Two book-length studies of recent Australian theatre, Hilary Glow's Power Plays: Australian Theatre and the Public Agenda and Joanne Tompkins's Unsettling Space: Contestations in Contemporary Australian Theatre explore the complicated relationship between the theatre and the social practices and processes of making (and unmaking) national identity. Both authors examine an impressive range of Australian plays and theatrical productions, and the result is a dynamic dialogue between the history of Australian theatre and recent productions. As one would expect, there are many points of intersection. Both Glow and Tompkins undertake rigorous primary analyses of recent examples of writing for the theatre by Katherine Thomson, Stephen Sewell, Ben Ellis, Wesley Enoch, and Andrew Bovell. However, while Glow restricts her discussion primarily to the writings of eight playwrights whom she interviewed and who, she claims, write “political theatre … within the conventional and normative modes of naturalistic theatre [and] [w]ithin the framework of mainstream theatre” (1, 8), Tompkins's examination of spatiality on the contemporary Australian stage isn't limited by imprecise terms of definition.
Glow's terms, as she defines them, are highly debatable, as is the “fit” between the conceptual scaffolding of her argument and the plays set for analysis. It is a worthy exercise to explore “theatre as a place for public political engagement” (2) and, concomitantly, the playwright “operating within the domain of the public intellectual, using the theatre as their platform” (15). This should not, however, be confused with a study of ‘political theatre,’ which is not adequately defined or historicized here (in Australian or international terms). Unfortunately the two subjects are conflated. The result is that the book struggles to make a convincing argument, and the plays under analysis risk strangulation.
Glow argues that the past decade of Australian theatre is remarkable because a diverse group of playwrights (not the next “Next Wave,” 8) promoted a “critical” and “caring” nationalism against a “paranoid” (15; Glow actually uses Ghassan Hage's term here) and “defensive” one. According to Glow, theatre provided a “countervailing voice … [i]n a political environment dominated by hegemonic nationalist discourses of ‘one people, one nation’” (16). This may be partly true. At the same time, it goes only a very little way toward explaining how Australian playwriting in the decade 1996–2006 activated social, cultural, and political engagements beyond the discursively critical to which Glow's approach, focused on the analysis of written and published texts, is largely restricted. Discussion of a putative ‘political theatre’ is further circumscribed by the scene of analysis: “mainstream theatre” (7). It is a very “odd place to look for a theatre of social change” (6), and I'm afraid that Glow's arguments (enfranchised audiences, national reach) fail to convince me otherwise. Several of the plays under examination (7 Stages of Grieving, Who's Afraid of the Working Class, Wonderlands, and Last Cab to Darwin) emerged from the small-medium theatre sector which Glow seems to gloss over as “diminished” (4) by an “economic rationalist approach to arts policy and funding” (3) instituted in the 1990s by the Keating Labour government. The shift to a cultural- and creative-industries model has impacted on the mainstream as well in terms of increasing commercialization, hence a trickle rather than a (new next) wave of playwrights produced on Australian mainstages. How, then, can Glow attend to a “political theatre …[w]ithin the framework of mainstream theatre” (1, 8) without, at the same time, considering the commodification of the political in that increasingly competitive and commercialized scene?
The main casualty of Glow's somewhat woolly thesis is the work, by which I mean the material, intellectual, and emotional workings of the playwrights who produced the plays under analysis. In the end, all that labor is at risk of being reduced to the “principled critical action[s]” of telling countertruths to political lies, “facilitating debate,” and testing “the conventionalising of cultural beliefs, assumptions and expectations” (12). These are not insignificant artistic and social aims, yet I am moved to question whether recent Australian playwriting, “political” or otherwise, can be contained within such an instrumentalist frame. It would be a great shame if Australian playwriting in the period 1996–2006 was seen as worthy of analysis primarily because it served the function of “meditat[ing] on the way the [Howard government] used [its] power” (3). There is a more vibrant love of life in these plays (and others not in this selection) than this, and, indeed, some of the plays under analysis (such as Enoch and Mailman's 7 Stages of Grieving, Melbourne Workers Theatre's Who's Afraid of the Working Class, Bovell's Holy Day, and Ellis's Falling Petals) appear to bristle against the narrow analysis. The undoing of the argument is there in the writings discussed, which tap into the amoral, excessive, explicit, and irreverent in performance (historical and contemporary, Australian and international) and which cleverly deploy allegory (and other symbolic modes) in addition to naturalism. The plays in this book are read too literally for my liking, and there is too much of an analytical focus on a dry version of textual ‘deconstruction’ (see, for instance, 91).
As a general introduction to a selection of recent Australian plays and playwrights and the publishing house Currency Press (which published the plays given primary focus in the book), Power Plays: Australian Theatre and the Public Agenda is a satisfactory starting point. It deals with some powerful and moving Australian theatre written at a particular moment in the nation's recent history, but it isn't an exemplary work of theatre history or performance-studies scholarship. The author completed her doctoral thesis, from which the book emerged, in Australian studies and, though she is a working dramaturge, the drama takes a back seat to polemic.
In Unsettling Space: Contestations in Contemporary Australian Theatre, Joanne Tompkins, in stark contrast, has an excellent grasp of the complicated relationship between theatre and its social context and how theatre's potential as a radical site hinges on the opposition between the “real” and the “not real” that constitutes it. According to Tompkins, “a rigid mimetic reflection is boring in its reproduction of life off stage; it also limits the potential for the audience to read the details of performance as signifying (historically and politically) beyond the narrative of a particular production” (7). Thus, underpinning Tompkins's historicizing analysis of Australian plays and live performances since approximately 1979 (“the era before that being well-rehearsed critically,” 17) is Elin Diamond's notion of “unmaking” mimesis: “the truth-modelling that produces self-identical subjects in coherent plots gives way utterly to the pleasure and significance of contradiction—and of contradictions that, at any given moment, are emerging but unseeable” (Diamond in Tompkins, 7). With this theoretical foundation in place Tompkins undertakes an original examination of the ways in which “representational space performed in Australian theatre … contests conventional Australian history and culture” (5) and, at the same time, “stages alternative means of managing the production of space in a spatially unstable nation” (5).
The notion of “contested space” is key to Tompkins's thesis, and it is carefully conceptualized in reference to Una Chaudhuri's notion of “polytopicalism”—the “combination and layering, one on top of another, of many different places, many distinct orders of spatiality” (Chaudhuri in Tompkins, 4)—which prevents limiting the analysis to oppositional criticism. In fact, Tompkins suggests that recent Australian theatre actively participates in a dynamic struggle over many different and competing perceptions of the spatiality that constitutes Australian cultural identity. Whereas for Glow, Australian theatre promotes a critical nationalism counter to a more anxious, fearful, and defensive version, for Tompkins, Australian theatre produces deeply unsettling emotions that resonate with the profoundly unstable history of settlement in Australia, the violent seizure of territory being a major cause of cultural anxiety. Whereas Glow would contain Australian theatre as “antidote” (16), counteracting and reducing certain emotions, in Tompkins's account theatre sets off a depth charge whose repercussions resonate far beyond the bounds of the space–time of a single production, cultural formation, or historical period. In other words, Australian theatre isn't contained as rational cultural critique but regains its potential as a dangerous or radical social (spatial and embodied) site.
Tompkins's introduction defines, very precisely, her key terms of analysis. Two of these that she deploys throughout the book to analyze specific contestations of spatiality in Australian theatre are “the uncanny” and “methexis” (8, 13). The uncanny is a variation of Freud's concept developed in response to the Australian context by Gelder and Jacobs. It refers to the metaphysical relationship between Indigenous Australians and the land, and non-Indigenous Australians' more mercantile claims to ownership and possession of that same land. In an uncanny Australia, neither dispossession nor possession is ever fully accomplished, and this fact remains very much on the surface of everyday life, generating multiple spatial anxieties. The term methexis (which has its origins in the work of Plato and Aristotle) is taken from Paul Carter's work, where it relates to Aboriginal custodianship of country. Carter uses the term to promote a nonrepresentational relationship to the landscape, a material and participatory mode of being in and making our place in the world. At first, both terms seem a little unwieldy. The uncanny is difficult to wrestle away from Freudian psychoanalysis, and methexis is just awkward. I wonder whether, instead of methexis, “nonrepresentational practices” defined through cultural geography would do just as well? Both terms do, however, closely relate to the foundation stones of Tompkins's theory—”unmaking mimesis” and “polytopicalism”—and are deployed consistently in later chapters on “Monuments,” “Contamination” and “The Borders of Identity.” In a short while, I became much more familiar with the exploration of “methektically inflected and uncannily influenced activations of theatrical landscape” (19) and, in fact, very much valued the reading of that landscape in a manner that did not “reinscribe a singular, foreign, mimetic linearity” (11).
Tompkins's book is an exemplary piece of theatre scholarship. She hopes the book will facilitate more “contextualized studies of theatre” (18), and I, too, hope that the spatial theories and analytic tools elaborated in this book and applied extensively to recent Australian theatre will be applied further and to other theatres elsewhere.
