Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-z4zkx Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T16:20:22.722Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Sharing risk: the Netherlands' new approach to pensions

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  28 May 2008

EDUARD H. M. PONDS
Affiliation:
ABP Pension Fund, Tilburg University and Netspar (e-mail: eduard.ponds@apb.nl)
BART VAN RIEL
Affiliation:
SER and Leiden University (e-mail: b.van.riel@ser.nl)
Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

The solvency crisis in 2001–2004 urged Dutch pension funds to reconsider their final-pay plans with de facto unconditional indexation. Most pension funds switched to an average-wage plan with solvency-contingent indexation. This pension plan redesign was the outcome of a new compromise between the major stakeholders of Dutch pension funds. The redesign is of interest as it results in a hybrid combination of DB and DC. This new setting indeed greatly improves solvency risk management. Moreover, the new plan structure appears to be welfare-dominant compared to other collective plan settings and individual alternatives, as it improves the conditions for intergenerational risk sharing. However, drawbacks of the new plans are the lack of transparency and potential welfare loss for individuals because of the inherent contingent claim structure of the new plan. Moreover, the plan redesign has led to value redistribution from older to younger plan participants.

Information

Type
Issues and Policy
Copyright
Copyright © 2008 Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.Sources of income of pension funds (1987–2005)

Source: Statistics Netherlands.
Figure 1

Figure 2.Percent of active participants in defined benefit plans by type, 1998–2005

Source: Dutch Central Bank (2006).
Figure 2

Figure 3.Hybrid DB-DC plan

Figure 3

Figure 4.Traditional DB

Figure 4

Figure 5.Collective DC

Figure 5

Table 1.ALM projections

Figure 6

Table 2.ALM results for pension-plan variants (2006–2025)

Figure 7

Table 3.Summary results of ALM analysis*

Figure 8

Table 4.Welfare comparison of alternative pension plans with optimal individual plan

Figure 9

Figure 6.Confidence (moderate to high) in retirement income providing institutions

Source: van Dalen and Henkens (2006). The bars display the relative share of people, differentiated to their life-phase and where the total reflects the weighted average, with a moderate to high confidence in institutions delivering retirement income provisions: banks and insurance (taken together), government and pension funds.
Figure 10

Figure 7.Value redistribution between generations over 2006–2025 when from traditional DB plan to hybrid DB-DC plan or to collective DC plan (as % of total nominal liabilities 2006)

Source: Hoevenaars and Ponds (2007). The horizontal axis denotes the age of the cohorts in the plan in 2006. The analysis looks 20 years forward, so also members of cohort −2 will be part of the labor force in 2025. The cohort with an age of 105 will die with certainty within one year. The vertical axis reports the change in generational accounts of each of the age cohorts (generations).