Charles W. Calhoun's From Bloody Shirt to Full Dinner Pail traces the profound transformation of national politics from a near fixation on race and sectionalism in the 1860s to a primary focus on economic policy by the 1890s. The author's emphasis is on the relentless struggle for power at the national level. Because most voters resided in the Northeast and Midwest during this period, these sections play a pivotal role in Calhoun's story.
As with other revisionist studies of Gilded Age politics produced over the past forty or so years, Calhoun operates on the presumption that voters perceived real differences between the major parties and found substance in the issues that the parties agitated. Not all writers on the subject have seen it this way. Mark Twain and Charles Dudley Warner, whose novel The Gilded Age (1873) gave the era its popular name, emphasized corruption in both politics and society. Early twentieth-century writers, such as Vernon Louis Parrington and Matthew Josephson, de-emphasized the struggle over the tariff, the favorite issue of Democrats and Republicans alike, as a sham battle designed to divert voters from real issues, such as currency reform and labor conditions. This essentially was the Populist position. Parrington had been a Populist in the 1890s and probably remained one spiritually the rest of his life. Josephson was a Marxist who found all reforms that enabled capitalists to retain power to be inadequate.
Beginning after World War II, but particularly during the 1960s, scholars began to take the issues that major party politicians agitated more seriously. Enough time had passed for a less partisan examination of the era's politics. From Bloody Shirt to Full Dinner Pail operates thoroughly within the revisionist camp. All of the main controversial issues—race, sectionalism, the tariff, and currency reform—were present throughout the Gilded Age. The transformation that Calhoun identifies is a matter of emphasis, not absolutes. Calhoun's talent as a writer serves him well in explaining the nuances of change because the events and personalities he draws upon are not new to the scholars of this era. The pivotal year of transition from the old issues to the new is 1880, when, Calhoun argues, “no one could say with certainty whether sectional or economic issues had exerted the greater influence” (75).
Earlier scholars emphasized corruption. Like other revisionists, Calhoun does not deny its existence. The Credit Mobilier scandal and Grover Cleveland's illegitimate child make their appearance, but the author does not make boodle or scandal the defining characteristics of the era. The struggle between two governing ideals, Republican Party nationalism and Democratic Party localism, is the focus. The GOP was not shy about guiding the nation toward unity, both culturally and economically. Democrats placed more emphasis upon laissez-faire economics and personal liberties (particularly with respect to white southerners' treatment of African Americans). Although it was a period of political equilibrium, the more activist GOP seemed to dominate the era and thus dominates this book.
Calhoun bases From Bloody Shirt to Full Dinner Pail on the relevant primary and secondary sources. He draws from his own work, Conceiving a New Republic: The Republican Party and the Southern Question, 1869–1900 (2006), in emphasizing the continuing disorder in racial matters. He also draws upon his most recent book, Minority Victory: Gilded Age Politics and the Front Porch Campaign of 1888 (2008), for the transition in campaign methods designed, at least in part, to avoid a repeat of the infamous “Rum, Romanism, and Rebellion” gaff that played a part in James G. Blaine's 1884 defeat.
Republicans, of course, had their problems during this era. Blaine's loss to Grover Cleveland in 1884 was a bitter pill to swallow. The GOP's reduction of the embarrassing Treasury surplus with the “Billion Dollar Congress” of 1890 placed Democrats back in power in 1892. Fortunately for the GOP, Democrats took over just in time to receive blame for the Depression of the 1890s. The 1890 Congress also saw Republicans make one last attempt to protect southern blacks by introducing the Lodge Federal Elections Bill. Western Republicans, in the end, sabotaged the bill in return for southern Democrats' help on currency reform, a perfect example of the author's theme in this book. William McKinley's election in 1896 “marked the effective abandonment of blacks' rights by the GOP” (167). The author's final assessment is that “McKinley decisively turned the nation away from the old Civil War party system, although the idiom of race and section remained dominant in the South” (180). This, of course, betrays Calhoun's emphasis on the Northeast, Midwest, and Republican Party. Although most voters resided in these sections and would vote primarily Republican for decades after 1896, the sectional orientation of this balloting probably was stronger after 1896 than before. The northern abandonment of African American rights created a more uniform culture of race relations but did not undermine sectionalism. As Calhoun astutely notes, Democrats went on to wave a Bloody Gray Shirt for decades after the 1890s.
The emergence of William Jennings Bryan as the leader of the Democratic Party marked the party's takeover by its southern and western wings. Bryan's ascension as party leader may have been necessary to keep the Democratic Party from going the way of the Whigs. Given the hardship of the depression of the 1890s, Grover Cleveland's continued domination of the Democratic Party could have led to its collapse. Populists, of course, were waiting in the wings to fill the void.
From Bloody Shirt to Full Dinner Pail is excellent on Republican Party national politics during the Gilded Age, but a bit less so on the Democratic and Populist parties during the 1890s. Still, this book provides a strong overview of politics during Gilded Age America and is recommended for scholars and popular readers alike.
