to appeal to Church youth as Mormons and call upon them to preserve their Mormon identity in their amusements. Church leaders also called upon the membership and leadership of the Church to assist the youth in maintaining a distinctive Mormon identity.
Church leaders took a three-pronged approach to the problem of amusements that both reflected and departed from the strategies of other reformers of the time. First, they attempted to cultivate in their youth an ethic of restraint, decorum, moderation, and good taste in making choices about their entertainment pursuits. This was not an unusual strategy among progressives, but Mormons formulated this ethic of restraint within the context of their theology of free agency. God, Mormons believed, had given humankind freedom to choose in their mortal sojourn as a kind of test of loyalty to the faith. When Mormon adolescents made choices against Church council, they marked themselves as out of harmony with the Church community.
Second, in order to provide good options for youth to choose, Church leaders implored Mormon young and adult women to make their homes places of amusement “so attractive, so interesting that they will outdraw the public dance hall, the public resort, the moving picture show, and every other form of entertainment that takes our boys and girls away from the home.”Footnote 92 This strategy was fairly distinctive to Mormons. Other progressive reformers focused on reforming commercial entertainments themselves and on providing spaces like settlement houses and the YMCA and YWCA where youth could live and sometimes socialize under supervision.
Third, leaders gradually called the Church itself to provide more “wholesome” alternatives through the Young Ladies’ and Young Men's Mutual Improvement Associations. This strategy reflected other progressive reform strategies occurring in settlement houses and YMCAs and YWCAs, but they were much more successful in drawing youth participation. Moreover, in ways unmatched by any other religious organization, by the end of the 1910s, Church leaders had demonstrated their faith in the Church organization to solve the problem of entertainment by institutionalizing Mormon sociality Church-wide.
Over the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, the Church actively cultivated among its youth an ethic of self-restraint, moderation, and good taste in their quests for amusement. This was particularly evident in the ways the Word of Wisdom, the Mormon prohibition of alcohol, tobacco, coffee, and tea, came to the foreground of Mormon identity around the turn of the century. Thomas G. Alexander and Amy Hoyt and Sara M. Patterson have noted that the increased concern about adherence to the Word of Wisdom came about in the wake of the Woodruff Manifesto; as polygamy faded, post-manifesto leaders emphasized adherence to the Word of Wisdom as a marker of Mormon distinctiveness.Footnote 93 In this context, perhaps because Church leaders worried much more about young men's potential to break the Word of Wisdom, this ethic of restraint was, in part, gendered.Footnote 94 Church leaders were very concerned about the attraction of saloons and poolrooms for young men: “We know a few bright boys who are wasting their energy and money in pool rooms, and seldom spend a night at home. But the day is sure to come when they will be very sorry over their spent money and their wasted time.”Footnote 95 Church leaders cautioned young men against pool rooms and saloons: “Boys, quit wasting your time and money, and start a reformation today. … Don't take another step that will lead you to the pool room or the saloon, no matter what the inducements are. Rather, break with your companions and stand alone rather than spend another hour wasting your energy and force on the downward road.”Footnote 96
Both genders, though, were instructed to exercise restraint in their entertainment choices. Joseph F. Smith declared that amusements “should not be excessive; and young people should be discouraged from giving themselves up to the spirit and trivolity [sic] of excessive mirth.”Footnote 97 He further cautioned Church youth that “what these young people do themselves, and the attitude which they assume … matters very greatly to them personally. It means in the end either success or failure for them morally, and for that reason is of great consequence to them. They must choose for themselves, and they must choose right … if they expect to keep themselves uncontaminated from the vices and abominations of the world.”Footnote 98 Not only must the youth choose proper entertainment, but they must choose to conduct themselves properly when pursuing any entertainment. For Joseph F. Smith, “The great key words, as stated, are decency in dress and proper conduct, as well as gentlemanly and lady-like deportment in social gatherings and dances. Deportment that will lead to clean, innocent, genuine pleasure, and steer away from the kind that in the end leaves a sting of sin, sorrow and regret—deportment that will herald the making of true men and women of character.”Footnote 99 It was not only the choice of amusement, but how youth behaved while amusing themselves that protected them from the dangers of commercial entertainments.
Church leaders also urged moderation in amusement. They believed that “many become cloyed and surfeited by excessive pleasures. Their appreciation becomes benumbed, and they go to fatal excesses, in order to stimulate their sense of pleasure.”Footnote 100 Leaders echoed the concerns of some Protestant reformers who believed that moderate dancing could be healthy, but in excess it “over-exhausted the female system.”Footnote 101 Church leaders worried especially that too much dancing would “contribute to make the nerves unsteady” and “is often a serious cause of moral degeneracy.”Footnote 102 Youth, particularly young women, were encouraged to cultivate variety in their amusements to avoid excessive dancing: “[S]he should not dance to excess nor cultivate a preference for dancing above other forms of amusements. Her pleasures like her food should be diversified.”Footnote 103 Too much pleasure stimulated bad emotions in the youth and was to be avoided.
More broadly, Church leaders suggested that “It cannot be denied that the proneness of the present age is toward the frivolous, the obscene and the low. … [T]he legitimate and the orderly do not appear to suffice; the hazardous, the dangerous, that which unnaturally agitates and stirs the feelings is sought after instead.”Footnote 104 Mormons were concerned that their youth simply spent too much time and energy in the pursuit of amusement. According to President Smith, “The danger lies in making it [recreation] a purpose instead of an occasional diversion and in seeking it among those whose influence is not uplifting.”Footnote 105 This concern was linked to Church leaders’ worry that twentieth-century youth were losing the pioneer fortitude with which life on the frontier had equipped their parents and grandparents. City life, leaders thought, was making youth, young men especially, soft and lazy.Footnote 106
Motivated by concerns that youth spent too much time recreating, making them soft, Mormon leaders thought it important to cultivate in their youth not only self-control, but discernment in identifying good pleasures and bad. One author lamented the passing of the custom of chaperonage, declaring that “The path, therefore, of safety for the youth lies ‘through their own self-control.’ But this self-control can only come through the training of the critical faculty of discrimination.”Footnote 107 “Our duty,” President Smith declared, “lies in cultivating a better taste in the choice of amusements, and a more rational preference in recreation.”Footnote 108 Young men and women should make good, moderate, and tasteful choices in their pursuit of amusement. In order to provide such options for youth to choose, President Smith declared in 1908 that “some recreation must be provided. Certainly; and it should be provided not only in the home, but also in our public ward and stake organizations, for which genuine loyalty should also be early taught.”Footnote 109
Many Mormons saw increased participation in commercial entertainments among youth as a failure in the home. In a unique twist on progressive reformers’ attempts to provide alternative wholesome amusements, Mormons, more than other progressives, emphasized home amusements. While other progressives emphasized alternative public amusements for youth in places like settlement houses or YMCAs and YWCAs, Mormons called on women, especially, to make the home a place of amusement. A lesson, printed in The Young Woman's Journal, declared that “many parents either through lack of knowledge or through neglect of opportunity have failed to make the home all it should be socially. As a result, many Latter-day Saint children are drifting away from its protection. They are seeking their pleasures in other places.”Footnote 110 Repeated injunctions in both The Young Woman's Journal and The Improvement Era advocated making the home the foremost place of amusement. President Smith declared that “We may well invest means in the home for the comfort, convenience, entertainment and training of our children. We may well give our sons and daughters some time for recreation and diversion, and some provision in the home for satisfying their longing for legitimate physical and mental recreation, to which every child is entitled, and which he will seek in the street or in objectionable places, if it is not provided in the home.”Footnote 111 He went on to ask, “But what are we doing in our homes to enlighten [our children]? What to encourage them to make home their place of amusement, and a place where they may invite their friends for study or entertainment?”Footnote 112 The Mormon home should be another line of defense against the temptations of the new commercial pleasures.Footnote 113
It was more the responsibility of young and mature women than men to make the home a place of entertainment; here, a double standard was embraced. One essay by Susa Young Gates, writing as “Aunt Su,” gave specific advice for Mormon women of all ages entertaining in the home. She advocated simplicity and modesty in providing entertainments, and provisions should always be within the means of the hostess. She claimed that “What our young people need, is not more pleasure, of any kind, but more simplicity in the giving thereof, and less altogether of that exciting and dangerous stimulant [pleasure].”Footnote 114 “Aunt Su” even went so far as to critique some Mormon institutions and entertainments, claiming that “We are racing after parties, picnics and pleasuring, as individuals, as families, as wards, and as stakes. Excursions in the summer, parties and dances in the winter, absorb nearly all the time and strength of young and old.”Footnote 115 Church leaders seemed to keep members “going all day and night.”Footnote 116 Mormons, she maintained, spent too much time in Church entertainments and too little in the simplicity of home entertainments.
More broadly, the YLMIA encouraged women and girls especially to combat the evils of commercial entertainments with entertainments in the home. They were instructed to make their homes the center of LDS social life. A series of lessons in The Young Woman's Journal advocated having family “Home Nights,” making mealtimes social events, and hosting and attending home parties.Footnote 117 Another lesson declared that “If more home parties were given, children and young people would less frequently seek amusement at public dance halls or shows.”Footnote 118 Of utmost importance for home parties was the guest list. One article, in The Young Woman's Journal suggested that invitations be provided to individuals, not couples, to invite more sociality between guests and avoid too much pairing off. The article also cautioned against inviting non-Mormons and strangers or loose acquaintances.Footnote 119 Overall, it was the calling of women and girls to “make our homes so attractive, so interesting, that they will outdraw the public dance hall, the public resort, the moving picture show, and every other form of entertainment that takes our boys and girls away from the home.”Footnote 120 Home entertainment would protect the youth from the moral temptations that awaited them in places of popular amusement. The consistent message to parents, especially, but to the youth as well, was to make the home more preferable than the new forms of entertainment.
In some ways, this home entertainment hearkened back to the older models Beth Bailey discussed where courtship took place under the watchful eyes of family, in this case under the protective umbrella of Mormon households. In other ways, however, home entertainments mirrored the new entertainments, providing safe avenues for young people to experience new forms of entertainment. One article recommended the following forms of amusement at home socials: “games of skill, guessing games, literary games, mirth-provoking games, and musicals.”Footnote 121 Joseph F. Smith advocated providing “good books, games, music, and well-lighted, well-ventilated, warm rooms for their convenience and pleasure.”Footnote 122 Church leaders thus provided some guidance to parents and youth themselves about how to make the home a place of amusement, but overall placed the responsibility on families and youth to amuse themselves and each other under parental supervision.
One report from the South Davis Stake suggests the success of some of these efforts. In addition to providing dances, ward theatricals, and other entertainments, the South Davis YLMIA organized “supplementary evenings, devoted to ‘class preparation.’” The class preparations were held on a rotating basis at each YLMIA girl's home, followed by socializing. The report commented that “the social feature, which consisted of excellent but simple refreshments served after lessons were over, and the accompanying chat and good comradeship added greatly to the attractions.” The classes were so popular that they had to expand their efforts and divide the attendees into smaller groups.Footnote 123
Church leaders did not realistically expect youth to stay completely away from the new entertainments and only engage in entertainment in the home. Home entertainment, Mormon leaders argued, was not enough and must be buttressed by the Church; the Church itself must provide amusements for its youth through local ward leadership. As early as 1899, Joseph F. Smith, then Second Counselor in the First Presidency of the Church, called for “Every organization of the church [to] take part in this needed reform among our young people.”Footnote 124 Three years later, an article in The Young Woman's Journal declared that “The MIA should be a social circle and should provide wholesome amusement for its members. Our girls should have no excuse for going elsewhere for their pleasure.”Footnote 125 Nearly a year after that, an article in The Improvement Era suggested “to those in charge of ward affairs that many of our young men and maidens fair, failing to find their desires for amusement gratified within, go outside in pursuit of it. Then is taken the first step that leads them away from the protecting care of the church. It often results, as far too many broken-hearted parents know, in misery and woe. … To obviate this unhappy result, we suggest that more attention be given to local amusements.”Footnote 126 In 1908, Joseph F. Smith echoed these concerns as President of the Church. He reported that far too many youth attended “non-‘Mormon’ social organizations, because these afford better facilities for amusement and recreation than is provided in our ward organizations.”Footnote 127 He declared that “supplementary to the training in the home, it is to be hoped that our organizations will as soon as possible provide every arrangement for legitimate entertainment and recreation, physical and intellectual, that will tend to attract our young people, and hold them interested, loyal, and contented within the pale of our own influence and organizations.”Footnote 128
Over the first decades of the twentieth century, calls for additional and improved Church activities found willing audiences, as local wards organized amusement and activities committees to direct the social affairs of the ward, especially the youth. The Fourth Ward of the Salt Lake Stake, for example, organized concerts, a Juvenile Dramatic Company that put on plays for the ward, farewell parties, and home parties.Footnote 129 Other ward MIAs and Primaries put on variety shows and plays at missionary farewell parties, home parties, and other social gatherings as well.Footnote 130 Some of these were fundraisers for ward amusement halls, for missionaries, or, at least in one instance, “to help extricate [the ward] from debt and interest.”Footnote 131 The archival record contains dozens of advertisements and records of similar events, indicating their success at attracting the participation of Church youth. Many of these activities continued well into the twentieth century, sometimes in the form of “road shows,” vaudevillian performances that began in the 1930s and traveled from meeting house to meeting house to perform.
Although youth participation in these Church amusements is difficult to gauge precisely, home and Church dances were held quite frequently and over long periods of time, indicating high participation rates. Moreover, the marriage-centered courtship patterns no doubt drew youth to Church entertainments. The test of time also indicates that Mormon attempts to draw their youth into more wholesome amusements were much more successful than those of progressive reformers. Many Mormon entertainments developed in the early twentieth century remain central to the culture and practice of Mormonism today. Mormons continue to host frequent dances and other activities for their youth and church buildings remain centers of social as well as religious activity.
In the early twentieth century, though, Church entertainments were somewhat ad hoc and often lacked coordination and appropriate restraint. It seems that precisely because Church amusements were so successful that some of the evils of commercial entertainment crept into Church-sponsored activities; Church entertainments had failed to keep out the dangers of the world. In January 1916, the editors of The Improvement Era declared that “We think there is need of more careful management and supervision, stricter order and discipline, and greater attention to details and etiquette than now obtains in our ward socials.”Footnote 132 Thus, it was not enough that amusements be held under the auspices of the Church—Church amusements themselves had to be reformed and monitored to prevent the dangerous practices of public entertainments, and especially the public dance hall, from encroaching into Church-sponsored activities. Over the 1910s and 1920s the Church developed educational opportunities to train local leaders in recreational leadership.Footnote 133
The year 1916 marked the beginning of a much more institutionalized and correlated effort from Church authorities to reform the dancing, dress, and sociality of the Church's youth. In June 1916, at a conference of the YMMIA and YLMIA, leaders introduced a set of rules for MIA activities, including the establishment of social or amusement committees in all wards and stakes.Footnote 134 In September of that year the Church Presidency issued a “Call to the Women of the Church” that it sent to the General Boards of the Relief Society, the YLMIA, and the Primary, along with the General Boards of the Sunday School, the YMMIA, and the Religion Class, and was later published in the January 1917 issues of The Young Woman's Journal and the Relief Society Magazine. This call expressed Church leaders’ feeling “that there exists a pressing need of improvement and reform among our young people,” declaring that “Our women are prone to following the demoralizing fashions of the world” and that “Many of our youth of both sexes are fast approaching a state of depravity in dancing and in their feverish pursuit of frivolous and dissipating pleasures.”Footnote 135 It called for the women of the Church, “as the chief officers of a great and influential auxiliary within the church, to give this matter immediate consideration.”Footnote 136 The “General Boards that are composed of women” addressed modesty first, resolving that the women lead by example, recommitting themselves to modesty in their own dress.Footnote 137 A rush of addresses and articles followed, restating and emphasizing the need for modesty in dress among the young women of Zion.
This call for improvement and reform led to the establishment of the Social Advisory Committee in November 1916. While the minutes of the Committee are currently closed to researchers, one 1983 article by Thomas G. Alexander, written when the minutes were still open to at least some researchers, sheds light on the Committee and its attempts to reform Church amusements. The Committee was composed of representatives from the Council of the Twelve Apostles, the MIA, the Relief Society, the Primary, the YMMIA, the YLMIA, Zion's Aid Society, Religion class Department, and the Deseret Sunday School Union. At one of their first meetings, the Committee “agreed to propose a program including strict chaperonage of girls at parties and dances, moderation in dress …, censorship of movies depicting crime, and prohibition of what were then considered extreme forms of dancing based on jazz and popular music.”Footnote 138 A few months later, “President Joseph F. Smith approved the organization of stake and ward level social advisory committees to coordinate social work … activities on the local level.”Footnote 139
In early 1917, the Committee published a pamphlet titled “Instructions on Social Work,” which was reprinted in the April 1917 issues of The Improvement Era, the Juvenile Instructor, the Relief Society Magazine, and the Children's Friend, and was widely distributed among MIA leaders. The pamphlet formalized the expectations of Church-sponsored entertainments, especially dances. Alongside “Instructions on Social Work,” a leaflet on dress also emerged that detailed expectations for young women's modesty.Footnote 140 Together, these publications marked the institutionalization of what previously had been largely informal local campaigns to reform the social interactions of Church youth.
As Alexander points out, the activities of the Social Advisory Committee stretched beyond monitoring and regulating the amusement of young people, making clear that the Committee, and Mormon leadership more broadly, viewed the problem of amusement as one piece of a larger project of the moral reform of youth.Footnote 141 Although the Committee dabbled in many social problems, one of its primary concerns continued to be Mormon youth sociality, especially dancing. At the Committee's 1919 conference, for example, the primary topic of concern was dancing styles, and in the early 1920s, the Committee advocated the building of amusement halls alongside new or renovated meeting halls so that local wards and stakes would have a place in which to conduct Church-sponsored entertainments.Footnote 142 In these amusement halls, currently called cultural halls, local wards provided and continue to provide recreational opportunities such as wholesome movies, dances, parties, athletics, and other gatherings.
In the early twentieth century, in response to concerns about youth participation in new forms of unacceptable commercial entertainment, the Church formally became an institution of amusement as well as worship, especially for youth. With remarkable success, uncommon among other progressive reformers, the unique approach of the LDS Church to the problem of emerging popular amusements seemed to draw their youth into the fold of the Church's amusements. By the mid-1920s, however, it had become clear that the Church increasingly saw entertainment as the province of youth; in 1923 the Church turned its entertainment programming over to the YLMIA and YMMIA, which gave instructions for amusements Church-wide, where it remained until the 1960s.Footnote 143
Since the early twentieth century, the Church has maintained a comprehensive program providing entertainment and amusement for its youth that has continued well into the twentieth and twenty-first centuries. In some ways, these efforts reflected those of other progressive reformers, but in other ways Mormon responses to the new commercial entertainments were unique. Their responses to gendered modes of participation in commercial leisure rejected the double standard that often focused efforts on women's participation in commercial leisure; Mormons targeted men's and women's leisure alike. Moreover, unlike other progressives, Mormons succeeded in providing alternative entertainments that mirrored commercial entertainments and that their youth would actually patronize. Indeed, faithful Mormons will likely recognize remnants of the early twentieth-century reform efforts in their contemporary Church-sponsored amusements. While the institutional structure has changed, the impulse has remained the same: to keep the youth as loyal members of the Church community through providing distinctly Mormon amusements. Echoes of the unique ways Mormons responded to the challenges of early commercial entertainments remain in the twenty-first-century Church's emphasis on young women's modesty, as well as in the highly chaperoned, modest entertainments for young people that the Church continues to provide today.
