During the author's two year Peace Corps commitment, he volunteered as an outreach street educator for a non-governmental organisation (NGO) working with street children in Santo Domingo, Dominican Republic. His manuscript is both an anecdotal report of his time with a group of homeless adolescent boys, and a social science exploration of their situation. In the first case, we meet not only the street children but the drug dealers, cops and jailers, and even the prostitutes the boys are involved with. Intertwined with this are the author's feelings about them, and this is blended into his analysis.
In the introduction the author divides previous work about street children into the structural and cultural point of view. The structural approach claims that the economic factors including the widening gap between rich and poor and the resultant need of street children to find work in the service economy are the major factors in understanding their lives. As the author mentions, the mere presence of street children illustrates a moral failure of the economic system. The cultural approach shows how, as tourism became a more central cultural (and economic) force in the Dominican Republic, the lives of street children changed. In this point of view a single mother copes with poverty by sending her eldest son to the street to work, and she hedges her bets by taking on a man to help support her, but who helps to push out the boy from the home. The street child is pulled to the street by the culture of street life that relies on the tourist trade for income, including sex work.
Each chapter begins with an account of one or more boys and the consequences of their lives and ends with an evaluative commentary which explains the ethnographic notes. This structure serves the reader well, because one of the author's strengths is his ability to connect the two seamlessly. The author's ability to write well is evident from little jargon, and a lot of specific examples of people and events.
By showing us the boys in their contexts, their homes, the juvenile remand home, the hospital, the criminals and pimps, etc., we see what they are up against and how they cope. What we get is the overriding imagery of poverty and limited opportunity. The boys accept this, perhaps, more than others who stay at home, they are engaging in life, no matter how sordid it is. We can see them fight to avoid becoming palomos, street children who are not coping and can be seen because they are not taking care of their hygiene, wearing rags, being addicted to drugs as evidenced by their constant attachment to a bottle filled with glue or gas, and who eat from dumpsters. In the end it appears their problems have more to do with their dependence on drugs, and the money and deeds they need to get them, than it is on street life per se.
As the author says, it is almost impossible to predict how any one boy will end up, and we are left with the impression that they are both strong and weak: strong in their ability to leave dismal home situations, cope on the streets with difficult circumstances, not the least of which is having to make nearly impossible choices between giving up long-standing friendships for personal survival, but, weak, in their dependence on drugs, which comes with violence and sex work. As a reader I went from admiration to despair; I imagine, not much different from how the boys felt themselves.
The author reveals, subtly and not in any unseemly way that might dominate the narrative, information about himself. We see, at several times during the narrative, that he cares about these boys and is committed to helping them. His attachment does not smother his intellectual view. In fact we see how it helps him face tough choices (like the boys he studies) like for example given the situation of some of children's family, he empathises with their decision not to return. He admires their sense of freedom, their tenaciousness and he shows his frustration about how fate of where and when one (we) is born and to which parents and even our gender and skin colour determines so much of who we will become. In this case it means the unlikelihood of moving from a world of street life and to a world much beyond survival at a level of poverty unknown to most of us reading this book.
There is wisdom in the way the author measures his success as a street educator, which is by small victories in small wars, a change of attitude even if temporary, a moment or two of self-reflection where there was none before. He understands that forcing street children to return to families which at best are only dysfunctional or to incarcerate them will do little to help them. By his wiliness to become involved in their lives, and admiring the children for their courage and cunning, he makes a difference. NGOs, like the one he worked for, come and go and change continually, and no matter what they claim as their approach, it is this human connection that matters, and what matters is small and individual and temporary, one meal at a time or one medical intervention when needed, not sweeping claims by large international organisations. In this, this book is less about Latin American street children than it is about all street children.
