Recent years have witnessed a boom in scholarship dedicated to the decline, fall and/or transformation of the late Roman world. This book, which is a revision of the author's University of Southampton dissertation, focuses on the changing uses of urban space in the city of Rome from roughly the fourth through sixth centuries a.d. Johnson uses ceramic evidence as a measure of changing use patterns in urban space. He focuses in particular on data for imported amphorae, gathered from sites across the city of Rome, though chiefly in the centro storico. Ambitiously, J. proposes marshalling this archaeological data in order to craft a more holistic approach to this historical period. Rather than an economic history or straightforward reinterpretation of the statistical datasets from published contexts, J. uses Geographic Information Systems (GIS) to analyse how and where discarded containers were deposited with respect to the emporium district and key monuments.
The book is organized into nine chapters and four appendices. After a very brief introduction, the next six chapters (chs 2–7) treat a range of topics that emphasize a historiographical approach, which allows J. to frame how his own interest in contemporary spatial theory and method pushes the available evidence in a new direction. Although this approach is critical to contextualizing the project, the breadth of topics covered leads this discussion to be uneven and, at times, superficial. In ch. 3, for example, J. offers a broad assessment of the archaeological evidence concerning Rome's food supply, specifically the rôle of oil amphorae. J. devotes most of the chapter (38–43) to discussing the ostraca from the Ilôt de l'Amirauté in Carthage — a summary derived almost exclusively from J. T. Peña's article in Carthage Papers (1998). Next he offers only very brief sections on the archaeological evidence from shipwrecks and storage centres. Similarly, in ch. 6, J. provides the reader with a brief historiography of amphora studies that goes back to Heinrich Dressel and CIL 15, but he omits the important work of Stephanie Martin-Kilcher at Augst (1987–1994). While arguably less significant in the larger historiography on pottery studies, this is a major lacuna for someone interested in Baetican oil amphorae, since Martin-Kilcher foregrounds the thorny issues surrounding these amphorae, namely the Dressel 23/Keay XIII. Coupling this chapter with the amphora typologies encompassed in Appendix A, there are additional concerns revealed in terms of pottery expertise. For example, J. includes distinct entries given to the Dressel 20 and the Ostia I (which are, in fact, the same). Similarly, his illustration of amphora types (Appendix B) includes the Baetican Dressel 20, but not the Dressel 23.
On the other hand, J. seems more at home with utilizing GIS techniques in tandem with ceramic data in order to model economic change. His forays into this approach are the strength of this book. Although his use of GIS is contextualized at points in the previous chapters, it is the focus of the final two chapters (chs 8–9) — which account for only about one-quarter of the whole text. These chapters integrate pottery evidence with GIS in order to interpret the changing patterns of the late antique urban landscape of Rome. Here, J. is at his most authoritative. He discusses the relationship between the sites of investigation and the Emporium river district (148–50), residential areas (151–3) and monumental sites such as churches (153–8). Through these key sites, he explores how the disposal of waste reveals continuity and change in use (or perceived use) of space.
J. observes that as the central distribution node centered on the riverine emporium breaks down, it is replaced by a series of distributive nodes (150). While this may reflect the breakdown of the state system providing food for the masses, J. seeks to correct the assumption that ecclesiastical involvement filled this void. He cites the evidence of spatial analysis, which does not place any ecclesiastical sites near those waste deposits in the centro storico. J. is correct to point out that the accumulation of waste deposits in the city centre is more indicative of new priorities for the city and its administrators, though perhaps his analysis misses the mark on the complexities in the situation. Although J. relies on the archaeological evidence as a ‘means of accessing socio-political decision-making processes and planning decisions’ (164), his argument would have been stronger if contextualized with some textual evidence. Material evidence also counters this spatial approach through, for example, the presence of Christograms or menorah on amphorae (e.g., in the Schola Praeconum excavations), a fact that clearly attests to some sort of non-secular involvement in the food industry. In this regard, I think J. under-appreciates the nature of the early Christian participation in Rome's food provision systems, which was quite prominent by the time of Pope Gregory the Great (a.d. 590–604).
Overall, J.'s book applies an innovative methodology that utilizes the growing datasets from excavations in the heart of the Urbs in order to think about the use of space in late antique Rome. The model presented has great potential, though it could have benefited from further revision following the dissertation. Since both GIS analysis and pottery analysis become more sophisticated as greater datasets become available, it will be particularly interesting to see how this technique can be adapted in the future. Such a technique surely holds promise in our ongoing quest to understand the nuances and complexities of the transitional economy of late antique Rome.
