Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-7pwfn Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T13:35:41.590Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Passive bionic motion of a flexible film in the wake of a circular cylinder: chaos and periodicity, flow–structure interactions and energy evolution

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  10 May 2024

Fan Duan
Affiliation:
Key Laboratory of Fluid Mechanics, Ministry of Education, Beijing 100191, PR ChinaInstitute of Fluid Mechanics, Beijing University of Aeronautics and Astronautics, Beijing 100191, PR China
Jin-Jun Wang*
Affiliation:
Key Laboratory of Fluid Mechanics, Ministry of Education, Beijing 100191, PR ChinaInstitute of Fluid Mechanics, Beijing University of Aeronautics and Astronautics, Beijing 100191, PR China
*
†Email address for correspondence: jjwang@buaa.edu.cn

Abstract

The self-sustained interactions between a flexible film and periodic vortices epitomize the spirit of fish swimming and flag flapping in nature, involving intricate patterns of flow–structure coupling. Here, we comprehensively investigate the multiple coupling states of a film in the cylinder wake mainly with experiments, complemented by theoretical solutions and nonlinear dynamical analyses. Four regimes of film motion states are identified in the parameter space spanned by the reduced velocity and the length ratio. These regimes are (i) keeping stationary, (ii) deflection flutter, (iii) hybrid flutter and (iv) periodic large-amplitude flapping, each governed by a distinct coupling mechanism, involving regular and irregular Kármán vortices, local instability of the elongated shear layers and 2P mode vortex shedding. The film futtering in regimes (ii) and (iii) is substantiated to be chaotic and bears a resemblance to the ‘entraining state’ of fish behind an obstacle in the river. The periodic flapping in regime (iv) manifests itself in an amalgam of standing and travelling waves, and has intrinsic relations to the ‘Kármán gaiting’ of fish in periodic vortices. With the spatiotemporal reconstruction for the periodic flapping, we procure the energy distributions on the film, revealing the energy transfer processes between the film and the large-scale vortices. The findings unequivocally indicate that the flow–structure interaction during the energy-release stage of the film is more intense than that during the energy-extraction stage. Given the similarities, the mathematical and physical methods presented in this work are also applicable to the research on biological undulatory locomotion.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2024. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.Sketches of the experiment protocol. (a) Experiment set-up and definition for the Cartesian coordinate system. The origin is set at the centre of the midspan cross-section of the cylinder model, while the $x$, $y$ and $z$ axes align with the streamwise, vertical and spanwise directions, respectively. The film with a spanwise height of $b = 240$ mm is clamped behind the circular cylinder with a diameter of $D = 20$ mm, which covers the middle spanwise portion of the cylinder across $-6 < z/D < 6$. (bi) Cross-section of the experimental model. Here, the Lagrangian curvilinear coordinate $s$ is defined along the film length with the points of $s = 0$ and $s = L$ corresponding to the fixed leading edge and the free trailing edge, respectively. (bii) Magnified view to show details on the connection between the film and the circular cylinder. (c) Film with fabricated leading edge, which is attached to the cylinder by inserting the clamped leading edge into the slot on the cylinder, as illustrated in panel (bii).

Figure 1

Table 1.Aggregation of experiment cases and film parameters.

Figure 2

Figure 2.Motion states of the 0.1 mm thick film in the cylinder wake. (a) Trailing-edge amplitudes $\tilde {A}/D$ (left-hand vertical axis and triangular markers), self-similarity coefficients $\gamma ^\ast$ (right-hand vertical axis and square markers) and largest Lyapunov exponents $\lambda _1$ (top coordinate and circled plus markers) as functions of the non-dimensional film length $L/D$. For each regime separated by light-coloured blocks, sequences of instantaneous deformations are incorporated to show the representative motion patterns. (b) Phase trajectories of (i) trailing-edge point for $L/D = 1.0$, (ii) trailing-edge point for $L/D = 3.0$, (iii) trailing-edge point ($s/D=5$) and $s/D=3$ point for $L/D = 5.0$. Here, the vertical velocity $U_y{/U}_\infty$ and the displacement $y/D$ of the point are fivefold refined by modified Akima piecewise cubic interpolation to enhance the fineness of data and the accuracy of the phase trajectories (Akima 1970; Moler 2019). (c) Short-time fluctuations of the film motion in the $y$ direction with unit-amplitude rescaling $[y_{rms}]_t^\ast =[y_{{rms}}]_t/[y_{rms}]_t^{s=L}$ vary with time within 10 s, by which the self-similarity is revealed: (i) $L/D = 1.0$; (ii) $L/D = 3.0$; (iii) $L/D = 5.0$. (d) Cross-correlation coefficients, $c_r(t)={Corr}( \overline {[y_{rms}]_{t}^\ast },[y_{rms}]_t^\ast )$, as a function of time $t$ within 10 s: (i) $L/D = 1.0$; (ii) $L/D = 3.0$; (iii) $L/D = 5.0$. .

Figure 3

Figure 3.Results of linear stability analysis. (a) Stability boundaries of the film motion in the $S$–$U^\ast$ plane solved by (3.2)–(3.9), above which the perturbations undergo such an exponential growth that the film loses it stability. The green solid line shows the stability boundary with the linearized tangential stress $\tau _0^\ast$ considered, while the black dashed line is without the stress $\tau _0^\ast$. The diagonal shading between the two boundaries gives the diminution of the reduced velocity due to the tangential stress $\tau _0^\ast$. Here, $\tau _0^\ast \sim -2\times 10^{-3}$. Sequences of instantaneous deformations for the film of $L/D=0.5$ after instability are also incorporated in this panel. (b,c) (i) Finite time Lyapunov exponent (FTLE) fields calculated from the phase-averaged velocity fields (see Appendix B) (He et al.2016; Wang & Wang 2021a), and (ii) time-averaged vorticity fields superimposed with the time-averaged streamlines; (b) for $L/D=0.5$ and (c) for $L/D=1.0$.

Figure 4

Figure 4.Comparison of the flow field characteristics. Distributions of (a) the streamwise velocity fluctuations, $u_{rms}/U_\infty$, with the contour interval of $\pm 0.06$, (b) the vertical velocity fluctuations, $v_{rms}/U_\infty$, with the contour interval of $\pm 0.07$ and (c) the normalized instantaneous spanwise vorticity fields, $\omega _zD/U_\infty$, with the contour interval of $\pm 0.6$. Here, the vorticity fields are calculated using the velocity fields reconstructed by the spatial modes from the proper orthogonal decomposition (POD), which accounts for 85 % of the total energy (Qu et al.2019). (i) The plain cylinder; (ii) the cylinder with the film of $L/D=0.5$ and $h=0.1$ mm, the stationary state; (iii) the cylinder with the film of $L/D=0.5$ and $h=0.022$ mm, the flutter state; (iv) the cylinder with film of $L/D=1.0$ and $h=0.1$ mm, the flutter state. The bottom $x$-axis is normalized by cylinder diameter $D$ while the top $x$-axis by the vortex formation length $L_f$. The blue plus markers ‘$+$’ in (b) denote the location of the maximum $v_{rms}/U_\infty$.

Figure 5

Table 2.Representative statistical quantities of flow fields for the four cases in figure 4.

Figure 6

Figure 5.Influences of the short films on the typical characteristics of flow fields. (a) Profiles of $u_{rms}/U_\infty$ at several streamwise locations, which are normalized by the vortex formation length $L_f$. (b) Time histories of normalized spanwise vorticity, $\omega _z^*=\omega _zD/U_\infty$, at $\mathcal{L}(x=L_f,y=0)$ in 15 periods of vortex shedding ($T_0$), which are extracted from the POD reconstructed vorticity fields with 85 % total energy. Here, the bule circles highlight the data corresponding to the instantaneous vorticity fields shown in figure 4(c). (c) Power spectral densities (PSD) for the vorticity series at $\mathcal {L}(x=L_f,y=0)$. The grey shadings indicate the peak range determined by full width at tenth maximum. The subpanels (i), (ii), (iii) and (iv) in (b) and (c) correspond to the cases of the plain cylinder; the cylinder with film of $L/D=0.5$ and $h=0.5$ mm (stationary); the cylinder with film of $L/D=0.5$ and $h=0.022$ mm (flutter); the cylinder with film of $L/D=1.0$ and $h=0.1$ mm (flutter), respectively.

Figure 7

Figure 6.Extraction of the flection state and the deflection state during the $L/D=3.0$ film flutter based on the short-time fluctuation characteristics. (a) The normalized short-time fluctuations $[y_{rms}]_t^*$ of the film's vertical displacements. Example 1 for the deflection state and Example 2 for the flection state. (b) Variation of correlation coefficients $c_r(t)$ versus time $t$, which is calculated by correlating all the normalized short-time fluctuations $[y_{rms}]_t^*$ with the baseline $[y_{rms}]_0^*$ shown in panel (a). The light red region represents the film flutter dominated by flection, while the light green region represents the film flutter dominated by deflection. The red plus marker ‘$+$’ highlights the correlation coefficient for example 1 in panel (a), while the green cross marker ‘$\times$’ highlights the correlation coefficient for example 2 in panel (a).

Figure 8

Figure 7.Comparison of the velocity fluctuations during the deflection state and the flection state for $L/D=3.0$. (a,b) Distributions of streamwise velocity fluctuations, $u_{rms}/U_\infty$, associated with the deflection state and the flection state, respectively. (c,d) Distributions of vertical velocity fluctuations, $v_{rms}/U_\infty$, associated with the deflection state and the flection state, respectively, wherein the blue plus ‘+’ markers denote the locations of the global maximum $v_{rms\_max}/U_\infty$. The bottom $x$-coordinates for panels (a) to (d) are normalized by cylinder diameter $D$, while the top ones by the vortex formation length $L_f$. (e) Variation of the maximum $u_{rms}/U_\infty$ at each streamwise slice. The locations of the slice maximum $u_{rms}/U_\infty$ are signified by cyan cross markers in panels (a) and (b). (f) Profiles of the $u_{rms}/U_\infty$ for deflection state and the flection state at $x/L_f=1$. (g) Profiles of the $v_{rms}/U_\infty$ for deflection state and the flection state at the streamwise slice where the global maximum $v_{rms}/U_\infty$ is located, namely, $\mathcal {L}_x(v_{{rms\_max}})$.

Figure 9

Figure 8.The FTLE fields reveal the evolution of the LCS during the $L/D=3.0$ film's flection flutter in approximately one period of the vortex shedding (table 3). The time interval between two adjacent panels is $\Delta t=1/400$ s. The clockwise and anticlockwise vortices are marked by $V^\ominus$ and $V^\oplus$, respectively. The subpanel in (a) presents the time trace of the film's trailing edge, in which the six red points on the trace from left to right correspond to the film motion in panels (a) to (f), respectively. The time coordinate in the subpanel is normalized by the dominant period of the vortex shedding (table 3). The yellow dashed arrows in panel (d) schematically show the directions of force exerted by the large-scale vortices on the different positions of the film.

Figure 10

Figure 9.The FTLE fields reveal the evolution of the LCS during the $L/D=3.0$ film's deflection flutter in approximately one period of the flow field (refer to table 3). The time interval between two adjacent panels is $\Delta t=1/400$ s. The subpanel in (a) presents the time trace of the film's trailing edge, in which the six red points on the trace from left to right correspond to the film motion in panels (a) to (f), respectively.

Figure 11

Figure 10.Representative instantaneous spanwise vorticity fields, $\omega _z^*=\omega _zD/U_\infty$, for $L/D = 3.0$. (a) For flection state, corresponding to LCS in figure 8(c), at which the vortex $V^\ominus$ is formed and vortex $V^\oplus$ is just shed into the wake. (b) For deflection state, subpanels (i) and (ii) corresponding to LCS in figures 9(e) and 9(f), respectively. The contour interval for the vorticity fields is $\pm 0.8$.

Figure 12

Figure 11.Extraction of the flection state and the deflection state during the flutter of the $L/D=4.0$ film based on the short-time fluctuation characteristics. Captions for panels (a) and (b) are the same as those for figure 6(a) and 6(b), respectively.

Figure 13

Figure 12.Comparison of the velocity fluctuations of the deflection state and the flection state for the film of $L/D=4.0$. Captions for panels (a–g) are the same as those in figures 7(a) to 7(g) in a one-by-one manner.

Figure 14

Figure 13.The FTLE fields reveal the evolution of the large-scale LCS during the flection flutter of the film with $L/D=4.0$ in approximately one period of the flow field (refer to table 3). The time interval between two adjacent panels is $\Delta t=1/400$ s. Here $V_1^\oplus$ and $V_2^\oplus$ denote the anticlockwise vortices evolved from the shear layer on the lower side of the cylinder, while $V_1^\ominus$ and $V_2^\ominus$ denote the clockwise vortices evolved from the shear layer on the upper side of the cylinder. Panel (i) presents the time trace of the film's trailing edge, in which the eight red points on the trace from left to right correspond to the film motion in panels (a–h), respectively. The time coordinate in panel (i) is normalized by the dominant period of the vortex shedding (table 3). The yellow dashed arrows in panel (e) schematically show the directions of forces exerted by the large-scale vortices on the different positions of the film.

Figure 15

Figure 14.The FTLE fields reveal the evolution of the LCS during the deflection flutter of the film with $L/D=4.0$. The time interval between two adjacent panels is $\Delta t=1/400$ s. The dash–dotted boxes ${P_1}$ and ${P_2}$ highlight the approximately symmetric evolution of the two separated shear layers. The dashed rectangular boxes ${B_1}$ and ${B_2}$ highlight the local instability of the shear layers. Marker $V^\oplus$ denotes the large-scale anticlockwise vortex in the wake. (i) The time trace of the film's trailing edge, in which the eight red points on the trace from left to right correspond to the film motion in panels (a)–(h), respectively. In panel (a), the red pentagram marker at $\mathcal {L}(x/D=3,y/D=1)$ denotes the probe used to extract the streamwise velocity signal in the shear layer, while the purple triangle marker at $\mathcal {L}(x/D=4.67,y/D=0)$ denotes the probe used to extract the vertical velocity signal in the wake.

Figure 16

Figure 15.Representative instantaneous spanwise vorticity fields, $\omega _z^*=\omega _zD/U_\infty$, for the film of $L/D = 4.0$. (a–c) For flection state, corresponding to LCS in figures 13(b) to 13(d), respectively. Vortices $V_1^\oplus$, $V_1^\ominus$ and $V_2^\oplus$ are the same as those in figure 13, while vortices $V_s^\oplus$ and $V_s^\ominus$ are small-scale vortices. (d–f) For deflection state, corresponding to LCS in figures 14(d) to 14(f), respectively. Markers ${P_1}$, ${P_2}$, ${B_1}$, ${B_2}$ and $V^\oplus$ have same meaning as those in figure 14.

Figure 17

Figure 16.Frequency characteristics for the case of $L/D=4.0$. (a) Continuous wavelet transform of the streamwise velocity signal extracted from the shear layer at $\mathcal {L}(x/D=3,y/D=1)$, the location of the pentagram in figure 14(a). The time coordinate is normalized by the dominant period of the flow field (table 3). (b) The PSD of the vertical velocity signal extracted at $\mathcal {L}(x/D=4.67,y/D=0)$ in the wake, the location of the triangle in figure 14(a).

Figure 18

Figure 17.Kinematic analyses for the periodic flapping of the film with $L/D=5$. (a) Film flapping in approximately one cycle captured by long-exposure imaging with an exposure time of 1/30 s, where the film is illuminated by a double pulsed laser with a frequency 800 Hz and straddling time of $135\ \mathrm {\mu }\mathrm {s}$. (bi) Phase-averaged deformation of the film in one cycle. The curvature distributions for four typical phases are shown by vectors, and the figure-eight trajectory of the trailing edge by the dashed line. (bii) Spatiotemporal evolution of the curvature on the film in one phase-averaged flapping cycle. (c) Comparison of the first two POD modes of the film flapping in the $y$ direction and the modes of a cantilever beam solved by the Euler–Bernoulli theory (Piersol & Paez 2010). (di) Spatial amplitude of the first complex empirical orthogonal function (CEOF) mode, $\zeta (s)$, characterizes the envelope of the film flapping in $y$ direction. (dii) Sequence of the film flapping in the $y$–$s$ space in one cycle reveals the physical meaning of $\zeta (s)$. (diii) A comparison between the envelope of the film flapping (black solid line) and that of the Kármán gaiting of a trout (red dash–dotted line) (Akanyeti & Liao 2013b) in the range of $s/L = 0.5\sim 1$; here, unit-energy normalization is applied to both the envelopes. (ei) The temporal phase of the first CEOF mode, $\psi (t)$. (eii) Global PSD derived from the Fourier mode decomposition of the film flapping in the $y$ direction shows the dominant frequency $f_0 = 30.8$ Hz (Wang et al.2021). (fi) Spatial phase of the first CEOF mode, $\phi (s)$, with a linear fitting in the range of $s/D = 2.5\sim 5$ (goodness of fit $r^2 > 0.995$). (fii) A comparison between the spatial phase of the film flapping (black solid line) and that of the trout's Kármán gaiting (red dash–dotted line) (Akanyeti & Liao 2013b). In this subpanel, the light green shade represents the mean squared error given by Akanyeti & Liao (2013b). For comparability, the phase curves are rescaled with their maximum, namely, $\phi ^\ast =\phi /\phi _{max}$, and for the present data, $\phi _{max}$ is chosen as the maximum of the linear fitting in panel (fi).

Figure 19

Figure 18.The FTLE fields reveal the evolution of the LCS in one flapping cycle during the lock-in interaction between the $L/D=5.0$ film and the flow fields. The time interval between two adjacent panels is $\Delta t\approx 1/9T_0$, where the flapping period $T_0 = 3.25\times 10^{-2}$ s. In this figure, superscripts and subscripts are used to signify the vortex characteristics, where $V_C^\ominus$ denotes the clockwise vortex evolved from the shear layer of the upper side of the cylinder and $V_T^\oplus$ denotes the anticlockwise vortex evolved from the trailing-edge shear layer. The vortices $V_C^\ominus$ and $V_T^\oplus$ comprise the vortex pair in downstroke together. Likewise, the anticlockwise cylinder vortex $V_C^\oplus$ and the clockwise trailing-edge vortex $V_T^\ominus$ comprise the vortex pair in upstroke together. The vortex pair marked by the grey dashed circles in panels (a) and (b) are formed in the upstroke of the last period.

Figure 20

Figure 19.Characteristics of the $L/D = 5.0$ film flapping as a support for the motion reconstruction and energy solving. (ai) Global PSD for the film motion in the $x$ direction obtained by applying the Fourier mode decomposition to the motion (Wang & Wang 2021b), (aii) sequence of the film motion in the $x$–$s$ plane in one flapping period $T_0$ (here, $x^\prime =x-\bar {x}$). (b) The same as (a) but for the motion in the $y$ direction. (c) Second spatial derivatives of the Fourier coefficients $a_x^n$ and $b_x^n$ determined by the quintic smoothing spline for the reconstructed $x$-directional motion. (d) Second spatial derivatives of the Fourier coefficients $a_y^n$ and $b_y^n$ determined by the quintic smoothing spline for the reconstructed $y$-directional motion.

Figure 21

Figure 20.Phase trajectories of the film motion obtained from the motion reconstruction (see (3.13)). (a) For the motion of the points $s/D = 5$ and $s/D = 3$ in the $x$ direction, where the bottom horizontal axis is for $s/D = 5$ and the top one for $s/D = 3$, both of them of the same scale. (b) Phase portrait characterizes the $y$-directional motion of all the points on the film, where the curvilinear coordinate $s/D$ is represented by the gradient colour scale. The dash–dotted lines are isochrones, each of which indicates the phase distribution for the whole film at a certain moment. The moments $t_0 \sim t_8$ in panels (a) and (b) have a one-by-one correspondence to those in figure 18.

Figure 22

Figure 21.Energy density distributions on the film over one flapping period $T_{0}$. (a) Kinetic energy density in the $x$ direction, $e_{k\_x}$, with a contour interval of $1\ \mathrm {mJ}\ D^{-1}$. (b) Kinetic energy density in the $y$ direction, $e_{k\_y}$, with a contour interval of $5\ \mathrm {mJ}\ D^{-1}$. (c) Elastic potential energy density, $e_{b}$, with a contour interval of $0.1\ \mathrm {mJ}\ D^{-1}$. In panels (a–c), the cylinder diameter $D$ serves as the unit length for the energy density in order to match with the non-dimensional curvilinear coordinate $s/D$. The moments $t_0$ to $t_8$ correspond to those in figures 18 and 20 in a one-by-one manner.

Figure 23

Figure 22.Energy evolution. (ai) Variations of the kinetic energy $E_{k\_x}$ and $E_{k\_y}$ as well as the total mechanical energy ($E_{k\_x}+E_{k\_y}+E_b$) versus time $t$. (aii) Variation of the elastic potential energy $E_b$ versus time $t$. At the top of panel (a), the evolution periods of vortices in the flow field are depicted by different bars to expatiate the phase relation between the film energy and the dominant flow structures. The red bars with diagonal line denote the formation of the cylinder vortices, $V_C^\ominus$ and $V_C^\oplus$, after which the bars with diamond pattern denote the movement of the cylinder vortices against the film surface. The grey shadings denote the stage where both the cylinder vortices have direct interactions with the film. The green bars with diagonal dotted line denote the formation of the trailing-edge vortices, $V_T^\ominus$ and $V_T^\oplus$. The moments $t_0$ to $t_8$ correspond to those in figures 18, 20 and 21 in a one-by-one manner. (b) Instantaneous spanwise vorticity fields ($\omega _zD/U_\infty$) with the contour interval of $\pm 0.8$ at (i) moment $t_1$ and (ii) moment $t_5$, exactly corresponding to the LCS shown in figures 18(b) and 18(f), respectively. (c) Sequence of the film flapping and total energy evolution the in one energy period, viz., $0.5T_0$. For each frame, the area of the circular marker at the trailing edge is proportional to the total energy carried by the film. During the stage of energy extracting, the maximum projected distance swept by the film in the $y$ direction is $\Delta \hat {y} =3.77D$; then, the maximum frontal swept area is $\hat {S}_p=\Delta \hat {y}\times b$, where $b=240$ mm is the spanwise height of the film (see figure 1).

Figure 24

Figure 23.Diagram shows the variations of coupling states in the $U^*$–$L/D$ plane for the film in the wake of a circular cylinder. The light red region below boundaries I and II, light yellow region between boundaries I, II and III, light blue region between boundaries III and IV, and the light green region between above the boundaries IV represent the regimes of keeping stationary, deflection flutter, hybrid flutter and travelling-wave flapping, respectively. The region covered by diagonal lines denotes film motion approximately governed by linear instability (figure 3). The region superimposed by light grey shading indicate the transition from linear instability to vortex–film interaction, where the red arrow suggests the sharp decrease of the stability boundary in $U^*$–$L/D$ plane due to the influence of large-scale vortices. The dash–dotted line at $L/D=3.5$ denotes an estimated length limit for the steady extension of the separated shear layers. The boundary I is derived from the stability boundary in figure 3 in terms of the film with $h=0.45$ mm. The boundaries II, III, IV are approximately determined based on the critical points of state transitions, as exemplified by the points in the grey dashed circles. The critical points are initially interconnected using Bézier curves and then the Bézier curves are fitted to rational functions to gain the boundaries. Since the density of critical data points is insufficient, these frontiers only provide a rough estimation.

Figure 25

Figure 24.Average mutual information. (a) Variations of the average mutual information $I$ with the delay time $t_d$: (i) for $L/D=1$; (ii) for $L/D=3$; (iii) for $L/D=5$. Here, the delay time $t_d$ is scaled by the mean orbit period $\hat {T}$. We adopt the vortex-shedding period to approximate the mean orbit period of the case, namely, $\hat {T}\sim T_0$ (table 3). The optimal delay time $t_d^0$ for the phase-space reconstruction is determined by the first local minimum on the $I$–$t_d$ curve. (b) Probability histograms of $p_i$, $p_j$ and $p_{ij}$ at the optimal time delay $t_d^0$: (i) for $L/D =1$; (ii) for $L/D=3$; (iii) for $L/D=5$.

Figure 26

Table 3.The dominant frequency and period of the vortex shedding for each case.

Figure 27

Figure 25.Percentage of FNN versus embedding dimensions $m$ for (a) $L/D=1.0$, (b) $L/D=3.0$ and (c) $L/D=5.0$. The time delays used for evaluate the FNN percentage are given by the AMI results in figure 24. At $m=4$, the FNN percentages for the three cases are all smaller than 1 % and plateaus occur in the figure, meaning the appropriate dimension for embedding should be $m\geq 4$.

Figure 28

Figure 26.Projections of the reconstructed four-dimensional attractors to the three-dimensional spaces of (i) $y_1-y_2-y_3$, (ii) $y_1-y_2-y_4$, (iii) $y_1-y_3-y_4$ and (iv) $y_2-y_3-y_4$ as well as the two-dimensional planes (the light grey projections): (a) for $L/D=1.0$; (b) for $L/D=3.0$; (c) for $L/D=5.0$. The attractor is reconstructed by embedding the vertical motion of the trailing edge to the four-dimensional space with the optimal time delay $t_d^0$, where $y_1=y(t)$, $y_2=y(t+t_d^0)$, $y_3=y(t{+2t}_d^0)$ and $y_4=y(t{+3t}_d^0)$. The optimal time delay $t_d^0$ is determined by the corresponding AMI in figure 25. For clarity, only evolution of the attractor within 1 s is shown in this figure.

Figure 29

Figure 27.Evolution of the largest Lyapunov exponent $\lambda _1$ with the number of iterations $M$, (a) for $L/D=1$, (b) for $L/D=3$ and (c) for $L/D=5$. The subpanel incorporated in figure (a) shows details of $\lambda _1$ within the range of $1000 \le M \le 2000$. The evolution of $\lambda _1$ is fitted as a function of the number of iterations $M$ in the power-law form, $\lambda _1=\alpha M^\beta +c$. The constant $c$ in the fitted result gives the final estimated $\lambda _1$, which represents the limit of convergence of $\lambda _1$. For $L/D=1\ {\rm and}\ 5$, the estimated $\lambda _1$ are 0.455 and 0.017, respectively. For $L/D=3$, due to the oscillations at the beginning stage of the iteration, the evolution of $\lambda _1$ with $M$ is fitted to two power-law functions, and then the estimated $\lambda _1$ is given by the average of the two corresponding constants as 0.7315.

Figure 30

Figure 28.Solving the second derivative for the Fourier coefficient $a_x^0$ in equation (3.13). (ai) The original data of $a_x^0$ and its optimal quintic smoothing spline fitting; (aii) magnified view in $s/D=1\sim 1.2$ to show the details of data; (aiii) difference between the original data and the smoothing spline fitting, where $\delta =a_x^0-\tilde {f}$, which approximately represents the noise in $a_x^0$. (b) Roughness, $R^3$, versus error tolerance, $\varXi$, of quintic smoothing splines solved by iterating Reinsch's tolerance method with a successive value of $\varXi$. Here, each point on the curve corresponds to a specific quintic smoothing spline. The optimal error tolerance for the fitting of $a_x^0(s)$ is given by the kink on the $R^3$–$\varXi$ curve as $\varXi _0=5.56\times 10^{-12}$. (ci) Comparison of the derivatives solved by the quintic smoothing spline fitting and local least squares; (cii) magnified view in $s/D=1.8\sim 2.4$ to show the details. Here, the local least square is solved with the window size of 21 points and the polynomial order of five.

Figure 31

Figure 29.Solving the second derivative for the Fourier coefficient $a_y^1$ in (3.13). The captions for this figure are the same as those for figure 28 in a one-to-one correspondence. The magnified view, panel (aii), exhibits the details of data in $s/D=1.6\sim 1.8$. The optimal error tolerance for the fitting of $a_y^1(s)$ is given by the kink on the $R^3-\varXi$ curve as $\varXi _0=5.49\times 10^{-9}$ in (b). In panel (c), due to the relatively large noise in $a_y^1$, its second derivative solved by local least squares is completely divergent, whereas the optimal quintic smoothing spline fitting outputs a satisfactory second derivative of $a_y^1$.

Figure 32

Figure 30.Transition of the motion states from hybrid flutter to the periodic flapping for the 0.1 mm thick film with $L/D=5.0$. Panels (a) and (b) depict the hybrid flutter of the film at $U_\infty =5\ \text {m s}^{-1}$ together, where (a) is for deflection state and (b) is for flection state. (c) shows the periodic flapping of the film at $U_\infty =6\ \text {m s}^{-1}$.

Supplementary material: File

Duan and Wang supplementary movie 1

(Left) Small-amplitude deflection flutter of the film with the length of L/D=1.0 in 2 seconds (about 180 periods of vortex shedding), corresponding to regime (ii) in figure 1(a) of the main text. (Right) Phase trajectory of the trailing edge, which evolves simultaneously with the film flutter shown in the left panel. The frame rate of the movie is 15 frames per second and the physical time interval between two successive frames is 1/800 s; thus, the flutter is slowed down by about 50x in this movie. The color of the instantaneous deformation of the film in the left panel AND the instantaneous phase point in the right panel is changed abiding by the color scale, which visually represents the physical time variation. For clarity, in the right panel, we just retain the color of the phase trajectory within about 12 periods of the vortex shedding, beyond which the phase trajectory is prescribed to be gray.
Download Duan and Wang supplementary movie 1(File)
File 10.1 MB
Supplementary material: File

Duan and Wang supplementary movie 2

(Left) Small-amplitude hybrid flutter of the film with the length of L/D=3.0 in 2 seconds (about 150 periods of vortex shedding), corresponding to regime (iii) in figure 1(a) of the main text. (Right) Phase trajectory of the trailing edge, which evolves simultaneously with the film flutter shown in the left panel. Other details of this movie are the same as those described in the caption for movie 1.
Download Duan and Wang supplementary movie 2(File)
File 6.3 MB
Supplementary material: File

Duan and Wang supplementary movie 3

(Left) Large-amplitude periodic flapping of the film with the length of L/D=5.0 in 2 seconds (about 60 periods of vortex shedding), corresponding to regime (iv) in figure 1(a) of the main text. (Right) Phase trajectories of the trailing edge (point of s/D=5, the red point) and the point of s/D=3 (the blue point), which evolve simultaneously with the film flapping shown in the left panel. Other details of this movie are the same as those described in the caption for movie 1.
Download Duan and Wang supplementary movie 3(File)
File 10.3 MB
Supplementary material: File

Duan and Wang supplementary movie 4

The complete coupling interactions between the film with L/D=5.0 and the flow field are shown by the evolution of the Lagrangian coherent structures (LCSs) over 10 vortex shedding periods. The LCSs are extracted by finite time Lyapunov exponent. The frame rate of this movie is 10 frames per second and the physical time interval between two successive frames is 1/800 s; thus, the interactions between the film and the flow field are slowed down by 80x in this movie.
Download Duan and Wang supplementary movie 4(File)
File 7.7 MB