Introduction
Ultra-wideband (UWB) technology, a method of wireless communication method functioning within the frequency range of 3.1–10.6 GHz, has garnered substantial interest in recent times given the increasing need for swift wireless communication systems. The Federal Communications Commission (FCC) approved this frequency band for commercial usage in 2002. UWB technology is associated with several benefits, including impressive data transfer speeds, efficient power usage, and robust resistance to interference [Reference Rao Devana, Kusuma Kumari and S1]. However, designing a UWB antenna with consistent and predictable performance across the entire band is a challenging task. The antenna must also have high radiation efficiency and be able to accommodate the UWB bandwidth. In addition, UWB antenna featuring notched bands is popular in many applications, which can avoid interference with other narrowband services such as WLAN, WiMAX, and X-band satellite communication [Reference Z, P and Y2].
There are many methods for producing multi-band notch bands in UWB antennas [Reference Singh and Kalraiya3–Reference Zhao, Zhang and Lu14], including etching a splitted concentric ring (SCR) on the radiating element [Reference Singh and Kalraiya3, Reference Lin, Lu and Wang4, Reference Premalatha, Prasad and Murthy6, Reference Sharma7, Reference Chilukuri and Gogikar11, Reference Rahmatian, Moradi and Movahhedi13, Reference Zhao, Zhang and Lu14], loading slot and parasitic branches on the antenna [Reference Babu, Ramakrishna and Ensermu5, Reference Deng, Lai and Wang8, Reference P, Kumar and Ali9, Reference Roy, K and Nandi12], embedding electromagnetic band gap (EBG) structures on the ground plane [Reference Dilruba Geyikoglu10]. The abovementioned antennas have no more than five notched bands in the designed operating frequency band, and it is still challenging to design more notched bands in a small size antenna.
At the same time, wearable antennas have received widespread attention for its revolutionary potential in the fields of communications, health monitoring, and medical applications [Reference Chilukuri and Gogikar11–Reference Wang, Cheng-zhuacaa, Shu and YueZhi-Huaa18]. In Chilukuri and Gogikar [Reference Chilukuri and Gogikar11], the wearable textile antenna is designed on two different dielectric substrate, which show that the antenna has an impedance bandwidth of 1.8–10 GHz with two notched bands. In Roy and Nandi [Reference Roy, K and Nandi12], a flexible and wearable UWB antenna based on jeans substrate is proposed. The antenna shows the operating frequency ranges (S11 ≤ − 10 dB) in 2.4–4.2 GHz and 5.86–10.7 GHz bands with notch properties in telemetry/mobile communications (4.4–4.99 GHz) and WLAN (5.15–5.85 GHz) band. In Rahmatian et al. [Reference Rahmatian, Moradi and Movahhedi13], a planar full-ground plane UWB antenna based on PDMS substrate is presented with ability to reject C band (6.3–7.15 GHz) using split ring slots. In Zhao et al. [Reference Zhao, Zhang and Lu14], a miniaturized wearable antenna is proposed with five notched features, covering the entire UWB spectrum from 2.56 GHz to 12.7 GHz. In Lee and Park [Reference Hoosung and Yong Bae15], a flexible wideband antenna operating in WLAN/c band /x band is designed. In Chengzhu et al. [Reference Chengzhu, Wang and Zhong17], an ultra-thin CPW-fed ultra-wideband flexible MIMO antenna for Internet of Things (IoT) applications is proposed, covering the entire spectrum from 4.4 GHz to 39.2 GHz. In Wang et al. [Reference Wang, Cheng-zhuacaa, Shu and YueZhi-Huaa18], a compact coplanar waveguide (CPW) fed wearable slot antenna with four notched bands for ultra-wideband (UWB) applications is presented, and the impedance bandwidth of the measured antenna ranges from 2.46 GHz to 12.52 GHz.
Various flexible substrate materials such as Fleece, Perspex, Plastic materials, Cotton, Rogers Duroid RO3003™ (semi-flexible), Polyurethane, Jeans, etc., are commonly used as substrates in wearable antennas. Different flexible materials have different properties, so the choice of substrate is particularly important. Liquid crystal polymer (LCP), as an innovative substrate material, has the advantages of low dielectric loss, minimum coefficient of thermal expansion and cost effectiveness, and is the preferred material for flexible antenna design [Reference Du, Li and Zhong19–Reference Du, Wang and Y21]. The water absorption of LCP is very low, only 0.04%, reducing the risk of relative dielectric constant and loss of tangential changes. In addition, LCP has significant chemical resistance, high-dimensional stability, and excellent mechanical strength, further improving its applicability in demanding applications in antenna technology. This quality makes it ideal for compact, high-performance devices and holds great promise in wearable applications. For the above reasons, LCP substrate material is chosen as the medium base in this paper.
This paper introduces a wearable antenna which offers six band-notched characteristics. The innovation points of the proposed antenna include [Reference Rao Devana, Kusuma Kumari and S1]: The compact antenna has six notched bands [Reference Z, P and Y2]. The antenna is flexible, making it suitable for applications on the human body [Reference Singh and Kalraiya3]. The slotted antenna has wider impedance bandwidth [Reference Lin, Lu and Wang4]. Using coplanar waveguide (CPW) feeding, the antenna can be used in microwave integrated circuits easily.
Section II specifies the flexible six notched-band antenna design process and its performance. Section III presents the antenna design followed by its results and discussion including S parameters, surface currents, far radiation pattern, peak gain, bending analysis, and on-body effects. Finally, Section V summarizes the work.
Antenna design
Antenna design process
The design evolution of the antenna is shown in Fig. 1, and the S-parameters during the design process are displayed in Fig. 2.
The design process of the antenna. (a) Antenna a, (b) Antenna b and (c) Antenna c.
The S11 of the Antenna a, Antenna b and Antenna c.
Firstly, Antenna a is the first design step, the antenna covers the entire ultra-wide band frequency range with a bandwidth of 2.52–12.3 GHz, and the antenna uses CPW feeding. In this antenna design, a circular patch with a radius of 5.7 mm is used, and slots are etched on both sides of the ground plane of the feed line, and the feed line size is gradually tapered to achieve better impedance matching characteristics.
Secondly, Antenna b is the second design step, the antenna with four band-notched characteristics is designed by etching four differently sized stepped impedance resonators (SCRs) on a circular radiation patch of the UWB antenna. Each SCR can generate a notch band, resulting in four band-notched characteristics. The SCRs are located at the center of the radiation patch, and the position and size of the gap and radius of each SCR can be adjusted to the generated relational notch band. The simulated results of Antenna b show that the bandwidth range with S11 <−10 dB is achieved from 2.51 GHz to 13.99 GHz. The notches of the Antenna b are located at 4.15–4.85 GHz, 5.08–5.54 GHz, 5.89–6.5 GHz, and 7.83–8.2 GHz.
Finally, Antenna c is the third design step, on the basis of the Antenna b with four band-notched characteristics, two L-shaped branches were added to each side of the ground plane, resulting in Antenna c with six band-notched characteristics. It can be easily seen that two additional notch bands are generated without interfering with the other four notch bands, and the modifications of the antenna structure are not needed. At this point, the simulated results of Antenna c show that the bandwidth range with S11 <−10 dB is from 2.43 GHz to 14.01 GHz. The notches of the Antenna c are located at 2.9–3.77 GHz, 4.14–4.9 GHz, 5.09–5.55 GHz, 5.86–6.46 GHz, 6.66–7.39 GHz, and 7.93-8.43 GHz.
Figure 3 illustrates the geometry of the ultra-wideband antenna featuring six band-notched characteristics. The antenna utilizes an LCP dielectric substrate with specific properties, including a relative dielectric constant of 2.9, a loss tangent (tan δ) of 0.002, a thickness of 0.1 mm, and a CPW feed. The antenna design comprises a circular patch as the primary radiating element, along with an enhanced coplanar ground structure. The optimized parameters obtained through the use of HFSS software optimization are presented in Table 1.
The geometry of the ultra-wideband antenna with six band-notched characteristics.
Optimized design parameters of the antenna
Parametric analysis of the notched frequency bands
By analyzing the parameters of each notched band, it is evident that effective control over the notched bands can be achieved by adjusting the length of the L-shaped stubs and the radius of the SCRs. The first notched band can be controlled by adjusting the length Ln2 of the longer L-shaped stub, as shown in Fig. 4(a). The second notched band can be controlled by adjusting the radius R4 of the SCR, as shown in Fig. 4(b). The third notched band is controlled by the radius R3 of the SCR, as shown in Fig. 4(c). The fourth notched band is managed by adjusting the radius R2 of the SCR, as shown in Fig. 4(d). The fifth notched band can be controlled by the length Ln1 of the shorter L-shaped stub, as shown in Fig. 4(e). The sixth notched band can be adjusted by varying the radius R1, as shown in Fig. 4(f). These figures demonstrate that each notched band can be individually controlled with minimal impact on the other notched bands.
Parametric analysis of the notched frequency bands (a) Ln2, (b) R4 , (c) R3 , (d) R2 , (e) Ln1 and (f) R1.
Results and discussions
Simulated and measured s-parameter
The performance of the proposed antenna was simulated using HFSS software, and the results were clearly displayed. Figure 5 shows the actual processing diagram of the antenna. Figure 6 also shows the reflection coefficient magnitudes (|S11|) of the ultra-wideband antenna, which has six band-notched characteristics. The measured working bandwidth range with S11 <−10 dB is from 2.7 GHz to 13.7 GHz, and the measured notches of the antenna are located at 3.1–3.75 GHz for Wimax, 4.14–4.7 GHz for ARN, 5–5.5 GHz for WLAN, 5.7–6.38 GHz for C-band, 6.8–7.5 GHz for X-band, and 7.75–8.7 GHz for ITU-8 GHz. Each notch exhibits a peak value greater than −5 dB, signifying the outstanding notch performance of the antenna. The measured S11 is almost identical to the simulated S11, with some differences due to manufacturing defects and the inability of the antenna testing equipment and the testing environment to reach ideal conditions during testing.
The geometry of the ultra-wideband antenna with six band-notched characteristics.
The S11 of the proposed UWB antenna with six band-notched characteristics.
The distribution of surface currents
Figure 7 shows the distribution of surface currents on the proposed antenna at 3.2 GHz, 4.6 GHz, 5.3 GHz, 6.2 GHz, 7 GHz and 8.1 GHz. In Fig. 7(a), it can be observed that the currents are predominantly distributed along the longer L-shaped stub. In Fig. 7(b), the currents are mainly focused around the SCR with a radius of R4. Similarly. In Fig. 7(c), the currents are mainly focused around the SCR with a radius of R3. In Fig. 7(d), the currents are primarily focused around the SCR with a radius of R2. In Fig. 7(e), the currents are mainly distributed along the shorter L-shaped stub, and in Fig. 7(f), the currents are mainly focused around the SCR with a radius of R1. The current distribution shows the successful achievement of non-radiation effects of the antenna at specific frequencies.
The distribution of surface currents on the antenna at (a) 3.2GHz, (b) 4.6GHz, (c) 5.3GHz, (d) 6.2GHz, (e) 7GHz, and (f) 8.1GHz.
Radiation pattern and peak gain analysis
For the designed UWB slot antenna with six band-notched characteristics, it is necessary to analyze its radiation pattern characteristics and peak gain. By selecting two representative non-notch band frequency points, 2.5 GHz and 5 GHz. we obtained the normalized radiation patterns in the E and H plane. Figure 8 presents the simulated and actual measured results of the radiation pattern. It is evident that at the frequencies of 2.5 GHz and 5 GHz. The antenna exhibits an “8” shape radiation pattern in the E-plane and omnidirectional radiation in the H-plane, indicating that the antenna is suitable for receiving and transmitting signals from any direction in the working frequency band.
The simulated and measured E-Plane and H-Plane radiation patterns. (a) 2.5GHz and (b) 5GHz.
In addition, the simulation and measurement realized gains of the antenna are given in Fig. 9. The realized gain of the antenna sharply decreases at the notch band frequencies, and most of the notch bands achieve negative gain values, reflecting the excellent band-notched characteristics of the antenna. In other operational frequency bands, the gain surpasses 0, and the maximum gain of the antenna exceeds 6.5dBi, demonstrating that the antenna can achieve six band-notched characteristics and has satisfactory radiation characteristics in the working frequency band.
The measured and simulated realized gain.
Bending analysis
In order to assess the flexibility of the antenna, we simulated its radiation characteristics while it was bent along the H-plane. The dielectric substrate utilized for the antenna is a flexible LCP material with a thickness of only 0.1 mm. In our simulation, we securely mounted the antenna on cylinders with radii of 30 mm and 50 mm, respectively, and plot the bent S11 curves under different curvature radii, as shown in Fig. 10. It can be found that under bending conditions, the antenna bandwidths of the two states all cover 2.7–11 GHz. When the antenna is fixed on a cylindrical surface with a radius of 50 mm, the degree of bending is relatively small, and at this time, the six notch bands can still be achieved, albeit with a certain degree of offset. When the antenna is fixed on a cylindrical surface with a radius of 30 mm, the degree of bending is relatively large, and at this time, The first and second notch bands are connected between 3 and 4 GHz, changing from six band-notched characteristics to five band-notched characteristics.
The S11 of the bending antenna. (a) Bending measurement setup and (b) the measured S11 of the antenna when flat and bend.
On-body effects
To investigate the characteristics of the antenna when close to the human body, we positioned the antenna on the arm, chest, and leg. The actual measured results of slot antenna on these body locations are depicted in Fig. 11. It is observed that when the antenna is closed to the human body, its bandwidth experiences a significant reduction, and the position of the notch band slightly shifts. Specifically, the first notch band moves towards lower frequencies. When the antenna is closed to the arm or the leg, it has all six complete notch bands. When the antenna is closed to the chest, the fifth and sixth notch bands are connected, so the measurement results are better on the arm and leg than on the chest.
The measured S11 of the antenna placed on human body.
Specific absorption rate validation
In the realm of wearable antenna applications, the quantitative assessment of the impact of antenna radiation energy on human tissues is typically conducted through Specific Absorption Rate (SAR) measurements. The evaluation of SAR values is paramount in determining whether the antenna poses any potential radiation risks to the human body.
In the simulation, the human body model is characterized by four distinct layers: skin, fat, muscle, and bone, each with specified thicknesses—1 mm for the skin, 5 mm for fat, 20 mm for muscle, and 14 mm for bone. Collectively, the human body model possesses a total thickness of 40 mm. The separation distance between the antenna and the human tissue model is set at 5 mm, with an input power of 0.1 W. Figure 12 displays the three-dimensional distribution of SAR for the proposed antenna. SAR values were simulated in 10 g of biological tissue at frequencies of 2.5 GHz and 5 GHz. At 2.5 GHz, the maximum SAR value is 1.48 W/kg, and at 5 GHz, the maximum SAR value is 0.96 W/kg. The findings indicate that the SAR values remain below the European standard of 2 W/kg per 10 g of tissue, adhering to established guidelines for radiation exposure.
The SAR distribution of the antenna positioned on the human tissue at (a) 2.5 GHz and (b) 5 GHz.
Comparison
Comparing the slot antenna with the literature referenced earlier, it can be observed for Table 2 that the slot antenna has more notch bands, smaller dimensions, wider bandwidth and higher gain. Importantly, this antenna is flexible and can be applied in the field of wearable devices.
Comparison of proposed work with other literature works
Conclusion
A flexible UWB antenna with six notched bands is proposed. The antenna employs a flexible LCP substrate, making it suitable for wearable devices. The six notched bands within the operating frequency range of 2.7–13.7 GHz are achieved through the integration of four SCRS and two symmetrical L-shaped branches. The antenna exhibits notches at 3.1–3.75 GHz, 4.14–4.7 GHz, 5–5.5 GHz, 5.7–6.38 GHz, 6.8–7.5 GHz, and 7.75–8.7 GHz, effectively suppressing interference in the WiMAX band, ARN band, WLAN downlink band, C-band uplink band, C-band/INSAT/super expansion band, and ITU-8 GHz band. The measured results confirm that the antenna successfully achieves six band-notched characteristics across its operating range and satisfactory radiation performance. Additionally, the antenna maintains robustness and flexibility under bending conditions, making it a promising candidate for wearable wireless communication systems.
Acknowledgements
The authors would like to thank the CETC Shanghai Microwave Communication Co., Ltd for providing measure facility.
Competing interests
All authors disclosed no relevant relationships.
Tianshi Wang was born in Heilongjiang Province, China in 1999. He received the B.S. degree from the Shanghai University of Electric Power in 2021. He is currently pursuing the M.S degree in College of Electronics and Information Engineering, Shanghai University of Electric Power. His research interests include UWB antenna with band-notched characteristics and flexible antenna.
Chengzhu Du was born in Haikou, Hainan Province, China. She received the B.S. degree from the Xidian University, M.S. degree from Nanjing University of Posts and Telecommunications and PhD degree from Shanghai University, in 1995, 2003, and 2012, respectively, all in electromagnetic wave and microwave technology. She is currently an associate Professor of Shanghai University of Electric Power. Her research interests include flexible antenna and textile antenna, multiband and wideband antennas, and MIMO technologies.
