Türkiye, positioned at the convergence of the African, Arabian, and Eurasian tectonic plates, is highly susceptible to earthquakes.Reference AKAR 1 , Reference Ersoy and Koçak 2 The 1999 Marmara and 2023 Kahramanmaraş earthquakes are 2 significant seismic events that have tested and shaped Türkiye’s disaster management strategies. This study aims to provide a comparative analysis of these earthquakes within the framework of the Sendai Framework for Disaster Risk Reduction, highlighting the evolution in disaster preparedness and response.
Methods
This study employs a mixed-methods approach to compare the impacts and disaster management responses to the 1999 Marmara and 2023 Kahramanmaraş earthquakes. Quantitative data were collected from official reports on seismic characteristics, casualties, economic losses, and response statistics. Qualitative data were sourced from disaster management documents, focusing on legislative and policy changes pre- and post-1999.
Results
Quantitative Analysis
The 1999 Marmara earthquakes, with magnitudes of Mw=7.4 and 7.2, resulted in 17 199 buildings collapsed, 44 000 injuries, and 18 243 fatalities. In contrast, the 2023 Kahramanmaraş earthquakes, with magnitudes of Mw=7.7 and 7.6 (Figure 1), led to 37 984 buildings collapsed, 115 353 injuries, and 50 784 fatalities in Türkiye. The response to the Kahramanmaraş earthquakes was significantly more robust, with 35 250 national and 11 488 international SAR personnel, compared to 4755 national and 3622 international personnel for Marmara. The scale of response included 146 806 health personnel and 845 185 tents distributed for Kahramanmaraş, compared to 7507 health personnel and 113 924 tents for Marmara (Tables 1 and 2).
Location of 2023 Kahramanmaraş and 1999 Marmara (Kocaeli and Düzce) centred earthquakes.

Distribution of some features of the Kahramanmaraş and Marmara earthquakes.

Relationship between the impact and response capacities of Kahramanmaraş and Marmara earthquakes.

Qualitative Analysis
Post-1999, Türkiye underwent significant reforms in disaster management. The establishment of the Disaster and Emergency Management Presidency (AFAD) in 2009 marked a shift towards an integrated and centralized approach. This transformation aligns with the Sendai Framework’s priorities, emphasizing risk reduction and resilience building. Despite advancements, challenges persist in local-level coordination, civil-military integration, and engagement of the private sector and academia.
Discussion
The 1999 Marmara earthquakes exposed severe shortcomings in Türkiye’s disaster management system, which was then fragmented and reactive. The significant casualties and economic losses prompted a comprehensive overhaul of the disaster management framework. The establishment of AFAD centralized disaster management, allowing for more efficient coordination and resource allocation during crises.Reference Ergünay 3
The 2023 Kahramanmaraş earthquakes provided a stark contrast in terms of preparedness and response. The response efforts were more organized and extensive, reflecting the lessons learned from the 1999 events and subsequent reforms.Reference Orhan 4 The distribution of resources and the mobilization of national and international aid were swift and efficient, underscoring the progress made in disaster response capabilities.
However, the analysis also reveals persistent gaps. Local-level coordination remains a critical issue, as centralized control can lead to bottlenecks and delays in localized response efforts. Enhancing the capacity of local governments and ensuring clear roles and responsibilities for all stakeholders, including the military, private sector, and civil society, are crucial for further improving disaster preparedness and response.
Investment in infrastructure resilience has been a key focus post-1999, with significant efforts directed towards earthquake-resistant construction practices. However, the devastation witnessed in the 2023 earthquakes indicates that more needs to be done in terms of enforcing building codes and ensuring the retrofitting of existing structures. The importance of community-based disaster risk reduction cannot be overstated. Public awareness campaigns and community training programs are essential to build a culture of preparedness and resilience at the grassroots level.
Conclusion
The comparative analysis of the 1999 Marmara and 2023 Kahramanmaraş earthquakes highlights significant advancements in Türkiye’s disaster management strategies, aligned with the Sendai Framework. The shift from a reactive to a proactive approach has improved preparedness and response capabilities. Nevertheless, addressing gaps in local-level coordination, civil-military integration, and infrastructure resilience remains imperative.
To further enhance disaster preparedness and resilience, Türkiye must focus on:
-
- Strengthening local governance capabilities and ensuring effective decentralization of disaster management.
-
- Engaging the private sector and academia in disaster risk reduction efforts.
-
- Investing in continuous public education and community-based training programs.
-
- Enforcing stringent building codes and retrofitting vulnerable structures.
-
- Leveraging advanced technologies and data analytics for real-time decision-making and risk communication.
By continuing to refine its disaster management framework and addressing these areas, Türkiye can serve as a model for other earthquake-prone regions, demonstrating the importance of integrating comprehensive disaster risk reduction strategies into national and local governance.
Acknowledgements
We would like to express our gratitude to the Turkish Red Crescent Society for their collaboration in this study. We extend our special thanks to the President, Prof. Dr. Fatma Meriç Yılmaz, and the DG of Disaster Management, Assoc. Prof. Dr. Kurtuluş Açıksarı, for their valuable support. Additionally, we sincerely appreciate the contributions of Assoc. Prof. Dr. Cüneyt Çalışkan and Prof. Dr. Handan Ankaralı for their assistance with statistical analyses.
Author contribution
Hüseyin Koçak: Background research/literature review, research design; Kerem Kınık: data collection, data analysis, figures, manuscript writing and editing, article submission, and corresponding author.
Competing interests
The authors declare none.
