Yaron Friedman's book marks an important step forward in the academic study of the ʿAlawi (Nusayri) sect of Syria and of the historical development of Shiʿism in general. Building on an already important body of Western scholarship on ʿAlawism and Shiʿism, the author has drawn on a number of original, apparently authentic ʿAlawi treatises recently published in Lebanon to assemble a broad picture of the ʿAlawi belief system and its early dissemination. In this sense, he has achieved his goal of providing a comprehensive new synthesis to replace René Dussaud's seminal Histoire et religion des Nossairis, published in 1900.
The first part of the book deals with the historical development of the Nusayri sect, from its origins in the ghulāt (extremist) Shiʿi milieu of medieval Baghdad to its spread throughout Iraq and finally to Syria through missionary activities. The author shows that rather than being dismissed as heretics, figures such as Muhammad ibn Nusayr and Husayn ibn Hamdan al-Khasibi were part of the mystical elite of the time and continued to be cited as authorities in the Imami tradition as well; it is only through the occultation of the Twelfth Imam and their claim of the Imam's divinity that their Sufi-like brotherhood became marginalized by what would become mainstream Shiʿism. The support of secular powers such as the Namiri tribe and the Hamdanid and Buyid dynasties allowed the ‘Alawis to propagate their teaching among the rural population as far as western Syria and Lebanon; of particular interest is Friedman's discussion of the Harran cell as the last to have exercised authority over the whole community in Syria and Iraq. The study's chronology ends around the 14th century, after the takeover of leadership in Syria by the emir Makzun al-Sinjari, the increasing division of ʿAlawi society along tribal lines, and the ʿAlawis’ difficult situation under Mamluk rule.
The greater part of the study concerns the Nusayri/ʿAlawi religion per se, beginning with its foundation in neoplatonic philosophy, its gnostic spin on Shiʿism, and its allegorical interpretation of Islam's standard texts and legal tradition. Much of this is already well known, and it is not always clear how Friedman's discussion supersedes or nuances that of earlier authors as far as Nusayri cosmology, the conception of history, or religious observances are concerned. However, he has rendered an important service in providing the most comprehensive and systematic overview of the ʿAlawi belief system to date—among the most valuable aspects of the study is an annex containing a detailed analysis of the authorship and reception history of some sixty ghulāt and Nusayri treatises—which highlights the different variations and discrepancies between some of the traditions and opens the way to a closer intertextual analysis of the writings that have been passed down. One of the more original discussions concerns the concept of docetic sacrifice, whereby “extremist” Shiʿa could abandon taqiyya (the dissimulation of one's beliefs) and proclaim the divinity of the Imam in order to incur condemnation and martyrdom, or at least the outward appearance of martyrdom, to the noninitiated.
Beyond the excellent presentation of Nusayri thought, however, Friedman's discussion of the community's history raises several methodological problems. He accepts as fact that the Nusayris, like the Druze and other minority groups, “took refuge” in the mountains of western Syria because they were systematically persecuted by Sunni Muslim states. Yet as Kamal Salibi has shown in the case of Lebanon, there were actually very few documented instances of such persecution, the notion of a “mountain refuge” being deployed mainly in modern times to construct a sense of group identity. Friedman relies on chronicle accounts of a 1317 punitive campaign, Sultan Baybars’ brief attempt to build mosques in the region, and Ibn Taymiyya's famous fatwa against the Nusayris to illustrate the Mamluks’ “extreme” policy toward heterodox sects (p. 62), which then leads him to inscribe the sect's history into “the general process of Muslim radicalization in the late medieval period” (p. 223). Things continued in the same vein under the Ottomans, but as “there are no reliable sources concerning the situation of the Nusayris between the fifteenth and the nineteenth centuries” (by which he presumably means religious texts) this period remains obscure (p. 199). In fact, sources that might have allowed for a more differentiated picture do exist, most notably, local biographical collections such as those published in ʿAli ʿAbbas Harfush, al-Maghmurun al-Qudama fi Jibal al-Ladhiqiyya (Damascus: Dar al-Yanabi‘, 1996) and Dib ʿAli Hasan, A'lam min al-Madhhab al-Jaʿfari “al-ʿAlawi” (Beirut: Dar al-Sahil li-l-Turath, 1997–2000). This material invites caution—as do the ʿAlawi treatises Friedman prefers to rely on—but by providing glimpses into the sect's regional distribution, internal disputes, poetic tradition, cult of shrine veneration, relations with Ismaʿili neighbors, and contacts with Mamluk and other state authorities, it suggests that ʿAlawi history should perhaps not exclusively be summed up in terms of theology and persecution.
These reservations do not detract from Friedman's scholarship on the Nusayri religion, and it is certainly legitimate to concentrate on its origins and medieval development, except that he does situate his study as focused on the religion, history, and identity “of the leading minority in Syria.” Given the diversity of political views among Syrian ʿAlawis (including an important number of political prisoners and other critics of the current regime), it is an open debate whether they can collectively be called “the leading group” in the country; what is certain is that the venerable esoteric traditions and initiatory brotherhood of Nusayrism traced by Friedman were never as historically marginalized as they have become in the modern era of rural development, Arab nationalism, and Baʿth party mobilization. In treating the question of “identity,” the author might have at least made token reference to the contributions of Hanna Batatu, Nikolaos van Dam, Patrick Seale, Eyal Zisser, and others regarding the rise of minority groups in republican Syria (rather than follow the likes of Daniel Pipes regarding the ʿAlawi “capture of power”), but what he really means by identity is the mix of neoplatonic, Christian, Jewish, Zoroastrian, and Shiʿi “influences” that can or cannot be discerned in Nusayrism. And this, we are told, is important because “it is possible to talk today about a Shiʿi–ʿAlawi–Sunni triangle as a prominent political axis [sic], involving struggles and negotiations between many countries in the Middle East” (p. 175) and with reference especially to Iran, “knowing that the Ghulat come from the same source as the Imamiyya and share some mutual beliefs and the same history . . . they can serve as useful political allies if needed” (p. 186).
Friedman's detachment from the realities of Syrian society and politics is evidenced by a number of factual mistakes as well: the coastal mountain range is not known today as Jabal “Ansa(y)riyya” (pp. 42, 191), and in fact the term is never encountered in older Arabic or Ottoman texts. The 1982 Hama massacre did not intensify the Muslim Brotherhood's campaign against ʿAlawi figures (p. 237) but rather put an end to it. The leading Twelver Shiʿi scholar in postwar Syria was Muhsin (not Muhammad) al-Amin (pp. 17, 28), and to characterize Hashim ʿUthman, a native of Latakia and sometime collaborator of the French Near East Institute, as typical of Lebanese (as opposed to Syrian) scholars and “against Western research of the sect” (p. 236) is incorrect.
The great merit of Friedman's book is that it is among the first pieces of scholarship to systematically explain and resituate Nusayrism within an Islamic field; a more serious engagement with the modern Arabic (not to mention the Turkish) literature, which he dismisses too easily as apologetic or as taqiyya, would have helped illuminate the question of ʿAlawi self-representation and identity today. In sum, this remains an extremely interesting book that will no doubt become a standard reference on the Nusayri/ʿAlawi religion. At the same time, it also makes clear the limits of the philological approach in explaining the role and status of certain sectarian groups or the logic of political alliances in the Middle East.
