Readers who open Robert Milder's Hawthorne's Habitations: A Literary Life in search of traditional biography will be disappointed. As Milder himself makes clear in the book's brief preface, Hawthorne's Habitations is a hybrid of sorts: “not a formal biography but more than a work of literary criticism, this is a book about a life led in and known primarily through written words – a literary life” (xi, original emphasis). While the book is structured by Hawthorne's residence in four different locales (Salem and Concord, MA; England; and Italy), Milder says comparatively little about specific life events. Under Milder's sensitive eye, rather, these physical habitations lead us into Hawthorne's “mental residence[s], region[s] of thought and sensibility” (ix). In reading Milder's book, in short, we spend more time in Hawthorne's mind – as mediated through his works – than we do in biographical episodes.
For Milder, that mind is one structured by an abiding “tension between the naturalist and the idealist, the realist and the romancer” (xi). In exploring this tension, Milder does not so much introduce us to a new Hawthorne as he does uncover Hawthorne's “masterplot” (45), a governing story that shapes everything he writes, from first to last, from notebooks to published fiction. Throughout the whole of his writing life, Milder argues, Hawthorne is pulled to the real and experiential; indeed, Hawthorne is for Milder an extraordinarily gifted (and in fact undervalued) observer of the actual. But Hawthorne is always troubled by a seemingly unresolvable worry: he fears that the naturalist point of view voids life of meaning, yet he is too much of a sceptic to rest secure in any kind of orthodox religious belief that would provide such meaning. A “religionist lacking the faith of religion” (11), Hawthorne thus turns to romance as his form of choice: “the moral and metaphysical idealizations of romance served Hawthorne instrumentally,” Milder writes, “as a refuge against the … horror of universal meaninglessness” (21). More specifically, Hawthorne sees romance as a medium in which he can explore sin – his “conduit to experiential meaning”: “Without the reality of sin,” Milder writes, “there was no transcendent dimension to human affairs” (13).
If it is in sin that Hawthorne finds some version of transcendent meaning, it is in Salem that Hawthorne finds sin. In Salem, Hawthorne wrote and published stories that establish his “signal theme”: “The development of the soul through sin and/or suffering” (45). Evidence of this theme, and its attendant literary modes (allegorical, dark, symbolic, interior) can be found in such early stories as “Young Goodman Brown,” “Roger Malvin's Burial,” and “The Minister's Black Veil”; but, Milder insists, we can even see the outlines of the theme in less obvious examples, in stories such as “Little Annie's Ramble” that have often been viewed in opposition to Hawthorne's darker tales.
Salem is the first “habitation” that Milder explores, and it is also the most enduring. Indeed, having found his “masterplot” there, Hawthorne will never actually leave, Milder asserts, despite many efforts to do so. Newly married and living in Concord, for example, Hawthorne nurtures the hope that marriage, fatherhood, and middle-class domesticity will liberate him from the introversion and sin-obsession of his Salem years. But though he apparently revels in the earthy and sensual dimensions of his Concord life, he is never, Milder suggests, able fully to divest himself of the fear that to embrace “the natural” is to embrace a domain “vacated of Providence, morality, and heaven” (64). He also harbors an abiding anxiety about the lure of sexuality – and in this regard, Milder's Hawthorne is a relatively familiar Hawthorne, a man drawn toward but conflicted about fleshly desires and the female bodies that incite them.
Essentially, Milder argues, Hawthorne is a “self-divided man … who senses from experience that naturalism may be the order of things but can neither live comfortably within its confines nor transcend them through religious belief” (24). While this division is captured most directly in the divergence between Hawthorne's Salem and Concord lives, it also stays with Hawthorne as he moves, with his family, to England, to Italy, and back to Concord again, and infuses virtually everything he writes. Thus, although he is drawn to the hearty materialism and earthy naturalism of English life and the “life of the senses” (242) he found in Italy, Hawthorne continues – even against the evidence that audience sensibilities had changed – to mine the vein of romance, for romance was Hawthorne's “instrument for shoring up his tottering faith that the universe was what it should be, a divinely appointed order, rather than the chaos it visibly seemed” (26). But what was for Hawthorne an undeniable impetus to romance is, in Milder's view, deeply unfortunate, for it left Hawthorne unable to carve out a writerly future in the domain of realist sketches. Without a clear sense of place in the changed landscape of wartime America, and unable to adapt to new literary circumstances, Hawthorne “seems to have acquiesced in, even welcomed death” (272). The Salem masterplot thus came to a perhaps expected, if still tragic, denouement.
Some readers may find Milder's masterplot overly schematic, even reductive. Fully trained on that plot, for example, Hawthorne's Habitations looks away from such matters as slavery, race, class and capitalism, industrialism, and same-sex desire that recent critics have located at the heart of Hawthorne's work. Yet as Milder traces out Hawthorne's inner divisions, he offers close readings that are rich, fine-textured, densely detailed, and commanding. Milder also attends to Hawthorne's interlude in England (a period often overlooked in the scholarship), draws our attention to the literary value of the notebooks, and demonstrates the worth of such largely neglected works as the late Our Old Home (1863), which Milder calls a “quiet masterpiece” (271). As we explore, along with Milder, Hawthorne's “habitations,” we might not find a new Hawthorne – but we will find a human Hawthorne, a man whose quest for stable meaning in a chaotic universe is as relevant today as it was 150 years ago.
